The only question is whether Google and American interests want to be in the room or left outside in the cold.
It's always better to be involved and informed.
That assertion only makes sense if you assume that helping perpetuate human rights abuses has no impact on human rights abuses.
It's no different than the justification some use when we talk about the ethical ramifications of selling arms to middle eastern states in conflict.
"They are going to buy their arms from someone, it may as well be us!"
It is amoral almost by definition.
Only if you are an amoral actor that cares not a bit about human rights or ability to self-determination.
It is very much in the interests of the US and every democracy to uphold human rights and self-determination at every turn and every possible location in the world.
Failure to do so enables dictators, authoritarians, and criminals. The fact that we've often failed to do so, or do it well, does not mitigate the benefits when we it is done well, or the damage when we fail.
And make no mistake, failure is what you are pushing.
The only question is whether you are doing it right now as a shill for the CCP, or only because you are amoral?
NONSENSE. Google would be explicitly applying the best and brightest in the world to help CCP achieve its goals sooner and better.
CCP may indeed ultimately achieve those goals themselves, but it would be much later and with less expertise.
Delay and degrading anti-human-rights capabilities is a good unto itself, and a good to the US and every democracy.
Sometimes it is not better to be informed and involved with what are basically criminal gangs.
Are you promoting this because you are amoral or because you are a shill for the CCP?
Because when you don't, they make your existence difficult, to varying degrees?
Google is building infrastructure for the powerful to control the masses' ability to communicate ideas.
Do you think the USA is "The People"? Then this is bad for them, because one of our most powerful companies is beginning to develop tools of direct social control.
Do you think the USA is the government & associated bureaucrats? Then this is good, because this technology will allow them to suppress threats to their authority.
https://medium.com/insurge-intelligence/how-the-cia-made-goo...
Google are having zero influence on China's totalitarian government, and there is zero hope that they could have any such influence. It is either do what the CCP wants, when they want it, or Google gets booted anyway in favor of the locals.
Most likely, China is simply using them to build and steal the best surveillance technology faster. The better result from a human rights POV would be to have less-competent locals build it.
The sole exception would be if Google is working very tightly with NSA, CIA, etc. and actually installing a massive US spy network within China. While this is a possibility we wouldn't know about, it's unlikely given Google's culture.
So, no, this is not even close to being in the interests of the US or it's citizens (a few major Alphabet shareholders excepted).
Exactly.
Therefore it is nonsense to be outraged by what Google is doing.
To spell it out, the GP was positing that by working with the CCP, Google was somehow adding western pro-human rights influence to the mix.
This is false because the CCP will allow no such influence.
Google's only possible influence is to enhance the effectiveness of the CCP's initiatives by adding Google's greater competence and development speed to the CCP's goal of mass surveillance and distorting or filtering the facts available to the Chinese people.
So, yes, since Google is enhancing the CCP's totalitarian goals of controlling the populace, outrage is quite appropriate (unless of course, you oppose the general principles of democracy and people being able to govern themselves).
My angle is very much one of realpolitik, as already mentioned, and outrage is either naive or disingenuous.
Seriously? Talk about naive, that's textbook.
"Realpolitik" -- you may be right about that, since the first definition is "a system of politics or principles based on practical rather than moral or ideological considerations."
In short, you say it is great as long as you consider only practical issues, and ignore all moral or ethical considerations.
So, you are either trolling to assist the CCP's goals or are simply advocating for behaving without ethics or morals. Which is it?
And I can assure you that outrage against helping totalitarian/authoritarian regimes is neither naive or disingenuous, at least for ethical people.
I suggest reading people who have actually lived in and fought such regimes, such as Garry Kasparov, former World Chess Champion and Russian Presidential candidate -- people who've actually been there, done that, buried their friends.
I assure you, they know the real score, and have zero tolerance for "realpolitik" bullst.
I think you missed an important implication, from the context.
> Google are having zero influence on <limiting> China's totalitarian government
Spending a lot of political capital to do the same thing as the other search engines in China doesn't seem like a good trade, politically. It makes a bit more sense as a way to make money, except that this doesn't seem like an area where China will let a foreign company win.
Healthy competition and free exploration of markets leads to better tools which creates both economic and cultural value.
