Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by solutionyogi on Monday October 18, 2010 @12:08PM
(#1803996)
I didn't know this, thank you for this very useful information.
If you have a signature set up in Gmail, whenever you compose a new email, Gmail will insert "-- \n" in the textarea just before the signature. It used to annoy me to no end as I could not find the '--' in my original signature. Now I know better. Thank you for helping out a geek with an OCD.
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by eiji on Monday October 18, 2010 @08:26AM
(#1803158)
In Germany you are required by law to have a massive signature in your email, if it is part of a "commercial correspondence".
Now the problem is to define "commercial correspondence". When are you talking to a friend or a coworker, inhouse or another company, but there are already poeple, trying to make money in Germany, to rip of firms for emails without signature, that somehow ended up in the "foodchain".
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by nas on Monday October 18, 2010 @06:44PM
(#1805459)
I do some work for a company has appends a ~140 word privacy statement to every message (without a sig marker, of course). It includes the phrase "return the original to us
by courier collect". sigh
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by thristian on Monday October 18, 2010 @05:52AM
(#1802828)
Back in the day on Usenet, civilised people never used a .signature longer than 4 lines, and often two of those were some form of ASCII-art divider. It's good to see that etiquette lives on, at least somewhere.
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by DLWormwood on Monday October 18, 2010 @08:53AM
(#1803237)
Yes, but when I read that article, I thought, “That .sig is nothing." Some of the stuff I’ve seen and heard about during my USENET days could bring you to tears. (Like the “Kibo Warlord” .sig mentioned here, for example.)
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by leif on Monday October 18, 2010 @12:46PM
(#1804167)
> This blank region of empty space is a hollow void that adds lines to the
> length of this .signature's physical size.
>
> I cant think of anything more to add!
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by gaius on Monday October 18, 2010 @07:18AM
(#1803000)
Even worse are the fancy graphical "please think of the environment before printing" logos - a few billion of them is some real watts of power & cooling in the datacentre...
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by hvs on Monday October 18, 2010 @10:29AM
(#1803600)
Ironically, I once printed an email with one of those on it (I actually needed to) and that stupid graphic logo is what caused it to print on two pages (otherwise it would only have been one page).
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by IgorPartola on Monday October 18, 2010 @08:15AM
(#1803125)
At one point I did a back of the envelope calculation and it came out that 25 e-mails are roughly equivalent to 1 sheet of printed paper. My context was whether to send out a mass e-mail or to put up a few posters around the place. I guess a few posters would be better for the environment in some cases.
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by IgorPartola on Monday October 18, 2010 @11:33AM
(#1803849)
I remember that I took into account the amount of storage and the hard drive capacity and the power consumption, etc.
Here's a new calculation: assume your e-mail server has user/server ratio of 1000/1. Assume the server uses 500 watts power (server + UPS + cooling + lighting). Assume each user has 10,000 e-mails stored on this server.
We get 500W/1000 users/10,000 emails per user = 0.00005 Watts/email.
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by davnola on Monday October 18, 2010 @12:30PM
(#1804101)
You're out by a factor of a 10^4. You forgot to divide by 1000 to get KW from W, and you accidentally scaled everything up by 10, too. Still, the correct figure is meaningless too.
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by sophacles on Monday October 18, 2010 @03:01PM
(#1804669)
I cannot trust your declaration of meaningless, since you seem to think that KW somehow matters to his calculation. There is no term that is originally in KW (thus requiring conversion) nor is there any term which he presents in terms of W which is usually presented in terms of KW (thus having a hidden error).
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by pornel on Monday October 18, 2010 @10:51AM
(#1803684)
I retaliate with this:
> By accepting this e-mail you agree, on behalf of your employer, to release me from all obligations and waivers arising from any and all NON-NEGOTIATED agreements, licenses, terms-of-service, shrinkwrap, clickwrap, browsewrap, confidentiality, non-disclosure, non-compete and acceptable use policies (”BOGUS AGREEMENTS”) that I have entered into with your employer, its partners, licensors, agents and assigns, in perpetuity, without prejudice to my ongoing rights and privileges. You further represent that you have the authority to release me from any BOGUS AGREEMENTS on behalf of your employer.
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by gvb on Monday October 18, 2010 @12:04PM
(#1803983)
OK, I have to tell a war story.
Many years ago (it was on a VAX system), Someone In Authority decided that we needed a "legal" disclaimer tacked onto all of our emails. The system administrator put this into the VAX mail system. Grrrrr!
I noticed that the script the sysadmin used was clever enough to not add a second disclaimer if one was already present in the email. OK, he must be doing a check, but I also noticed that it wasn't an exact check, because it still worked if the disclaimer got line wrapped differently (IIRC).
A bunch of emails to myself later, I had determined what the keywords were and put a disclaimer in my .sig that had those keywords. It was half the length and, IMHO, made more sense than the original.
