Perhaps, but no study has yet shown that calorie restriction actually extends human life. It works on lab animals. Given that human lifespans are already relatively long it will take many years to gather reliable data.
Re:Preventing Muscle Loss as We Age
by naasking on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:53AM
(#17970039)
Controlling for weight isn't meaningful if you're not also controlling for body composition.
Re:Preventing Muscle Loss as We Age
by stochastic_monk on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @12:16PM
(#17970271)
You make an interesting point. I glanced over the article and Iām curious: is weight a sufficient proxy for activity/lean body mass? The anecdata I have of athletes generally supports longevity and health, whether training strength or long distance exercise.
Calorie restriction IS perhaps the healthiest route, if you are mainly interested in living longer. Feeling better is harder to quantify. The "TLDR" is: Exercise moderately, and find the minimal amount of calories you can consume without feeling like shit. That's the optimal balance.
The unfortunate reality is that often the "healthiest" path in life, doesn't FEEL the best. I felt my best lifting 3-4x a week, running, and eating 3600-3900 calories per day. I was constantly full, but felt like I had tons of physical and mental energy. Alas, plenty of research has been done on the effects of large calorie diets EVEN WHEN CONTROLLED FOR WEIGHT. Large calories = bad.
If you're interested, here's a good place to start:
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2686342/