News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Georgia says switching back to all-paper voting is logist... by briandear on Thursday September 13, 2018 @12:36AM (#17976059)
To be fair, paper ballots also have their problems, Kennedy likely won the election because of ballot stuffing. However, I think it weird that we oppose electronic voting because of security concerns but similarly aligned groups oppose voter ID. If we cared about election integrity, we’d have a 100% photo ID requirement with facial recognition along with using election ink on a finger, along with tamperproor paper ballots. But I don’t think these groups actually care about election integrity — they simply seek to delegitimize election results for candidates and parties they don’t like. If their guy won, there wouldn’t be any challenge. Donna Curling (and her husband,) the lead plaintiff, has given over $48,000 to Democrat candidates, including contributing the maximum to David Scott — a congressman who, despite running unopposed in 2016, spent almost $1,000,000 in campaign funds on fancy DC restaurants and other nonsense — especially ridiculous since he ran unopposed. He literally just had to sit in a chair doing nothing and he would have won his election. But he managed to spend more money than many candidates in contested races. He may not have broken the law, but any reasonable person might have reason to believe that there is even more nonsense inside his tent.

And yes, this is relevant because Scott, throughout his career has engaged in highly questionable and potentially illegal campaign activities. Scott is also a member of the highly corrupt Congressional Black Caucus who has featured a veritable rogue’s gallery of unethical at best, illegal at worst members: Corrine Brown (federal prison for fraud,) Chaka Farrah (convicted of 23 charges of racketeering and fraud,) Eddie Bernice Johnson ethics violations,) Maxine Waters (multiple ethics violations due to involvement with OneBank,) Alcee Hastings (impeached as a judge,) Sheila Jackson-Lee (Medicare fraud,) Charlie Rangel (tax evasion,) Gwen Moore (ethical violations.)

David Scott also made the list of 25 most corrupt congressmen.

And the lead plaintiff is a major fundraiser for Scott.

If this Curling person actually cared about election integrity and ethics, then why would she significantly support one of the most corrupt congressmen in office?

David Scott, incidentally opposes voter ID laws and yet one of his biggest supporters is worried about election machine hacking? While I am not a fan of electronic voting, this entire case seems designed to deligitimize the election. People like to cite that voter fraud isn’t a real problem, yet election machine hacking also hasn’t been a proven problem either. So if voter ID is unnecessary because “fraud doesn’t happen,” then hacking an election machine seems even more unlikely — there hasn’t been a single proven case that a voting machine has been hacked but there has been multiple occasions of voter fraud. If we were trying to prevent election irregularities, then a paper ballot along with strict voter ID seems completely reasonable; but the Donna Curlings of the country don’t care about that. They care only that their guy wins.

Re:Georgia says switching back to all-paper voting is logist... by specialist on Thursday September 13, 2018 @01:13AM (#17976231)
"...yet election machine hacking also hasn’t been a proven problem either"

Fraud and errors are indistinguishable.

Voter Action proved in court that Kerry won New Mexico in 2004. Because the touchscreens didn't count spanish language ballots. As in none.

Fraud? Programming error?

Doesn't matter.

Re:Georgia says switching back to all-paper voting is logist... by kss238 on Thursday September 13, 2018 @12:40AM (#17976089)
Voter ID disenfranchises the poor, otherwise I don't think anyone would have an issue with voter id requirements.
Re:Georgia says switching back to all-paper voting is logist... by Aeolun on Thursday September 13, 2018 @12:48AM (#17976117)
So make ID’s free, and then require voter ID :/ seems the solution is right there. I have a hard time imagining the US can’t bear the cost of printing a few hundred million ID’s.
Re:Georgia says switching back to all-paper voting is logist... by SeanLuke on Thursday September 13, 2018 @01:01AM (#17976193)
It's not cost. The US has a long tradition of viewing required national identification documents as a violation of individual liberties.
Re:Georgia says switching back to all-paper voting is logist... by briandear on Thursday September 13, 2018 @12:48AM (#17976127)
But voter fraud disenfranchises everyone. Every single state has free ID programs. We have campaigns to help people get food stamps (which incidentally require ID,) but we can’t have similar programs to ensure everyone has ID? The idea that we can’t get ID for the poor is just ridiculous. Even illegal immigrants in California can get drivers licenses and they are far more marginalized than poor American citizens in terms of access to services.

https://www.vox.com/identities/2017/3/15/14909764/study-vote...

