News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by umvi on Monday September 17, 2018 @05:11PM (#18010120)
Possibly because, unlike race or gender, age-related biases are much more exagerrated between individuals.

I would guess young people are more eager to change/try new things whereas older people are more reluctant to change or stray from their "tried and true" methods.

The same cannot be said of a white person vs. a black person.

Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by tabtab on Monday September 17, 2018 @05:28PM (#18010245)
Re: guess young people are more eager to change/try new things whereas older people are more reluctant to change...

As I mentioned elsewhere, as I got older I am more skeptical/cynical of many fads/trends, and this "attitude" is often not valued by management. The thing is, I'm right more often than wrong and would bet my own money on such if I could. The fear of keeping up with the e-joneses has made our industry stupid. Fads/trends are poorly vetted for fit.

Warren Buffett has made similar observations about faddism in the financial industry, and he has the fat bucks to prove he's right.

Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by ljm on Monday September 17, 2018 @05:51PM (#18010438)
I find this to be true even just entering my 30s. I've made a few slips here and there, but it appears that there's a shift from mastering a skill to having decent domain knowledge for a specific tech.

So, you're not hired on how to solve a problem now, you're hired on how much you know their desired solution. This isn't engineering, you're not helping desig action, you're implementing it.

One of the huge failures in this sense is that tech has assumed priority over user value. Like your users give a shit about microservices, React, Vue, etc. etc. when you're using more of your runway on the infrastructure and not on the solution they want.

Most of this stuff has little value to most businesses. So if you push back you don't get hired; you have to find the places mature enough to understand why you would push back at all.

Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by mason55 on Monday September 17, 2018 @07:03PM (#18010872)
There are a bunch of different things wrapped up in your post and I won’t address them all. One thing though is that we don’t separate a technician vs an engineering in computing. Think about a plumber vs a water systems engineer. Both are valuable and paid well but they have very different roles.

Lots of people can be trained to be implementers and do valuable work. But we also don’t have stable best practices so that makes it harder. The line between engineer and implementer is blurred because an implementer constantly has to evaluate which new things should really be best practices.

Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by tabtab on Monday September 17, 2018 @05:59PM (#18010507)
I wish domain knowledge was valued more in tech staff, but I've just found that's often not the case. I'm not entirely sure why, and my theories (okay, guesses) would take a while to explain.

Further, if people don't see the "latest" UI on their screen, they become afraid that the underlying technology is "behind" even if it technically satisfies a business goal. Books are judged by covers.

Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by umvi on Monday September 17, 2018 @06:39PM (#18010734)
My point is that with a white person vs. a black person, you can assume that they are in all ways equal and interchangeable. A white person with 5 years of Java experience == a black person with 5 years of Java experience.

Young vs. old is different. A young person with 5 years of Java << an old person with 5 years of Java. Hence you must pay the old person 3x more because of all of their non-Java experience.

Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by tabtab on Monday September 17, 2018 @07:00PM (#18010855)
Re: Hence you must pay the old person 3x more because of all of their non-Java experience.

Not necessarily. I suspect what happened is IBM used to pay that way, but the industry practice has changed (for good or bad), but they fired based on current industry practice instead of their original practice, making it come out lopsided by age.

Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by jabits on Monday September 17, 2018 @05:22PM (#18010197)
This is bullshit and reflects the bias built into your own views. This is a deeply rooted viewpoint of many like you, most likely based on your experiences with your narrow network of "older" people.
Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by umvi on Monday September 17, 2018 @05:48PM (#18010412)
I disagree.

Anecdotally, my company is an ANSI C + ClearCase shop. Anytime discussion comes up about transitioning to safer languages like C++ or about using different VCS like Git or Mercurial it is shot down immediately by the senior developers who feel that those things are faddish.

Anecdotally, my parents always hated Windows and Microsoft Office upgrades because they would no longer be able to navigate the UIs. They became extremely resistant to upgrading anything that required them to relearn anything.

Heck, there's ancient adage "you can't teach an old dog new tricks" - why does that saying exist if it doesn't contain a kernel of truth??

There may be some older developers who are the exception to this, but my argument is that generally the older you get, the more entrenched your opinions and patterns become.

That's not necessarily a bad thing since those opinions and patterns were forged through decades of experience and hence contain much wisdom, but at a certain point when you are still using ANSI C and ClearCase in 2018 because there's "no need to switch to faddish version control like Git when ClearCase works perfectly fine" you are no longer fairly evaluating the technologies available on the market.

Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by brlewis on Monday September 17, 2018 @06:06PM (#18010550)
You disagreed, then confirmed that, as the comment you replied to said, your view is 'based on your experiences with your narrow network of "older" people'.

In addition, switching the VCS your company uses is possibly not what your engineering organization should focus on. I don't know enough about your company to say if switching away from ANSI C is worthwhile.

Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by umvi on Monday September 17, 2018 @06:18PM (#18010608)
And how do I know that your experiences based on your network of "older" people isn't equally narrow and biased?
Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by kasey_junk on Monday September 17, 2018 @06:39PM (#18010738)
You can be sure that it is. The difference is that they aren’t making arguments based on their age based biases.
Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by skookumchuck on Monday September 17, 2018 @07:33PM (#18011042)
As an older dev, I often weep when I see the Pull Requests from the young whippersnappers. They write code faster than I can fix the technical debt.
Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by brlewis on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @08:17AM (#18014550)
Don't discourage them from writing lots of code fast. That's a good way to learn. In your mind you need to stack rank the places where they should have done it differently, and just address the most important ones.
Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by skookumchuck on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @06:10PM (#18019645)
I coach the ones that want to learn. Most of 'em, however, will insist that their pigs fly. Only a decade or two of experience will help them.

Books on coding technique won't help much, because one needs experience to understand the point those books try to make.

Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by parsnips on Monday September 17, 2018 @09:04PM (#18011531)
What's older?
Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by projektir on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @12:03AM (#18012376)
> Heck, there's ancient adage "you can't teach an old dog new tricks" - why does that saying exist if it doesn't contain a kernel of truth??

Did you seriously just use a stereotype as evidence.

Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by YeGoblynQueenne on Monday September 17, 2018 @11:03PM (#18012145)
>> Heck, there's ancient adage "you can't teach an old dog new tricks" - why does that saying exist if it doesn't contain a kernel of truth??

A lot of people will also cry "oh god!" or something similar when they find themselves in a difficult situation, but that doesn't mean they believe in god; some do, many don't and still use the phrase. What's more, it doesn't mean there is a god. It's just something that people say.

Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by DoofusOfDeath on Monday September 17, 2018 @05:39PM (#18010344)
> This is bullshit

Please keep the discussion civil.

Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by s73v3r_ on Monday September 17, 2018 @07:51PM (#18011146)
Calling bullshit on an argument that is not made from fact is not being uncivil. I'd argue that making an argument that is such bullshit is far more uncivil than saying the word "bullshit".
Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by dang on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @02:57AM (#18013115)
You have a point, but it's trumped by the cruder point that when people get into the habit of hurling nasty words at each other, it leads to stupid discussion. Not from everybody, of course, but from most; the systemic effect is what dominates. That's why we don't allow that name-calling on HN (though that comment was hardly a serious instance of it).
Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by russdpale on Monday September 17, 2018 @05:30PM (#18010268)
Or the fact that the older people at my job still barely know how to type or use the printer or heaven forbid, scan to email! Even though they've had decades to learn it?

Im not a young dev anymore, but I can see why the older crowd has the rap they do. It doesn't make ageism right, at all.. but I can understand how it has happened.

An entire generation of people like me who have heard our older loved ones say they need their "foxfire" fixed or whatever.

10 years ago this was more palatable. Now a days it is dissolving as more older people learn the technology and more older people want to learn the technology. I personally never want to stop learning. My colleague is well into his 50's and still takes college course in math and CS. It has challenged my own personal prejudices and pushes me to be better as well.

Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by tabtab on Monday September 17, 2018 @05:36PM (#18010313)
There are negative stereotypes about inexperienced (young) workers also. Stupidity happens at all levels, and I could tell stories for months.
Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by skookumchuck on Monday September 17, 2018 @07:30PM (#18011026)
Taking math and CS courses isn't going to help you with scan to email.
Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by brlewis on Monday September 17, 2018 @05:41PM (#18010368)
When you say "young people" and "older people", do you mean all young and older people, or the average young or older person?

If you mean the average, then you're saying something no different from any other prejudice. You can't judge an individual by the statistics of some group s/he belongs to.

If you mean all young/older people, you've been really lucky with the young people you know and really unlucky with the older ones.

Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by fipple on Monday September 17, 2018 @06:53PM (#18010815)
Why is it bad to judge an individual by the statistics of the group they belong to? I assume that drunk drivers are dangerous because many are, even though I know that some people can safely drive drunk. I assume that tigers are dangerous even though I know some are very tame — I wouldn’t hop into a tiger cage hoping for the best.
Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by learc83 on Monday September 17, 2018 @07:53PM (#18011156)
Because most of the time there is greater variation within a group than there is between groups. If you use group statistics to judge individuals you will be wrong more often than if you don't.

But beyond that, we as a society have decided that in many cases the benefits of using group based heuristics aren't worth the damage done to individuals within groups who are judged negatively.

Imagine you toss out all resumes with non-white sounding names because white people are statistically more likely to have x, y, or z characteristic. Even if there is a correlation to some characteristic that you are looking for (more likely to have a college degree, statistically higher income etc...), the damage you do to the individuals in the groups you are tossing out far outweighs any benefit you receive.

Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by rhacker on Monday September 17, 2018 @08:51PM (#18011484)
I don't quite understand what you mean by all vs average, but I think he was saying that if you have 100 random old people and 100 random young people, there will be more people in the young group that know React, for example, than in the old group.
Re:IBM Is Being Sued for Age Discrimination After Firing Tho... by brlewis on Tuesday September 18, 2018 @08:24AM (#18014614)
Take that same sentence and substitute "women" for "old people" and "men" for "young people". If you used such a statistic to say "Women tend not to get React" wouldn't that be obvious sexism?