So a cottage industry of small, inefficient businesses is preferable to a large, efficient corporation because...? They naturally employ a lot of redundant workers? If that’s the case just skip the middleman and go with UBI if you want to just give away money to people for adding nothing of value.
Not everyone thinks corporations are a net-positive for societies.
Uh, that wasn't the question?
I have worked for and with some German and Scandinavian companies, and inefficiency is not a complaint that I would throw at them. Neither is lack of innovation.
YMMV, I guess.
The parent comment's question still stands: if the benefit of inefficient businesses is redistributive, why not just explicitly redistribute the gains from efficient businesses? This is a Pareto improvement when implemented properly (or more likely Kaldor-Hicks).
This isn't a rhetorical question, and there are theories as to why am efficient economy plus explicit redistribution isn't a good thing, but a lot of them depend (explicitly or implicitly) on Dickensian views like "the lower classes need pretend work to build character". You can hardly take this for granted without making a case for it, as your low-effort comment does. Hell, even if you _do_ take the Dickensian view, there are UBIish policies that may fit it better than the decentralized inefficiency you're talking about, like "govt as employer or last resort".
I'm not personally arguing in favor of inefficiency. I'm fairly neutral on the topic.
I'm only saying that not everyone values efficiency. And some people never will and will never be argued into valuing it.
Also,
> You can hardly take this for granted without making a case for it, as your low-effort comment does.
You should be more charitable. I wasn't arguing for anything.
> decentralized inefficiency you're talking about
I never said any such thing and I'll thank you for not attributing words to me that I never said.
How can you be neutral on the topic of efficiency?Efficiency is better full stop. Might as well say you are neutral on famines and poverty too.
Efficiency in doing what, exactly?
Efficiency might measure output of X as a function of input Y. Is having more X actually helpful or harmful?
How will the overall system respond if it suddenly becomes possible to more efficiently transform Y into X? (This can lead to higher rate of consumption of Y)
Does a strategy for increasing X / Y happen to damage some other valuable things A, B, C that aren't captured in the definition of the subsystem of X and Y we're trying to optimise?
I care about a lot of things. I don't care about everything.
In all, I am probably neutral on way more things than I favor or oppose.
I certainly don't care about efficiency for efficiency's sake. There may be some cases where I am pro-efficiency, and some where I am not.
I would not agree that "Efficiency is better full stop". There is nothing that is "full stop". There is always a dark side.
My grandmother's neighbor being allowed to install a 1000-head livestock operation 1 km from her house would have been more efficient than what she fought for and ended up compromising on with them. That less efficient compromise may have even contributed to greater poverty and possibly some future famine for all I know.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Is there always a segment of the population that believe the economic apocalypse is about to happen (or in this case happening)? If you want me to believe your doom and gloom try providing actual statistics that back up your assertions instead of vague hand wavings.
> Many thousand businesses moving €500k/year and using money locally is much better for local communities than 5 unicorns moving €50b/year
Do you have a citation for this claim? Also why should we be helping "local communities" and not simply helping people?
That's because those things are increasingly more creatively measured to paint a nice picture.
For example today any crap job regardless of quality/wages/precariousness etc is measured as "unemployment", whereas in the past you could have the same number of jobs but they would be much more solid (the "company man" and so on. Heck, a GM factory worker in the 50s could buy a house and raise 2 kids earning the only income in his family).
People who given up looking for work, because they can't find any, are also not counted, while still unemployed and struggling to make ends meet.
"The stock market, for example, has completely recovered from the financial crisis, and then some. Stocks are now worth almost 60 percent more than when the crisis began in 2007, according to a inflation-adjusted measure from Moody’s Analytics. But wealthy households own the bulk of stocks. Most Americans are much more dependent on their houses. That’s why the net worth of the median household is still about 20 percent lower than it was in early 2007. When television commentators drone on about the Dow, they’re not talking about a good measure of most people’s wealth.
The unemployment rate has also become less meaningful than it once was. In recent decades, the number of idle working-age adults has surged. They are not working, not looking for work, not going to school and not taking care of children. Many of them would like to work, but they can’t find a decent-paying job and have given up looking. They are not counted in the official unemployment rate."