Re:Georgia says switching back to all-paper voting is logist... by SeanLuke on Thursday September 13, 2018 @01:07AM (#17976209)
> But voter fraud disenfranchises everyone.

What voter fraud are you referring to?

The type of voter fraud that IDs would counter is "in-person" voter fraud. The amount of in-person voter fraud in the United States is extraordinarily miniscule, effectively zero.

When states pass laws which intrude on liberties, they are generally required to justify those laws with "compelling interest". With near-zero in-person voter fraud there is no compelling interest on part of the state for voter ID programs.

In 2016 North Carolina had one documented example of in-person voter fraud out of 4.8 million voters. But the state still requires voter ID to counter "voter fraud". This is absurd on the face of it -- it's transparently obvious that North Carolina republicans (among others) are seeking voter ID as a mechanism for suppressing the vote among various disadvantaged groups.

Re:Georgia says switching back to all-paper voting is logist... by techsupporter on Thursday September 13, 2018 @01:00AM (#17976188)
If you can reliably ensure that every single citizen who is entitled to get an ID can do so with no impediments at all in all fifty states, every territory of the United States, and the District of Columbia, without cost or delay, then fine.

As it stands, no one can ensure that.

Getting a birth certificate, often a requirement for a "free ID," costs money, time, and administrative overhead. Sometimes it is virtually impossible for someone who was born in an "uncommon" way.

Showing up in person, almost always a requirement for a "free ID," costs money, time, and logistical overhead. There are several states who oh-so-conveniently place enrollment centers for these IDs juuuuust outside the convenient reach of population centers whose citizens are more-likely-than-not to vote in the way that the incumbent politicians would prefer. Or the state pleads austerity and closes so many facilities that the wait just to enter one to request an ID is many hours. Or the delay in manufacturing the ID reaches near-infinity around common voting deadlines.

And then you have the asinine lists of acceptable IDs. For several years, for example, Texas would not accept a student ID issued by a public college but would accept an expired law enforcement commission card issued by any city or county in the state. So someone may, inaccurately as it turns out, believe he or she has a "government-issued ID" when he or she actually doesn't have one that's acceptable for voting.

And then you get into all of the other myriad edge cases that should not disqualify someone from acting as a citizen. Married women who changed their names. Married men who changed their names (because a man changing his name is "suspect"). Children who were adopted but still have old paperwork.

Voter fraud is not a sufficiently large problem that it needs to be solved by throwing a 200-pound anvil of paperwork at preventing it. And it's not good enough to say that "most" people have a driver license or state ID or passport or something like that. Every citizen should be entitled to vote.

Re:Georgia says switching back to all-paper voting is logist... by specialist on Thursday September 13, 2018 @01:06AM (#17976206)
"...similarly aligned groups oppose voter ID"

Please stop spreading FUD.

All jurisdictions require some kind of ID to receive a ballot.

The issue is dramatically restricting the permitted forms of ID, thereby disenfranchising people.

If the government requires me to have a particular form of ID to vote, then it must provide that ID, for free. Otherwise it's a poll tax, which is unconstitutional.

Re:Georgia says switching back to all-paper voting is logist... by rsj_hn on Thursday September 13, 2018 @03:12AM (#17976652)
> All jurisdictions require some kind of ID to receive a ballot.

That's false.

See http://canadavsamerica.com/voter-id-laws-canada-vs-america/

18 states do not ask for or require ID, including California, New York, and many other large states.

Where I vote in San Francisco, no ID was required. I was shocked, but they just asked for my address. You can register by filling out a form and they mail you a postcard. You sign the postcard and return it via the mail. All I needed was an address.

