My current employer is documented: it calculates your pro-rated fraction at each grade level for the bonus period two deal with promotions and then divides by 2 (bonus is paid out in two payments per year) and then multiplies grade level * company performance * employee performance. Any employee can calculate exactly how their manager ranked their performance. They can complain (or leave). With one weird exception people's grade levels are visible to others which means their bonus target is visible. For some people, 100% of their details (everything: base, etc.) are sometimes known to anyone who is interested (this applies to me).
(I should note that I don't think the compensation is transparent at VP level and above and know from experience there are tons of shenanigans there.)
When I worked for companies that did not document the bonus methodology, it was appalling. Bonuses were for glory hounds and friends of management. Terrible. A lot of employees didn't even know bonuses were paid.
I think the same issues exist for compensation (equity and base as well as special packages or retention bonuses) that exist for bonuses. It would be interesting to see if you could meaningfully execute a company with total transparency but I don't think it would survive contact with reality.
I think you can. There are some companies that do it already and places like military and Congress (they fully publish salaries) are transparent without falling apart. Secrecy around salaries is just a tool for employers to keep salaries low.
https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2014/09/how-did...
More public salaries: https://publicpay.ca.gov/Reports/Explore.aspx
It's doable.
In the private sector, salaries have more to do with subjective criteria like "how much do I think this person is worth" or "will this person go looking for other jobs if I only pay x."
Envy is not as much of an issue when people in the same role all make the exact same amount. It is an issue when pay is set by the will of a manager/HR person whose perception of things differs wildly from the employee's perception (regardless of whose perception is more correct). That being said, paying people by perceived performance, for all its flaws, is still better than rigidly paying someone based on what the sign on their desk says, with no consideration of how well they actually do their job.
someone else mentioned employers would have to be fair - yes, but that would not address the problem that 33% of your employees are crazy and/or delusional.
Entire countries manage it. Sweden, Finland and Norway publish all income tax returns.
Each year they announce how much, by percent, the bonus pool will be funded. And as long as I've worked there the bonus pool has been funded at >100%. The company is very fiscally responsible and they do everything in their power to meet their targets.
There are 4 categories of performance and if you meet the top two, you're guaranteed 100%. The policy for how much bonus % you receive is in the employee handbook. So your bonus is: (your base bonus percentage) * (performance percentage) * (bonus pool funding percentage) * (base salary). The only way you can get screwed is if you're tagged as underperforming. I've only known one person who's to ever receive that tag, and he was definitely underperforming.
That’s the only thing that makes sense. Asian economies learned this a while ago —but it leads to seasonal departures (after bonus distribution).
But yeah much easier to say bonuses will be reduced than to say salaries will get cut during lean times.
* though they do seem to get a lot of one offs...
It's a lot more cumbersome, and will create a lot more friction and problems.
The key reason there's even a distinction between salary and bonus is that a salary is guaranteed as long as you work there, while the bonus is not.
I am pretty sure it was deliberate, a way of cutting way back without having to give severance or make the news.
Doesn't sound like that "excuse" is working for them.
> I am pretty sure it was deliberate, a way of cutting way back without having to give severance or make the news.
It's the absolute worst way of doing layoffs. As you observed, the people walking out are the best performers who have great options elsewhere. Guess who stays?
Adverse selection in action.
As an employee, if you're given the choice between salary increase and bonus, the salary increase is worth way more in the long run.
> a move that gives them more flexibility to dial back that compensation if the economy turns sour.
To add further, though salary cuts can be done by companies (this may vary across geographies), it's usually a little more cumbersome and also sends a different message to employees. It's a lot easier to put in vacation caps (thus chopping off the ability to use the provided compensation completely) or not pay a bonus. While bad for morale, at least some employees may not consider these moves as a loss from the status quo. That's why different kinds of variable pay schemes is very attractive for employers so that they have several knobs to control.
As far as I'm concerned, employees should consider their base salary, benefits and some expected bonus as their fixed compensation so that they can better understand if the company is just skimming money and not rewarding their work because top executives want the bonuses for themselves (even when the situation looks like it wouldn't hurt to give some additional compensation). This behavior is quite common in many companies, and is probably one of the reasons why the CEO to average employee compensation has become increasingly skewed over time and is getting worse.
On the other hand, given a choice, most employees would choose a salary increase (continuous increase) over an unpredictable and one off bonus or any other benefit that can be easily cut.