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/14/opinion/columnists/great-...
>Do you have a citation for this claim? Also why should we be helping "local communities" and not simply helping people?
For one, because tax havens (where that money go instead of local communities, e.g. Apple's Ireland's cash stock) aren't "people".
Second because those local communities where the business is located are what should thrive first and foremost. You can't help "people" without first helping yourself.
They are measured the same way they always have been
>For example today any crap job regardless of quality/wages/precariousness etc is measured as "unemployment", whereas in the past you could have the same number of jobs but they would be much more solid (the "company man" and so on. Heck, a GM factory worker in the 50s could buy a house and raise 2 kids earning the only income in his family).
Oh this talking point again. Never mind the two world wars that made it all possible
>People who given up looking for work, because they can't find any, are also not counted, while still unemployed and struggling to make ends meet.
You are aware that there are multiple unemployment statistics that are tracked and that discouraged workers are included in some of them? Nobody is purposefully ignoring discouraged workers they are just not relevant to the market because they aren't participating in it.
>For one, because tax havens (where that money go instead of local communities, e.g. Apple's Ireland's cash stock) aren't "people".
What do you think happens to money in those tax havens? Do you think they convert it all into gold coins and lock it into a scrooge mcduck style vault? It's reinvested, they purchase treasuries with it, they do research and development with it. Governments then use that money to build roads and pay employees. Those employees then go and eat out and buy cars.
As I explained in the very next paragraph the creativity is in determining which people are in the workforce and which are not. Measuring the "same way they always have been" when work today is unlike it has "always has been" is like measuring inflation by the cost of commonly bought 1940s items.
>Oh this talking point again. Never mind the two world wars that made it all possible
A fact doesn't change based on what made it possible.
>You are aware that there are multiple unemployment statistics that are tracked and that discouraged workers are included in some of them? Nobody is purposefully ignoring discouraged workers they are just not relevant to the market because they aren't participating in it.
You're aware that the officially circulating numbers (U3 et all) don't show the impact of the problem by a very large margin? And that those people who "are just not relevant to the market" still need to put food on the table, pay rents, and pay medical bills...
>What do you think happens to money in those tax havens?
It gets further removed from the communities that fostered the companies that made it and their control, and on to the company's (or private owner's) discretion.
To the contrary:
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/11/magazine/americans-jobs-p...
The U6 is back to where it was in 1999. Wages are growing at the fastest pace in a decade, with a labor market that keeps getting tighter, driving wage gains faster.
The poverty rate and homelessness rate are both near record lows. The poverty rate has contracted rapidly in the last several years. That's due to the dramatic improvement in the job market over the past decade and a vast expansion over time in the US welfare state / social safety net, which is paid for by taxes from an aggressively expanding economy.
Since January 2010, the US has added a Germany + France in terms of economic expansion ($6 trillion in GDP), while only adding 16m in population.
US manufacturing, which is a critical supplier of decent blue collar jobs, has been persistently adding jobs for nearly a decade (1.3m manufacturing jobs added over that time). It's the first sustained period of manufacturing job growth since the late 1990s. It was widely proclaimed to be impossible that that could occur.
If you want to bolster the conditions for the bottom 1/2, you do it with jobs, wage pressure through a tight labor market, and a strong social safety net paid for via taxes from a booming economy.
Of course you need to make sure that companies don't privatize all the profits without giving back something to the community, but that's (IMHO) not an issue of company size but rather a taxation issue.
The answer to the economic problems you detail is worker owned cooperatives. The reason is that small business capitalists have too much incentive to being bought out by a larger conglomerate. They're also easy to run out of business with the Walmart model of running a loss for years.
We won't all have or be able to bank on a capitalist coming in to give us all jobs. Keeping the money local is imperative as you said, especially for the majority of economic activity worldwide, which consists of guaranteed, proven business models. An example would be your local 7-Eleven, there's no reason all of these essential services should have a board of directors in Japan rather than every worker being the board. You might get better service too.
