News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by shadowfiend on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @08:57PM (#17964754)
This is a perfectly reasonable setup for these agreements. If your spouse is not working and you are married, it is either through mutual agreement or inaction. Fundamentally a marriage is about mutual navigation of life. If you are failing at this, a divorce is an option, as are other avenues (marriage therapy, etc). The point of a* marriage contract working this way is exactly the flip of it: to go extreme, if you are abusive in the relationship and will not let your spouse out of your joint home, and they eventually manage* to get a divorce, they are now attempting to operate without the last N years of work history. How does your spouse get back on their feet now? The person who is taking advantage of the marriage can be the breadwinner, and the breadwinner (if there is only one) provides the means of survival.

Marriage is a life plan. You say that jointly and indefinitely, you will navigate life together. This means both of you are (should be?) planning with both of your current and future states in mind. If one isn't working, they are planning on the other's income to continue life. It's perfectly reasonable for the baseline of a marriage contract to be shared income and a reasonable time to adjust to the loss of shared income should you get divorced (and that this reasonable time grows the longer you are married). You might say, half of the duration is too much! Then propose something better, and adjust the contract accordingly. You might say, that jeopardizes my wedding, it seems like I don't love my future spouse! If this is important to you, that is something you must work through.

Now, it's also an emotional thing, so it can be hard to abandon ship and get a divorce when it's clear your life plans have utterly diverged; I'm not trying to trivialize that decision. But for the default case of marriage to be “you have understood your mutual obligations and the fact that you are embarking on a mutually navigated life” seems perfectly reasonable to me. As for kids… Kids cost money and time, which our society for better or worse equates with money. So of course kids add to the number.

Engineers who make big bucks and “let” (!?) their spouses stay home or pursue careers as ‘”artists”’ (?!?) are making that choice, either explicitly or by not having the conversation. If you don't steer your life, you let your life happen to you. And if you let your life happen to you, sometimes it will happen poorly. If they are having the conversation, then there's mutual agreement that this is what's best for the family, and no one is letting anyone do anything. It's absurd to talk about anyone “letting” their spouse stay home as if they have some sort of ownership over them, or passing judgement on the value of an artistic career choice from the outside.

Is there a human aspect to this, a fuzziness to it all? Of course. But feeling incensed on behalf of others because their marriages are operating in a way you don't approve of because of how you got burned… I don't know how useful that is.

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by 01100011 on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @12:19AM (#17965524)
I spent years trying to convince her to work at something. She sat around on facebook while taking days to do simple tasks like laundry. My family encouraged her. Her friends ridiculed her. Nothing motivated her. She finally got a job folding shirts for a local t-shirt artist 10 hours a week under the table. You make a mistake of thinking I had some way to motivate her to act. We tried counseling and she dismissed the counselor("She's a liberal women who hates stay at home women"). The counselor echoed my feelings that I only wanted a partner in the marriage and not have to carry the burden of literally everything.

How was I supposed to make her work? Cut off her food supply? Put her over my knee? Your comment is naive and frankly offensive.

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by antisthenes on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @07:10AM (#17967284)
Did none of this come up before marriage?

And I don't mean offense by this - I know nothing about your particular situation. But personally, I have trust issues, so I would try to probe my partner in every way possible before committing to marriage, especially in a country where I, the man, stand to lose far more if it doesn't work out.

When some people say "Oh I spent $100k on divorce lawyers" it absolutely horrifies me. $100k is higher than my entire net worth. My first boss probably lost to the tune of $1 million to his ex wife, despite still paying the majority of bills for the kids.

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by 01100011 on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @01:14PM (#17970903)
Before marriage and for the first 10 years of the marriage she had a job(well, there was that couple years where she sat around playing team fortress classic all day.. but still).

I was 21. I didn't know enough to ask the right questions and think ahead.

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by roenxi on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @09:35PM (#17964935)
> It's perfectly reasonable for the baseline of a marriage contract to be shared income and a reasonable time to adjust to the loss of shared income should you get divorced

You are positing a right without a responsibility. Why should a spouse with no earning power be given a free pass on having obligations?

The only answer I would readily accept is that one partner is responsible for earning and the other is responsible for children, but outside that the situation is hard to justify.

> How does your spouse get back on their feet now?

Claiming that being married disqualifies someone from the workforce is a relic of an era that is long past. In the absence of some hefty commitment (ie, children) it isn't true.

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by shadowfiend on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @10:05PM (#17965056)
Your spouse does not have a free pass, you and your spouse have agreed that the family has one of you working and one not. It doesn't require justification beyond that being the mutual agreement, and mutual agreement is how marriage moves forward through time.

