What makes people powerful is coordination.
The public space for conversation on the web are a handful of platforms - and those can easily be controlled.
The rest can still exist (personal webpages and so on), but they will remain fringe.
>Censorship has always been about maintaining their narrative.
Well, first they came for Alex Jones, but I didn't do anything, I wasn't a conspiracy nut...
They were very afraid.
Not to mention that a lot of very true shit going on is indeed conspiracies -- it just doesn't involve aliens and illuminati, but established powers (e.g. the white establishment having FBI follow and discredit MLK and other civil rights activists), state agencies, rich private interests buying politicians and forming cartels, powerful elites pushing their agendas, big industries promoting their crap (e.g. big food and big tobacco buying their own "scientific research" and then promoting it in through the magazines they advertise in) and so on...
Well that is simply not true.
For example, the Sandy Hook harassment brigade caused real harm, eg: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-florida-crime-sandyhook-i...
I'd say the problem lies more with people that find it acceptable to harass others, whether their actions are based on a true story or a hoax.
I agree there are many other things which are also harmful.
Someone wanting to harass someone else can do it over a true story (person X did X) just as well as over a conspiracy story (aliens made person Y did Z).
The fault lies with the harasser (who is acting badly) not with the reason why they harass.
Or maybe you think that if a story is true then it's OK to harass people over it?
I think we agree that isn’t true.
Both the harasser and the person encouraging it can be at fault.
You can throw in all the strawmen you like.
Trolling has been a problem for internet platforms since the Usenet days. The solution has always ended up being banning that individual from the place they are doing the harassing.
That's just sensible community management.
No, they are not a single entity. No they aren't perfectly coordinated. No, they aren't a single group conspiring in a smokey room.
But they are a social group. They go to the same schools, live in the same ZIP codes and vacation in similar places. They marry overwhelming among themselves. There are a few thousand families in the US with that level of power. New families reach these power levels and other families fall off, it isn't a fixed thing.
But you'll know who they are because you and I aren't invited to their clubs.
They are the people who own the country. They are the people who are invited to the Bilderberg meetings. They are those who fund think tanks. They are the people whose kids are guaranteed a seat in an Ivy league school, regardless of merit. They are also VERY unlikely to face jail time when they are accused of a crime; which is rare.
This sounds unlikely, since these are the people who are least affected by people like Jones. I'd also note that many of these people are also the ones making noises about a conspiracy against conservative voices in silicon valley.
The people who banned Jones are more like people like me. People who hate the lying, disrespect and trolling he represents.
Say company “X” runs a comms medium, and either an official office channel or an official with a private channel is contrary to the views of that entity, can that private entity legally censor government communication?
Free speech is a concept, not just the bare letter of the text of the bill of rights. [1]
And there are examples of private companies being forbidden from censoring or removing people.
For example, the courts ruled that a private airport was forbidden from kicking out people who were there to hand out flyers. [2]
And, do you seriously think it is ok for the private electricity company or the postal service to deny access to their network because they disagree with your politics? Is it really ok, just because "property rights"?
The first telegram network was a total monopoly, and was used as a tool by the wealthy to manipulate elections and tamper with commodities prices.
It was because of this that we got common carriage laws.
Back then, would you have defended the telegraph company banning journalists who criticized labor practices in coal mines? Why not? It's their private property after all. Those labor organizers and human rights activists should have thought about the consequences of their actions before attempting to expose child labor.
[1]: http://magaimg.net/img/5yri.png
[2]: https://blogs.wsj.com/law/2007/12/26/ca-supremes-give-free-s...
No it absolutely cannot be argued that. The 1st amendment clearly applies to the government, and there is no legislation requiring the same for private companies/citizens. There would need to be a law equating corporations to government (there is not) at a federal level.
No, it can't First Amendment rights apply only to federal government action.
Equivalent rights are interpreted as applying to State government action under the incorporation doctrine tied to the 14th Amendment.
You could possibly make an argument that the 14th Amendment applies to corporate (or LLC, but not sole proprietorship) action based on a theory that a state-chartered corporation’s actions are, ipso facto, state actions, but that's very out of line with basically all US legal precedent.
That's the same whether it's the USA or some Latin American country with 5 wealthy families enjoying politicians in their pockets.
"What's good for the country is good for General Motors"-style...
GDPR is not about controlling the internet but allowing users of the internet to control their privacy even against big companies.
As if before guns opposing trained swordsmen was an easy task.
That is to say, we have achieved decentralised internet so to speak, and we have the web which is a means to broadcast information, but we do not yet have the decentralised web.
- When religion overpowered us, we were helpless and had to obey.
- When guns came into play, we were helpless and had to obey.
- When TV and Radio began, the narrative was controlled and we were brainwashed to obey.
The Internet is like the power of TV and radio in the hands of the people, and the power of the people is beyond guns and religion.
This is too much for those who wish to stifle the power of the people. So they have been passing small laws left and right leading to a slippery slope of laws removing our rights and freedoms (and essentially the power of the people).
Now that we have become desensitized (they proved it with the “internet world control” move known as GDPR that proved they control the internet) they wish to make the final controversial blow.
Make no mistake, this has always been a fight for control of our freedom. The internet and decentralized technologies like it as well as the many built on top of it are the only chance we have to maintain freedom as people and society.
Censorship has always been about maintaining their narrative.
Luckily we no longer have to sit back and get whipped anymore. Now we have tools like cryptography that can allow us to create systems that cannot be controlled by a single person. That said, even with the tools, if we don’t use them, then we are “tools.”