When I went to the polls, I told them my name and address and that's it. If I gave them someone else's name and address, I could have voted in their name. Then I could have gone to another precinct and voted in another name. There would be no possible way I would have been caught (as there are no cameras there, either).

Unless they tried to vote as well, no one would know. And even if the victim ended up voting later, I wouldn't have been caught as I didn't give any identifier, and since they didn't give an identifier either, and there were no cameras, there would be no way to resolve the issue as to who voted illegally.

Sorry, but I don't view this as a secure system.

You need ID to open a bank account, go to a hotel, rent an apartment, rent a car, get a credit card, pretty much anything at all, but no ID is needed to vote. And it's frankly patronizing to say that people are too poor to obtain ID.

Canada requires a federal ID or two forms of other IDs to vote.

France seems to be OK requiring IDs, with an exception for living in towns with less than 1000 people where everyone knows everyone else.

Germany requires an ID to register, and the polling official can ask you for ID at the polls.

Iceland and Israel require photo IDs.

Interestingly, the only major nations that don't require IDs are the UK, US, and Australia. In Australia, voting is mandatory, though.

Mexico requires an ID to vote, and they have plenty of poor people who are able to obtain IDs.

The Netherlands requires an ID to vote.

Norway requires an ID to vote.

Switzerland requires an ID (but you can also present your ceremonial sword -- WTF)

Belgium requires an ID to vote.

Italy requires an ID to vote. They have poor people there, too. So does Greece (lots of poor there) and Spain.

I don't see why people in the U.S. are so intransigent on this issue -- why are we not willing to learn from the lessons of other advanced nations that seem to be able to hold elections just fine with requiring IDs.

Another problem is standardization. We need standardized elections, with standardized vote counting equipment, processes, registration requirements, etc.

The U.S. is just a huge backwater in this area -- no real chain of custody, no standardization, and no IDs. It's literally a third world system in the U.S. where they might as well give each voter some ink thumbprint. Just a crazy, dysfunctional system where there is no secure binding from identity to registration, or from registration to ballot, or from the ballots in the ballot box to the ballots cast.

Anyways, as someone who comes from Europe where everyone needs an ID, I'm just baffled by how much people are opposing this here.

Re:Georgia says switching back to all-paper voting is logist... by specialist on Thursday September 13, 2018 @08:55AM (#17978196)
"Where I vote in San Francisco, no ID was required. I was shocked, but they just asked for my address. You can register by filling out a form and they mail you a postcard. You sign the postcard and return it via the mail. All I needed was an address."

http://www.ncsl.org/research/elections-and-campaigns/voter-v...

This is no different than postal balloting, which only requires a signature. (Do you also oppose postal balloting? I only ask because every time I've attended an election certification board meeting, there's dozens of irregularities with postal ballots. Which doesn't get any attention.)

You may not consider this sufficient. But myself and many others do. Because the rate of voter fraud is infinitesimal and the legacy of disenfranchisement is huge. As an engineer, you cannot consider the costs & benefits, or the risks & rewards, separately.

All those other nations provide a free national ID. Do you support that in the USA? I do.

Further, in the United States, voters must be registered to vote.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voter_registration_in_the_Unit...

So maybe the semantics are throwing you off. The voter has already been identified. On election day, their identity is being confirmed.

"Another problem is standardization. We need standardized elections, with standardized vote counting equipment, processes, registration requirements, etc."

Agreed.

"The U.S. is just a huge backwater in this area -- no real chain of custody, no standardization, and no IDs."

And now you've lost me.

Re:Georgia says switching back to all-paper voting is logist... by rsj_hn on Thursday September 13, 2018 @06:07PM (#17983090)
>This is no different than postal balloting, which only requires a signature

In principle I don't oppose postal balloting. As implemented, I don't support it, as I think it's not a secure voting system. It would be possible to make it into a secure protocol, though. I am a bit worried about it, frankly.

> All those other nations provide a free national ID. Do you support that in the USA?

Yes, of course. It's crazy we didn't have this 50 years ago.

> And now you've lost me.

