Although automatic watches in the price range of an Apple Watch - $300-500 - can be pretty durable, their service costs are high enough to justify replacing the damn thing with a new watch once that time rolls around in 5-10 years.
(Tangent: folks in the watch community are “particular” about the watches they purchase. In 2018 quartz is out of style, even though they run longer and resist shock more than automatic watches. In my mind, OP traded one trendy watch - the Apple Watch - for another watch trend.)
I eventually bought one and I wear it every single day. Things I do with it:
1. Most important feature is notifications from iMessage, WhatsApp, SMS and a small number of apps that I want notifications from (e.g. British Airways app telling me which gate to go to). On occasion I reply using the watch.
2. Meeting reminders. I go to a lot of meetings. Knowing when they are coming up and where they are is super useful.
3. Activity. I like the gentle push to make me walk a bit more.
4. Timers. Use these often when cooking or making tea.
I have an original Apple Watch. Not sure the Series 4 is compelling for me, but the health features are what will drive me to buy a new watch at some point.
If you do use a smartphone, then a smart watch is quite close to the tracking part (except for some additional data collection about heart rate that you may consider invasive).
>and mesh bracelets look very 1980s to me.
You know you can get different bands. I have a leather band--admittedly way too expensive--but it's very nice leather and is very comfortable.
So I went out and bought a few nice automatic watches, and I’ve been incredibly happy since. Each of my watches tells time, each looks good, and each will still be running years after every smart watch sold in 2016 is powered off.
This particular Apple watch is IMHO too big, and mesh bracelets look very 1980s to me.