I intend to turn my sole proprietorship into a worker owned co-op and at least coexist with Accenture if not run them out of the city with far more caring employees producing superior product.
If you want a healthcare.gov debacle go with an inefficient capitalist enterprise, which has a singular goal of selling you the most expensive product made by the cheapest possible employees. Otherwise support your local worker owned co-ops.
In a cooperative, joining means buying a share in a company (not public stock), or bringing a share, and leaving means either letting the share go, or selling it back to the company. Since the company us co-owned, it involves everyone.
This is not bad per se, and does have its upsides. But fast growth is hard with this model, so is market domination.
And if your company is not pushing for market domination, your competition still is.
You would also have performance reviews and management just as in any other enterprise. You can get fired even as a worker-owner. Everything would be democratic and transparent, if you're not doing your job it'll show and you may get voted out. Yes there would be better job security than the dominant capitalist business model, which is a good thing. I'm assuming that would mean you'd be repaid for the value of your share upon your exit.
What this would do is attract the best employees to begin with. Between Accenture and a co-op where I get an ownership share and vote, and equal share of profits, I know which I'd prefer.
The great trick that is played by the current capitalist model is that there's a few great enterprises like Apple, Google, Microsoft and Facebook that pay well and treat people as good as if they had a union bargaining team. That doesn't exist for anyone else. These few dominant standouts build the reputation for other businesses that are a shadow of them.
It would certainly cut the fat out of inefficient models that include more middle management trying to justify their jobs and directors doing doing the same.
As far as growth, my view on that has always been that the size of companies that exist today are monstrosities. Many are propped up with government subsidies, defense contracts and such. Core government functions should be nationalized anyway, due to conflict of interest. The obvious one being folks who build bombs doing whatever it takes to encourage more wars and arms sales. That one is the most serious because it's not just waste, it's peoples lives being lost. Government has no such profit incentive conflict. There should be no such thing as perpetual contracts with the government. If it's a one-off and no co-op can meet the demand, there's options to scale quickly with contractors, and even in that case the co-op cares more about ensuring quality results than the capitalist enterprise. But you raise an important point, I'm suspicious of these mega-corps and their ties to government. I can't imagine a 10-person co-op bumbling healthcare.gov as Accenture did. In fact, I'm pretty sure with 10 hand-picked technologists, my cooperative could have outperformed Accenture's healthcare.gov job by a wide margin.
That is really a prime example of capitalism's inherent inefficiencies. Get the contract, possibly through favorable previous Accenture/gov't deals, and who cares about the result. For the people that work there, it's not their business, it's Wall Streets.
Accenture doesn't have to worry about their reputation after all, they're too big to fail. Where have we heard that before? We shouldn't encourage and participate in a system that enforces such mediocrity out of humanity. I'm one who expects excellence out of myself and those around me, and I can't see our current mode of production as encouraging that out of the majority.
I'm not sure in a capitalist enterprise's efforts to dominate that they'd be able to bring in the best people when candidates can be essentially on the board of directors somewhere else either. Basically I believe that your point about competitors attempting to dominate an industry will be very difficult with widespread co-ops. Not without gov't collusion (or similar tactics). Employees at capitalist enterprises will be even more demotivated than they are today, knowing they're stuck as non-owners and without an equal payout of quarterly profits as their cooperative competitors enjoy. I can't see capitalism as a mode of production holding up very well once the idea spreads and is demonstrated more.
In sum, all organizations are only as good as the people within them, no matter the ownership model used. Capitalist business fails today just as cooperatives will in the future. Most people, myself included really only want a fair shake for our hard work, and stability for the community we live in. That's what it provides. It's still work, and hard work at that. It's not utopia, it's just fair. It's probably more work than just working for someone else as an employee, but it's less work than starting your own company if you join an existing co-op, and you don't have to spend your time trying to trick people into working hard (or unpaid overtime) and not receiving 100% payment for that 100% effort.
They'll go so far as to feign "diversity" efforts (in quotes because the only diversity corporations are interested in is diversity of wages).
It'll be a lot of work as there are many details to work out but I've bookmarked your comment to let you know when the day comes.
Good luck
Love the diversity comment