P.S. To the best of my knowledge, that quasi legal disclaimer never saved the company from any lawsuit or legal expense, but it cost them 4 hours of my time, plus a lot of other engineers' time as they groused about it in the hall.
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by verdant on Monday October 18, 2010 @02:59PM
(#1804660)
My signature is company mandated, was done by our marketing department (along with all email signatures in our company) and includes 6 lines of contact information, an image of the company logo, and then a disclaimer paragraph (which only gets attached to external email). I don't know how prevalent this is, but many people may (like myself) have no control over the content of their signatures.
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by tokenadult on Monday October 18, 2010 @09:37AM
(#1803413)
I have a workaround for this. My sig is three lines, of which I often omit one on the fly as I send emails:
1) My full name and email user name
2) One organizational affiliation (deleted as needed)
3) Another organizational affiliation (deleted as needed)
For some emails I write for the organization in line 2 on its internal email list, I add a standard disclaimer in one line in place of the organization mentioned in line 3.
If I'm writing a personal email to a person who for business or personal reasons may need to contact me again, then I paste in the BODY of the email a text file of a few lines that gives my full name, postal address in standard format, and telephone numbers (land line and mobile), and also repeats my email address. That reduces the number of emails I get from people who would just be looking for my phone number (for example, from other parents whose children are on the same soccer team as my children, or from new business clients).
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by drats on Monday October 18, 2010 @02:03PM
(#1804460)
After reddit and HN I am horrified at even the useless stuff slashdot crams into their comment system but going to php forums of any kind is just another dimension of crazy: multiple animated gifs, the specifications of the machine the person is writing on. Small wonder stackoverflow-like Q/A sites are eating their lunch.
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by epochwolf on Monday October 18, 2010 @08:05AM
(#1803103)
I'm guilty of this... This the signature I'm using.
Thanks,
---
Firstname Lastname
My enterprisey title.
Name of the Company I Work For.
555 Some Rd. | City and, ST ZZZIP-CODE
Work Phone: 555-555-5555
Cell Phone: 555-555-5555
Email: [email protected]
I wish I could reduce the length of my signature but at least it's on the small side compared to the majority of the non-spam emails I run across in the customer support mailing list.
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by tallanvor on Monday October 18, 2010 @09:47AM
(#1803456)
Mine looks like this:
Name | Company | Group | Title | desk phone | mobile | group web site.
Don't ask me why the Title comes after the company and group, but it was somebody's bright idea. At least it's only 1 line, maybe 2 if it gets wrapped for some reason.
Of course, they're trying to add a crapload more lines, but I've been resisting it, and will until it's "do it or be fired".
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by adw on Monday October 18, 2010 @02:58PM
(#1804658)
I was on Usenet enough early enough to get the four-lines religion, and that's enough to get six different ways to contact me in.
(I've elided bits here, not because it's any type of secret - I'm not exactly hard to find - but rather because you know some robot's going to crawl this sooner or later. Seriously: skype spam?!)
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by Natsu on Monday October 18, 2010 @05:38PM
(#1805272)
Why put your email address in the .sig for your email? Don't they already have that, given that they got mail from you?
Or is it meant for the case when someone forwards it 8 times and your email is snipped or abbreviated out?
I usually sign with one or two lines, maximum. Sometimes I don't sign it at all. And it's not a .sig, I type it in every time and I snip out all the rubbish from anything I'm replying to or forwarding (which often includes overly long sigs).
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by gaius on Monday October 18, 2010 @11:35AM
(#1803857)
Heh, one time the company sent round a template signature that we all had to use, and everyone cut and pasted it without reading. So we all had the job title Top Brand Chief.
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by IgorPartola on Monday October 18, 2010 @08:17AM
(#1803131)
My former employer has in their guidelines that, in addition to the 10 or so line signature, we needed to attach the department's graphical logo to every e-mail... Can this be considered the signature whale?
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by joezydeco on Monday October 18, 2010 @08:33AM
(#1803185)
Half of my company has the "logo in signature" thing and it drives me nuts to no end. Now EVERY email has an attachment to it. I can't tell which emails have important files and which ones are just 200 copies of the company logo in a long thread.
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by joezydeco on Monday October 18, 2010 @10:22AM
(#1803576)
I'm on gApps and use the web interface a lot. I'll have to look through that stuff. Thanks.
{edit} Nothing there. Great. You know what, signature and signature processing in gMail sucks. Why can't the web interface know I'm mailing someone in the same organization and NOT include the signature? Why can't it skip the legal block that my company requires if it's already in the email thread?
Let's put the self-driving priuses on hold for a while and get some real functionality in there, Google!
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by slug on Monday October 18, 2010 @10:45AM
(#1803652)
"And you’re being a conservationist this way. Our precious digital resources will be preserved. Countless bits will be saved. This is one small step for a sustainable Internet."