Being married doesn't disqualify someone from the workforce, but not working for an extended period of time through the above mutual agreement does leave them with little work history, possibly reduced education, certainly reduced experience, etc. They made those decisions in the context of a reality that is changing due to divorce, and that change can have radical life results. As such, having a default agreement whereby that change is not abrupt and immediate is perfectly reasonable.

A prenuptial agreement modifies this by setting different expectations up front, and allowing everyone involved to adjust their decision-making process.

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by poulsbohemian on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @12:29AM (#17965563)
I think you might be missing something that 01100011 experienced, which frankly sounds a lot like what happened in my case as well. My ex became very mentally ill and had no desire to do anything about it - because she knew that either I would suck it up and carry on for the good of the kids, or that in the case of a divorce that she would walk away with anything she wanted anyway. So she had no incentive to go back to work, to get out of bed, or to do anything at all. Your words sound much like multiple lawyers I consulted, that somehow it was my fault because I was complicit in not forcing her to work. And like 01100011 said, how the eff was I supposed to do that?
Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by Tomte on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @03:24AM (#17966236)
Mental illness is obviously a whole different category.

Would you also slam her as lazy if she got crippled in a car accident?

Have you tried to get her help, in the form of therapy?

That's actually what "in bad times" means. It's probably okay to discover you're not up to the task, but it's not okay to diss her on message boards.

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by poulsbohemian on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:32AM (#17969783)
You are using hyperbole and are reading into the discussion your own meaning. You are being deliberately insulting and using a personal attack, whereas both the parent poster and I experienced a similar behavior from our spouses and faced the same legal dilemma.
Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by Tomte on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:38AM (#17969852)
I'm taking your very literal expression "mentally ill" at face value, as I do your other words. I haven't assumed a single thing, nor have I been injecting "my own meaning".

I'm sorry your marriage ended badly, I'm sure that can be very stressful.

But the only insults here are yours.

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by poulsbohemian on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @12:35AM (#17965585)
>Why should a spouse with no earning power be given a free pass on having obligations?

Completely agreed, and yet having just gone through this, I assure you the State has no problem telling you just that. At least in my state, the view is that each party should be put into a situation as much like what they had during the marriage as possible. Unfortunately the way the courts have interpreted this is that a non-working spouse is deemed to have been the childcare provider, therefore they have more rights to the children plus should be compensated with the same quality of life as before. This of course means that the working spouse cannot possibly ever have the life they had previously, because they will now be forking over nearly all of their income (seriously- I know of a local case where their child support obligation was more than their actual income) to that non-working party. Likewise, it's silly for the court to think things will ever be "the same" - unless there are sizable assets, of course the non-working spouse will have to go back to work!

So yes, I would like to agree with your statement that "Claiming that being married disqualifies someone from the workforce is a relic of an era that is long past" but unfortunately this is still the case in some (many? most? I don't know) states. Even nominally progressive ones.

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by cm2012 on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @09:53PM (#17965009)
> You are positing a right without a responsibility. Why should a spouse with no earning power be given a free pass on having obligations?

Because it's not actually a business contract. You don't have to "give your spouse a free pass", you can divorce her if she stops earning as much as you want her to. But that sounds sociopathic to me assuming you're not struggling financially.

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by thrownaway1337 on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @09:13PM (#17964820)
> planning with both of your current and future states in mind

This is what is so difficult about marriage. You sign up for a lifetime commitment, but no one plans their life 100% in advance. People change, desires change, realities change.

Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by afthonos on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @09:26PM (#17964892)
Sure, but GP is saying that constant planning is the deal. You constantly plan, reassess, and most importantly communicate. And you are always aware of the current conditions of the deal, the opportunity cost, etc. Are you in a bad marriage but hope it'll get better? The opportunity cost is X more years to have to pay alimony if you get divorced. Decide accordingly.
Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by thrownaway1337 on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @09:32PM (#17964925)
But then why do it in the first place? If you want to have the optionality to constantly plan, reassess, and communicate why would you bind yourself into a legal agreement that limits your ability to do that?
Re:The Marriage Decision: Everything Forever or Nothing Ever... by afthonos on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @09:44PM (#17964981)
Because there are tangible legal and social benefits to doing so, including hospital visitation rights, insurance, etc, as well the ability to live in harmony with people you love whose social expectations are that you get married. This is important to many people—especially if they have found a partner that they can conceive of spending a lifetime with.