News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Has an uncomfortable truth been suppressed? by tptacek on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:02PM (#17956420)
I've been a part of the program committees for a couple scholarly journal editions over the past two decades and in none of them were individual reviewers given the ability to accept or decline papers. At Usenix a few years ago, the practice was that everybody reviewed everything, and the program chairs (I was one) essentially counted votes and managed discussions. That was also the impression I got doing this for an ACM/IEEE journal in the early 2000s.

(It is, for whatever it's worth to you, also essentially the practice at Black Hat USA, which gets thousands of submissions every year --- albeit the review board is separated out into tracks with their own covering reviewers. But BH Cryptography, for instance, has 10 cryptographer reviewers, and they reviewed everything on the track).

Can I ask, from where did you get the impression that it was typical for an individual member of a review board to get assigned a paper and pass/fail it, or for any one review board member to have the authority to accept a paper?

Re:Has an uncomfortable truth been suppressed? by kgwgk on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:15PM (#17956471)
Re:Has an uncomfortable truth been suppressed? by tptacek on Monday September 10, 2018 @09:22PM (#17956502)
From that article:

Editors normally invite more than one reviewer to evaluate a scientific manuscript.

Re:Has an uncomfortable truth been suppressed? by kgwgk on Monday September 10, 2018 @10:01PM (#17956667)
As I said, it may be one of the members of the editorial board that acts as editor, sends the paper to the peer reviewers (only one in the case of the NYJM) and decides to accept or reject the paper (or ask for revisions) based on their report.

Even if there were two referees instead of one, they are usually external and not members of the editorial board. And you could still believe that no peer review was done or suspect that both referees were the handling editor himself.

Apparently in this case the final decision is taken by the editor-in-chief. Other academic journals may have other policies and maybe in some cases the whole editorial board is involved in every publication but I don’t think it’s usual.