News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by bayesian_horse on Saturday September 15, 2018 @10:17AM (#17994356)
And some people still wonder why Germans have an aversion towards anything called "nuclear".
Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by atemerev on Saturday September 15, 2018 @10:46AM (#17994456)
Why? These devices (and SADMs) literally saved West Germany from being overran by the Soviet Union. No other option would have prevented it.

German officials _insisted_ that tactical nuclear devices would have been deployed, even against American reservations at this time. They were right, in hindsight.

Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by dingaling on Saturday September 15, 2018 @02:15PM (#17995374)
SADMs and Davy Crockett couldn't repulse a massed Soviet armoured thrust. They simply didn't have the yield and blast radius needed and were deployed in tiny numbers. This can be deduced by the neutron-protective lining applied to Soviet first-line tanks, they were expected to roll on through.

Massed 155mm conventional artillery was NATO's mainstay response, with ATGMs to pick-off high-value targets like command tanks.

Later MLRS and Assault Breaker were developed, again conventional solutions.

Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by atemerev on Saturday September 15, 2018 @02:49PM (#17995539)
Yes, Soviet strategy have adapted. However, “neutron-protective lining” didn’t properly work; however, tank armies formations were spead out to reduce the possible radiation damage. You are right, however; tactical nuclear weapons were deployed as a deterrent, not as a valid defense option.
Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by TheOtherHobbes on Saturday September 15, 2018 @05:16PM (#17996072)
Soviet war plans have never been declassified, and the plans that have been - let's say - interpolated are just plain insane. They envisage massed Soviet tanks and infantry trying to blitzkrieg through the radioactive remains of Northern Europe on a suicide mission.

A few low-yield tac nukes make no difference in this scenario, because the radioactive remains of NATO would still have been raining megatons on any attempted Soviet advance.

Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by bayesian_horse on Saturday September 15, 2018 @01:10PM (#17995036)
Relying on nuclear contamination as deterrence to avoid the nuclear contamination of your country is inherently scary. Especially if the real decision makers live thousands of miles away.

There has always been a resistance against American nuclear weapons in Germany. It just didn't play a big role up until fairly recently.

[dead]
Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by majewsky on Saturday September 15, 2018 @06:42PM (#17996366)
My parents and grandparents lived under Soviet occupation (in the GDR) for decades and they had a pretty good time, all things considered. So did millions others.
Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by 08-15 on Saturday September 15, 2018 @07:23PM (#17996527)
I lived under Soviet occupation (in the GDR) for 14 years, thank you very much. It was a relatively good time, compared to, let's say, the stone age.
Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by bayesian_horse on Monday September 17, 2018 @03:23AM (#18003845)
The GDR wasn't turned into a nuclear wasteland before occupation. It was also "only" devastated once by a world war, not twice, as would have been the case for Western Germany if it were to be occupied by Soviet forces again.
Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by davrosthedalek on Saturday September 15, 2018 @07:32PM (#17996556)
Except for those who got shot when they tried to leave the country.
Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by majewsky on Sunday September 16, 2018 @12:50PM (#17999814)
Sure, not disputing that. But our current telling of history emphasizes the misery of those in the GDR that disagreed with the doctrine, at the expense of millions of people who got by just fine. I'm seeing a lot of resentment in East Germans against elites as a result of that.
Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by 08-15 on Sunday September 16, 2018 @05:37PM (#18001283)
The two million people (out of 17 million) who worked for Miniluv (Ministerium für Staatssicherheit, known as Stasi, an oppressive secret service comparable to the earlier Gestapo) got by just fine.
Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by majewsky on Sunday September 16, 2018 @07:28PM (#18001896)
I appreciate that you've stepped back a long way from your initial assertion that nuclear war is literally better than living in the GDR.
Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by emiliobumachar on Saturday September 15, 2018 @10:24AM (#17994372)
Come on, these are two separate discussions.

Nuclear power can be used without making weapons.

Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by bayesian_horse on Saturday September 15, 2018 @10:35AM (#17994416)
Historically, no. Nuclear power has always been tied to nuclear weapons in terms of infrastructure and technology. Only lately have there been attempts at nuclear power without the capacity for weapons development. Except for dirty bombs, of course, which are possible with virtually any radioactive material.

And fear of "nuclear" technology isn't totally about rational arguments. It's not baseless either, because so many "impossible" accidents happened and its so hard to dispose of nuclear waste safely.

The deployment of small nuclear grenades, intended to detonate near or in our cities for such "minor" targets as tanks hasn't exactly helped that fear.

Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by AnthonyMouse on Saturday September 15, 2018 @12:11PM (#17994798)
> Nuclear power has always been tied to nuclear weapons in terms of infrastructure and technology.

This is a reason to be wary of nuclear power in e.g. Iran. If you're worried that nuclear power in the United States or Europe will allow western countries to develop nuclear weapons, you're too late.

It should also be noted that (edit: some of) the first nuclear weapons were developed using uranium, which is naturally occurring and can be enriched using centrifuges or other technology without any nuclear reactor at all.