The author should take a look at the header that come attached to each email message, with its dozens of lines: From,To, Date, Delivery, DKIM, DomainKey, Spam status/score/etc , MIME, Reply-To, Subject, Encoding, etc.
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by lkijuhygtfd on Monday October 18, 2010 @09:51AM
(#1803468)
Then the recipient would have to first agree that storing the ino about this 'message being confidential' on a 3rd party website was accpetable - you would have to have click through EULAs on each email and make them different depending on the jurisdiction of the recipient.
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by limmeau on Monday October 18, 2010 @09:37AM
(#1803412)
You mean, like a homepage?
But seriously: I can understand people use URL shorteners to twitter ephemeral links, and pastebin for syntax-colored code copy&paste. But special-purpose hosting for something slowly-changing like contact information?
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by liedra on Monday October 18, 2010 @09:39AM
(#1803423)
No, please no. Then it registers as an attachment and then I can't tell which email you sent me has that very important attachment at a quick glance. Keep it short, sweet, and in 4 lines please.
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by pbhjpbhj on Monday October 18, 2010 @03:42PM
(#1804854)
Again with the downvotes, did I detract from the conversation? If you disagree say so (and preferably why) or upvote such a disagreement.
>I can't tell which email you sent me has that very important attachment
If it's from me then the subject will say "$important-attachment-subject" and the priority will he set to high (but not highest unless you're going to lose money or there is a risk of injury to persons or properties by a delayed response).
Seriously I'd have thought that people would like a vcard that can save them 10 mins inputting data and instead be imported into an address-book with a simple click.
Admittedly I hadn't realised that it got labelled as an attachment (but it seems obvious it should now). But then ...
Oi, I just tested with Thunderbird and vcards (and signature images) are not labelled as attachments. So, are you sure it does in your MUA?
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by liedra on Monday October 18, 2010 @05:58PM
(#1805327)
Yes, I am sure, or I wouldn't have mentioned it. Not everyone uses Thunderbird. (I use Mail.app for OS X and roundcube webmail. Both display them as attachments.)
tbh, I don't pay attention to priority ever, since the only people who use it when they email me are spammers.
So the moral is: not everyone uses the same client as you, and not everyone uses email the same way as you. To piss off the least number of people, go for a lowest common denominator thing. This is also why I always use plain text email.
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday October 19, 2010 @02:42PM
(#1808223)
Curiousity - I used links2 for a while, it's like lynx with images and some minimal js support.
Anyhow, I find images in email incredibly useful - it makes it an extra couple of steps for a lot of things if one has to upload or serve an image and the recipient then has to follow a link to get images.
What area of work are you in? Not big on branding?
I'll have to get some time with Mail.app, does it make no distinction between inline images and attachments either? How about encoded images that are inlined - do they show as attachments too?
I do know that OSX handles vcards very well so I'm kinda surprised it treats them as straight attachments but still don't think that matters so much.
Re:Stop the Signature File Insanity
by liedra on Saturday October 23, 2010 @07:42PM
(#1824671)
Sorry, only just got back to comments today. I'm in academia, so yes, not big on branding. The only attachments I like to receive are papers, calls for papers, agendas, student work, stuff like that. These tend to be important and can get lost in the pile if every email comes with an attachment.
Mail.app handles any attachments as attachments (even inline ones). If images are linked to as part of HTML email it will display them (but not by default due to spam tracking -- you have to click a button to display them), and not count them as attachments though.
http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc3676#section-4.3
If you have a signature set up in Gmail, whenever you compose a new email, Gmail will insert "-- \n" in the textarea just before the signature. It used to annoy me to no end as I could not find the '--' in my original signature. Now I know better. Thank you for helping out a geek with an OCD.
Now the problem is to define "commercial correspondence". When are you talking to a friend or a coworker, inhouse or another company, but there are already poeple, trying to make money in Germany, to rip of firms for emails without signature, that somehow ended up in the "foodchain".
Here's a new calculation: assume your e-mail server has user/server ratio of 1000/1. Assume the server uses 500 watts power (server + UPS + cooling + lighting). Assume each user has 10,000 e-mails stored on this server.
We get 500W/1000 users/10,000 emails per user = 0.00005 Watts/email.
0.00005 Watts/email * 365 * 24 = 0.438 W*hours/email.
Small but significant over your 10,000 emails.
[edit]: fixed my glaring mistakes. That's what happens when you rush.
http://www.birdhouse.org/etc/kibosig.txt
Suppose I want to serve him a writ?
