Re:Should Kids Be Paid to Do Well in School?
by jessriedel on Monday October 18, 2010 @02:43AM
(#1802594)
This is exactly the kind of conventional wisdom that needs to be actually tested, rather than assumed.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
exactly, reading through the article, the researcher got a lot of negative feedback (death threats) throughout the course. He wasn't ever saying we necessarily should be providing financial incentives, but he was asking if they work or not before automatically deciding against them.
it reminds me of an article I read about some organization doing scientific studies on charity. I wish I had the link handy.
There was once instance where people would charge people in 3rd world countries a nominal fee for HIV medications, thinking that the compliance in taking the medications would increase if you assigned some non-zero value to it. they did a formal study and found that it was less effective overall than just giving away the medicine.
Re:Should Kids Be Paid to Do Well in School?
by sliverstorm on Monday October 18, 2010 @04:01AM
(#1802686)
Yes, you're probably right. I'm just always stumped by the part where you can't try a dry-run in educational theory- you actually have to try it out, and you run the risk of screwing up a kid's education.
Re:Should Kids Be Paid to Do Well in School?
by jessriedel on Monday October 18, 2010 @05:13AM
(#1802782)
Seems easier than the situation in medicine. I have fewer moral qualms about testing experimental educational techniques on students than I do about testing experimental medicine on patients, especially if the students (or the students' parents) are compensated by an amount that make them willing subjects.