China is sacrificing that in order to maintain cultural control. It’s precisely the cost of Google’s absence which could twist their arm.
(Although I suspect they won’t change until they are forced to by censorship-resistant creatures which will spawn Jurrasic Park-style in the next decade from the morass of cheap electronic components and waste ideas)
In the former case it means increased influence of China's authoritarian government over an important western company that billions use to learn about the world. China has already used the implied threat to the Chinese operations of several American airlines to force them to make political changes to their global websites (https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-44948599).
What do you think will happen if China asks Google to make changes to the results ranking for this query (https://www.google.com/search?q=tibet), so that it can continue "to share China's development opportunities [and] invest in and operate in China?" There are a couple of links on the first page I'm sure the Chinese government would say do not "respect China's laws and rules, China's sovereignty and territorial integrity and the feelings of the Chinese people."
Xi's trajectory is making me nervous right now, but then look at our current leadership. And their government DID lift a few hundred million people out of poverty over the last 30 years. Maybe we can work with that.
Some of the rhetoric I'm seeing fly around on the topic sounds a little overheated to me, compared to how bad things could get.
When you refuse to do business, and "encourage" your allies to do the same, then the other side begins to think that perhaps it may just be easier to take your resources by force.
Based on that, better to be in than out.
Maybe so, but you definitely can hurt human rights by working there. I would say providing censored search results (and putting an American stamp of approval on them) is hurting human rights there. Furthermore, giving an authoritarian government economic leverage over an American search engine company can hurt human rights here.
This is a storm in a tea cup, but it shows that the US feel increasingly insecure when it comes to China.
25 years after Tiananmen, most Chinese university students have never heard of it
https://www.vox.com/2014/6/3/5775918/25-years-after-tiananme...
"Gosh, if only we had known there were no WMDs!" Nothing about the Philippine-American War made it into any history book ever assigned to any student in USA, just as nothing about the liars who killed 600,000 Iraqis ever will. Aware or not, we are still being manipulated.
Having Google censor results could create the false impression that search results are censored similarly in the US as well.
Maybe we can trust Google not to hide stuff from us, but how come the following bullshit is all over Youtube?
"teleSUR is funded in whole or in part by the Latin American government" [0]
First of all, that warning doesn't even make sense. "The Latin American government"? Who's the president in that government? Maybe they have a king? Is that government less reliable than the USA government? Do they fight as many wars? Does the USA government fund any part of any media sources?
More importantly, now that this sort of pathetic annotation has started, wouldn't we expect it to increase? If Alphabet require a complete accounting of all income sources for all video posters, they'll be able to annotate more comprehensively, and then charge on a sliding scale to hide those annotations. Can actual censorship be far behind?
> ...false...
> Maybe we can trust Google not to hide stuff from us, but how come the following bullshit is all over Youtube?
You're going off into the weeds and talking about an entirely different issue.
Google search results in the US are not censored similarly to China's: you can search for Tiananmen Square or Kent State and get accurate results. The kind of thing we're talking about is a scenario where those queries return nothing, or only garbage the supports the party line. The false impression is the one created when a Chinese person cross-checks Baidu against a hypothetical Google.cn and sees no difference in censorship, and makes the error that Google.cn reflects the behavior of Google.com.
We're not talking about poor labeling around who funded what (which is not censorship at all, by the way).
Baidu already exists.
You are right it's called Realpolitik.
You are advocating for amoral action, simply for profit, regardless of ethical considerations.
Your consistent promotion of this is repugnant, and raises the question of whether you are shilling for the CCP, are clueless about actual international affairs, or are simply amoral yourself.
It's more than just a situation of, "Someone else will do it eventually, so I might as well" and then as you put it, make a few bucks along the way and stay relevant and so forth. The difference here is that Google is offering elite levels of brainpower/research and resources. Not everyone can do that.
And I think you meant realpolitik, the concept of viewing the world in terms of true/material interests.
As I see it the choice is to either do what Google is doing, which means being involved, staying relevant, and making a few bucks along the way, or to stay away. In the latter case the only result will be diminished influence for Google and by extension the USA, as that won't damage China at all, it will just leave the door open for new Chinese tech giants.
It's called realpolitik.