> By accepting this e-mail you agree, on behalf of your employer, to release me from all obligations and waivers arising from any and all NON-NEGOTIATED agreements, licenses, terms-of-service, shrinkwrap, clickwrap, browsewrap, confidentiality, non-disclosure, non-compete and acceptable use policies (”BOGUS AGREEMENTS”) that I have entered into with your employer, its partners, licensors, agents and assigns, in perpetuity, without prejudice to my ongoing rights and privileges. You further represent that you have the authority to release me from any BOGUS AGREEMENTS on behalf of your employer.
And this is even better:
http://www.andrews-and-arnold.ltd.uk/inboundemailterms.html
Many years ago (it was on a VAX system), Someone In Authority decided that we needed a "legal" disclaimer tacked onto all of our emails. The system administrator put this into the VAX mail system. Grrrrr!
I noticed that the script the sysadmin used was clever enough to not add a second disclaimer if one was already present in the email. OK, he must be doing a check, but I also noticed that it wasn't an exact check, because it still worked if the disclaimer got line wrapped differently (IIRC).
A bunch of emails to myself later, I had determined what the keywords were and put a disclaimer in my .sig that had those keywords. It was half the length and, IMHO, made more sense than the original.
P.S. To the best of my knowledge, that quasi legal disclaimer never saved the company from any lawsuit or legal expense, but it cost them 4 hours of my time, plus a lot of other engineers' time as they groused about it in the hall.
For some emails I write for the organization in line 2 on its internal email list, I add a standard disclaimer in one line in place of the organization mentioned in line 3.
If I'm writing a personal email to a person who for business or personal reasons may need to contact me again, then I paste in the BODY of the email a text file of a few lines that gives my full name, postal address in standard format, and telephone numbers (land line and mobile), and also repeats my email address. That reduces the number of emails I get from people who would just be looking for my phone number (for example, from other parents whose children are on the same soccer team as my children, or from new business clients).
Name | Company | Group | Title | desk phone | mobile | group web site.
Don't ask me why the Title comes after the company and group, but it was somebody's bright idea. At least it's only 1 line, maybe 2 if it gets wrapped for some reason.
Of course, they're trying to add a crapload more lines, but I've been resisting it, and will until it's "do it or be fired".
(I've elided bits here, not because it's any type of secret - I'm not exactly hard to find - but rather because you know some robot's going to crawl this sooner or later. Seriously: skype spam?!)
Or is it meant for the case when someone forwards it 8 times and your email is snipped or abbreviated out?
I usually sign with one or two lines, maximum. Sometimes I don't sign it at all. And it's not a .sig, I type it in every time and I snip out all the rubbish from anything I'm replying to or forwarding (which often includes overly long sigs).
> I wish I could reduce the length of my signature
Company mandated?
{edit} Nothing there. Great. You know what, signature and signature processing in gMail sucks. Why can't the web interface know I'm mailing someone in the same organization and NOT include the signature? Why can't it skip the legal block that my company requires if it's already in the email thread?
Let's put the self-driving priuses on hold for a while and get some real functionality in there, Google!
The author should take a look at the header that come attached to each email message, with its dozens of lines: From,To, Date, Delivery, DKIM, DomainKey, Spam status/score/etc , MIME, Reply-To, Subject, Encoding, etc.
This is basically the reason for the existence of signatures..
I happen to use this one, for example: http://myonepage.com
But seriously: I can understand people use URL shorteners to twitter ephemeral links, and pastebin for syntax-colored code copy&paste. But special-purpose hosting for something slowly-changing like contact information?
Doesn't bother me at all, and I get annoyed when contact information I need is not listed.
>I can't tell which email you sent me has that very important attachment
If it's from me then the subject will say "$important-attachment-subject" and the priority will he set to high (but not highest unless you're going to lose money or there is a risk of injury to persons or properties by a delayed response).
Seriously I'd have thought that people would like a vcard that can save them 10 mins inputting data and instead be imported into an address-book with a simple click.
Admittedly I hadn't realised that it got labelled as an attachment (but it seems obvious it should now). But then ...
Oi, I just tested with Thunderbird and vcards (and signature images) are not labelled as attachments. So, are you sure it does in your MUA?
tbh, I don't pay attention to priority ever, since the only people who use it when they email me are spammers.
So the moral is: not everyone uses the same client as you, and not everyone uses email the same way as you. To piss off the least number of people, go for a lowest common denominator thing. This is also why I always use plain text email.
Anyhow, I find images in email incredibly useful - it makes it an extra couple of steps for a lot of things if one has to upload or serve an image and the recipient then has to follow a link to get images.
What area of work are you in? Not big on branding?
I'll have to get some time with Mail.app, does it make no distinction between inline images and attachments either? How about encoded images that are inlined - do they show as attachments too?
I do know that OSX handles vcards very well so I'm kinda surprised it treats them as straight attachments but still don't think that matters so much.
Mail.app handles any attachments as attachments (even inline ones). If images are linked to as part of HTML email it will display them (but not by default due to spam tracking -- you have to click a button to display them), and not count them as attachments though.