We don't have a national id system, or a national voter registry. We don't use a national e-verify system for employment. We don't have national standards for elections. We don't have national standards for voter registration. In one place, there is same day registration, in another you need 60 days. One place uses paper ballots, another doesn't. The system is run by county clerks in backwater places rather than experts at the national level. We are piggy backing social security numbers as a form of authentication, when they are really identifiers and not secrets.

These were all standardized systems adopted in Europe a long time ago. We are completely disorganized in the most important things that are necessary to support the functioning of our democracy. We're even backwards when it comes to simple things like chip and pin.

Re:Georgia says switching back to all-paper voting is logist... by specialist on Thursday September 13, 2018 @06:34PM (#17983299)
FWIW, I oppose postal balloting, except where it improves enfranchisement (eg on demand for disabled, military, overseas). It has all the pitfalls of electronic voting and adds a few new ones. It lowers turnout. [1] It leads to ballot chasing, driving up the costs of campaigns, and alienating voters.

The Oregonians get fluffed up in defense. But everyone thinks their baby is beautiful.

[1] Mail ballots in Washington State now have prepaid postage, which appears to have boosted turnout 3%, restoring turnout to the pre-all mail voting levels. We'll see if that holds.

--

We have national standards. Enforcement is spotty. It sounds like what you want is national administration. At one time, most of us election integrity activists would have probably agreed with you, before the Voting Rights Act was gutted. If our elections could somehow be administered in a non-partisan way... But I just don't see it on the horizon.

--

Chain of custody for paper ballots and gear is the norm. But the best laws, regs, rules mean nothing without civic participation. Administrating and observing elections is a mountain of work. We just don't have enough people stepping up. And election administration nationwide is chronically, notoriously underfunded.

--

Despite the opposition to Real ID, we do have national identifiers. The NSA, Lexis/Nexus (nee Seisent), ChoicePoint, Google, Facebook, others have uniquely identified everyone living and dead, tracked in near real-time. But the US Federal government refuses to leverage, license, nationalize these demographic databases for anything other than terrorist watch lists.

Why?

For one, it'd completely moot the current debates around the census, voter registration databases, immigration, Social Security, etc.

You can't manage what you don't measure. And there are powerful interests who thwart all efforts to measure.

Re:Georgia says switching back to all-paper voting is logist... by rsj_hn on Thursday September 13, 2018 @08:42PM (#17983929)
Well, I am a supporter of Federalism, but I think national level concerns do need to be managed at the national level. To me, basic identification of citizens and holding elections is a national concern.

By the way, I understand the fear that many on the left have for ID cards. I think it's out of date and overblown, but I get it. However, having elections be managed locally does far more to disenfranchise people. Imagine how much more enfranchised people would be with natiowide short term registration (same day if possible, otherwise say 24-48 hours notice), nationwide free ID, and the same standards for availability and access to poll booths. No more shuttering polls in minority areas, no more unwieldy registration requirements. It seems to me that such an overall package of election reforms should appeal to everyone concerned with the poor voting, and they should be able to concede the ID card issue. It's just a strange thing to fixate on, when the real obstacles to voting are not the ID, and when almost everyone else is able to handle having IDs just fine, and in fact IDs are required for the most trivial things nowadays.

I do think, there are privacy and civil liberty issues that need to be addressed, but as you point out, this stuff is happening now anyway, and I'd be much more comfortable with a standardized national ID and registration system that was democratically controlled than by what is happening now and the resulting chaos of our elections. I am not going to even bring up Florida and the hanging chad debacle.

Re:Georgia says switching back to all-paper voting is logist... by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday September 13, 2018 @04:47AM (#17977046)
Voter ID requirements have been proven to disenfranchise poor and ethnic voters time and time again.

https://www.wired.com/story/voter-id-law-algorithm/

Other countries may have different outcomes. But in the US, this isn't up for debate. Factually, and unarguably, the result of requiring voter ID in the US is disenfranchisment.

Re:Georgia says switching back to all-paper voting is logist... by rsj_hn on Thursday September 13, 2018 @05:06AM (#17977131)
They have not been "proven" to do that, and it's certainly up for debate. The very article you cite -- which is very far from a theorem or proof of anything at all -- points out that a very small percent of the population is without ID.