> And fear of "nuclear" technology isn't totally about rational arguments. It's not baseless either, because so many "impossible" accidents happened and its so hard to dispose of nuclear waste safely.

This is FUD. Nothing is ever "impossible" but we deal with things more dangerous than nuclear waste on a regular basis, with less care taken and more actual accidents. Meanwhile you have a nuclear plant with multiple safety measures, then something happens which overcomes half of them but not the other half and the story is how unsafe this is rather than how the multiple overlapping safety layers worked as intended.

The only majors disasters have been outside the United States in plants with lower safety requirements. The Chernobyl plant was designed unsafely and operated unsafely and even then the death toll was on the same order of magnitude as the collapse of a skyscraper or the sinking of a large ship, but nobody calls for an end to skyscrapers or ships, much less dams (which are much more dangerous), and that's before we even mention automobiles.

The waste problem is also entirely political. The major long half life component is plutonium, which can be reprocessed and used as reactor fuel in newer reactors, which actually permanently destroys it -- the only way to make sure it's never used for weapons. The shorter half life components have to be stored to cool off, but we're talking dozens of years rather than thousands there. Many of them also have commercial value in medical imaging and things like that.

Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by mikeash on Saturday September 15, 2018 @12:33PM (#17994890)
A bit of a nitpick: the first and third bombs ever detonated were plutonium weapons. Uranium bombs were developed in parallel, mostly as a backup plan in case the much more complicated but otherwise superior plutonium bomb ended up not being workable.
Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by bayesian_horse on Saturday September 15, 2018 @01:06PM (#17995025)
In reality it doesn't matter what else is dangerous in this world, when you have the possibility of a nuclear reactor blowing up or making portions of the country uninhabitable. For virtually no benefit. Just don't do it.

Of course, all the experts keep saying nothing bad is going to happen with "our" technology in "our" country with "our" government regulating it. But in reality stuff did happen again and again, and with the potential damage even very low probabilities become scary.

I don't get why being a "political problem" negates the nuclear waste argument. For one thing, suitable sites are a lot less common than previously thought, and safety of sites used earlier has been overestimated rather badly. For another, the "political" problem of getting people to accept a nuclear waste dump in their vicinity is extremely real and not going to go away. Not from any attempt of rational persuasion anyway.

Again, it's not so much about rationality as about fear. But it's also about the fact that engineers tend to underestimate the risk in relying on Human operators, designers, regulators and the stability of a government. Nuclear power plants have a lifetime measured in decades. The weather will change, the demand will change, the technology will change. All good reasons not to commit to decades long problems (centuries, in the case of Tschernobyl and maybe even Fukushima, and decommissioning old power plants looks to be a lot more expensive than everyone thought).

Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by 08-15 on Saturday September 15, 2018 @02:57PM (#17995584)
If the area around Fukushima is uninhabitable, then so is Denver. This irrational fear of trivial amounts of ionizing radiation is what prevents us from having abundant energy without emissions of greenhouse gasses. (But I guess that's virtually no benefit.)

> the nuclear waste argument

Can you see what you're doing here? You don't actually argue, you just pretend there is an argument and it's conclusive. If I tried to argue against that, I'd uselessly spend energy making points you don't care about, and you would claim victory.

Oh, that's not what you're doing? The what is the nuclkear waste argument?

> it's not so much about rationality as about fear

You need it to be about fear, because you don't have a rational argument.

Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by emiliobumachar on Saturday September 15, 2018 @11:31AM (#17994644)
Skepticism about expert classification of accidents as "impossible" is a completely rational argument given the history.

Again, I'm not trying to have either debate. I'm just arguing against conflating them, at least within each single country. Once we're policing other countries about keeping off bombs, then, sure, forbidding their power plants might make sense.

Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by bayesian_horse on Saturday September 15, 2018 @01:12PM (#17995043)
Rationally it makes sense to separate the idea of nuclear contamination from casual use of small nuclear weapons from nuclear contamination from nuclear power accidents or waste disposal problems.

Emotionally it doesn't make sense at all.

Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by 08-15 on Saturday September 15, 2018 @02:44PM (#17995519)
> Nuclear power has always been tied to nuclear weapons in terms of infrastructure and technology

You mean like the CANDU reactors?

Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by dboreham on Saturday September 15, 2018 @11:20AM (#17994596)
Nuclear power plants were literally the factories for weapons.
Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by mikeash on Saturday September 15, 2018 @12:34PM (#17994893)
Nuclear reactors were. Nuclear power plants didn’t show up until a decade later.
Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by dboreham on Saturday September 15, 2018 @02:46PM (#17995530)
Not sure why that's relevant. It takes O(years) to plan and build one.

http://www.world-nuclear-news.org/Articles/UK-marks-60th-ann...

Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by mikeash on Saturday September 15, 2018 @03:17PM (#17995655)
It’s relevant because producing bomb material and producing power are somewhat orthogonal, as evidenced by the fact that bombs were being made for about a decade before any power was produced.
Re:Davy Crockett (nuclear device) by 08-15 on Saturday September 15, 2018 @02:58PM (#17995591)
Citation needed. (Spoiler alert: they weren't.)