The U.S. is not special, and frankly your claim that this is not up for debate is indicative of a type of intransigence and refusal to both face facts and learn from the success of other nations in this area. So participate in the debate or it will go on without you.

Voter Id are laws are coming, and the debate is just getting louder -- it's time the U.S. joins the modern world and reforms the entire system from top to bottom, and including IDs is a basic building block of building a rational voting system that is based on standardization and chain of custody principles, starting with proof that the person who is voting has a right to do so.

Re:Georgia says switching back to all-paper voting is logist... by expathacker on Thursday September 13, 2018 @04:12AM (#17976896)
Do any of these other countries have the local / state / federal government separation nightmare of the United States, or do they have the same voting standard applied unilaterally for all citizens regardless of location? If not, then they aren't apples to apples comparisons. The American system is 50 different legal bodies, which means 50 governors, 50 senates, N local governments, all doing their best to muck up the system to bend to their own political goals. It's designed to be complicated, which means there can't be an easy answer without re-wiring the entire system.
Re:Georgia says switching back to all-paper voting is logist... by rsj_hn on Thursday September 13, 2018 @05:13AM (#17977158)
Many of these countries have a federal system -- the U.S. is not unique in this regard. In fact, switzerland makes our Federalism pale in comparison. Germany is more federalist. The U.S. is not unique in any way in having a federalist system.

Seriously, I need to keep saying this, but the U.S. is not special. We have no special insight about running elections that allows us to do it better than others. We do not have a monopoly on poor people. We don't have better healthcare, we don't have better police, we don't have better schools, or courts, we don't have better civic institutions more generally, and we certainly don't have better voting standards.

We should learn from the rest of the world and adopt best standards that work well across the OECD. Almost everyone in the OECD requires an ID to vote, and they have a better system, on average. We need to drop this irrational (and frankly, racist) notion that our citizens are unable to obtain IDs because they are too poor or dumb or too disorganized to get them.

Re:Georgia says switching back to all-paper voting is logist... by expathacker on Thursday September 13, 2018 @06:21AM (#17977429)
I'm not sure you understood my point. I am actually in agreement with you that we should be looking to the rest of the world for a voting model that works, because I feel that ours is a failure. I am not advocating against voter-id laws in fact, I am quite for them, but I recognize that these laws in the United States are frequently designed as weapons to be used against members of other parties.

My point is that the rest of the world has exactly 1 legislative body governing elections. America has 51 (perhaps more, I'm not sure to which level of influence local governments can influence electoral processes, but they can certainly influence zoning of polling booths. American resistance to a federal identification card is quite unique, and silly.

Re:Georgia says switching back to all-paper voting is logist... by rsj_hn on Thursday September 13, 2018 @03:28PM (#17981636)
I'm sorry. You are that standardization is a problem. You can have different political organizations oversee the voting process. I'm not saying do away with states. Yet you can have a standardized system.

If we built an interstate highway system and have standardization in rail and roads, we can do this for elections as well.

Re:Georgia says switching back to all-paper voting is logist... by detaro on Thursday September 13, 2018 @08:21AM (#17977995)
> My point is that the rest of the world has exactly 1 legislative body governing elections.

How do you come to that (wrong) conclusion, especially after the parent comment spelled out for you that other countries have similar federal systems?

Re:Georgia says switching back to all-paper voting is logist... by specialist on Thursday September 13, 2018 @10:30AM (#17978864)
"We need to drop this irrational (and frankly, racist) notion that our citizens are unable to obtain IDs because they are too poor or dumb or too disorganized to get them."

Here's a nice writeup about Spread The Vote, one of many orgs helping people get their voter IDs.

https://www.npr.org/2018/09/07/644648955/for-older-voters-ge...

Re:Georgia says switching back to all-paper voting is logist... by specialist on Thursday September 13, 2018 @08:58AM (#17978223)
FWIW, the misc election administrators have been nudging things closer together. One of the benefits of HAVA. In my experience, the EAC has been reality-based.