News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by gooddelta on Monday September 10, 2018 @12:30AM (#17949388)
Yeah, definitely no advertising, particularly overseas, that could have contributed to WhatsApp's growth. No features added like large groups that could be used to spread disinformation. WhatsApp chats are used to influence advertising, so that goes out the window. This happened because WhatsApp provided the means for it to happen – and you can speculate all day long about whether some other app would have made it possible, and whether it would have happened, but what you're saying is speculation, and what I'm citing are facts.

None of it was intentionally malicious – but not considering the moral, ethical, political ramifications of how your product will be used is negligent. This is negligence, not malice.

Platforms aren't neutral.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by stickfigure on Monday September 10, 2018 @12:48AM (#17949450)
The logical conclusion of this perspective is that human beings should not be allowed to freely communicate in groups. I'd rather not live in your world.

Technology can't fix broken human beings. There is a moral failure here, but it isn't Facebook's. Blaming WhatsApp at best makes the real problem harder to fix, and at worst makes excuses for the actors in this horrorshow.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by gooddelta on Monday September 10, 2018 @12:53AM (#17949471)
Speed and reach, my friend. Lynchings happened in the US a while ago, but they weren't a universal phenomenon. A platform with the speed and reach of WhatsApp makes disinformation more potent.

Nowhere in my post did I suggest human beings shouldn't be allowed to freely communicate – what I'm suggesting is that maybe we haven't built the right tools to enable that safely, and instead, we're exacerbating the "broken human beings" side of this issue.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by lxrbst on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:04AM (#17949508)
> we're exacerbating the "broken human beings" side of this issue.

There is no other side of this issue. This could and probably have happened with sms. This is 100% the mob's fault.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by user111233 on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:54AM (#17949677)
SMS costs a lot in 3rd world countries. We are probably seeing these issues now because this is the first time these people have had access to cheap and easy communication. The rest of the world was eased in to it with email and the web but these countries are being dropped in to the deep end.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by stickfigure on Monday September 10, 2018 @04:03PM (#17954732)
Subtext: You primitives aren't mature enough to communicate in groups without supervision.

Don't you find that an offensively paternalistic thing to tell whole societies?

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by solveit on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:21AM (#17949564)
By that logic we should ban megaphones as well.

You know what? Just ban shouting until people build the right tools to enable that safely.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by mijamo on Monday September 10, 2018 @07:04AM (#17950854)
Well if you start using a megaphone to encourage killing people you will have troubles in a few minutes. With whatsapp... Not that much. Whatsapp is probably the first medium of communication that is harf to monitor in many places. It is much safer to encourage hatred and violence there because you don't need physical interaction, it scales a lot and authorities cannot intercept it.
[dead]
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by tepidandroid on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:58AM (#17949690)
Actually all i’ve seen you do in this thread is moralize about the use of technology. You haven’t really offered any solution to the problem at all, aside from suggesting that technologists ‘think about it more’ before creating such platforms.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by dang on Monday September 10, 2018 @02:25AM (#17949781)
You've repeatedly broken the site guidelines in this thread. We ban accounts that do that, so can you please not do that? Someone else being wrong is no reason to break the rules.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

(I do appreciate that you apologized for going over the line in the previous comment.)

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by gooddelta on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @12:46AM (#17957234)
I apologize if it appears I've stepped out of line, or if this thread has been difficult for you to moderate; that wasn't the intention.

If you go back to my first comment on this post, it seems reasonably clear that my message is not particularly contentious – I'm simply suggesting that people apply some amount of ethical rigor to their work. Sadly, that message was heavily twisted in all sorts of ways that somehow fit within this site's guidelines.

Ethics and politics are indivisible from the act of creating software. It clearly stands to reason that software is fractal of the beliefs of the people that create it. By placing intellectual curiosity on a pedestal above morals and ethics, HN has managed to drive away some of the most talented and credible people in the industry from this site – and to promulgate a culture of no accountability for what we do, or fail to do.

I've fought year-long battles that have come close to costing me my job, just so I could prevent inaccuracies in systems that likely process your credit score. I've consciously killed projects that would disadvantage entire groups of people, no matter how technically cool or interesting they were. In much the same way that I'm not willing to negligently let someone die, I'm also unwilling to be part of the next Manhattan project – but it's becoming clear to me that I'm in the minority of the Hacker News readership that feels that way, or has ever even considered the impact of their work.

Over the past ten years, the attitude of this community has single-handedly convinced me that the end of our world will be because somebody could, so they did. If we can create "deep fakes" on demand, we will. If we can patrol the border with some hastily slapped-together CV and ML, we will. If we can use deep learning to decide who will go to prison, we will. All under the guise of intellectual curiosity.

I honestly believed tech was a good thing at one point in my career – now I spend most of my time building systems to protect people from my peers.

I know I can't delete my account here yet – I've tried. But I've never felt more disconnected from a community I'm supposed to be a part of.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by nradov on Monday September 10, 2018 @02:22AM (#17949766)
What are the right tools?
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by lxrbst on Monday September 10, 2018 @12:43AM (#17949434)
It's a chat application. How people can be so ignorant to abuse such a simple thing is beyond me. As much as I hate Facebook, I don't get how you can put this on WhatsApp.

From the looks of it, you could've achieved the same thing with someone printing and spreading around fliers. Doesn't mean a printing company selling printers should consider the "moral, ethical, political ramifications".

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by gooddelta on Monday September 10, 2018 @12:56AM (#17949484)
Printing creates a barrier to entry. You have to have enough conviction in your idea, and the determination to actually write the statement, lay it out, and print and distribute it. You don't just type "oh shit lxrbst should be hanged lmao," hit send, and reach 100 people.

You're basically describing why journalism is important, and still has an important place in our society.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by sooheon on Monday September 10, 2018 @02:34AM (#17949828)
Journalism is important, but not to the exclusion of other forms of communication. If your thrust is that barriers to entry for communication is good because it puts mass comm. powers in the hands of the few(er), I cannot agree.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by mijamo on Monday September 10, 2018 @07:05AM (#17950863)
Ironic to post such a comment in a platform that puts a high barrier for communication through moderation and guidelines.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by cwyers on Monday September 10, 2018 @12:33AM (#17949401)
Okay, but what about WhatsApp made this possible that wouldn't have been possible with plain old SMS/MMS? (Or even just the telephone? I guess no video over the telephone, but rumors and lies can certainly spread that way.) It's not like Facebook, where there's some kind of algorithmic curation. This is entirely peer-to-peer content distribution.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by Tempest1981 on Monday September 10, 2018 @02:48AM (#17949872)
Sounds like the videos were very shocking and quickly forwarded - instigating a mob mentality:

“each said they’d done so after watching shocking videos on WhatsApp warning of outsiders abducting children.”

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by robjan on Monday September 10, 2018 @12:34AM (#17949408)
How are WhatsApp chats used to influence advertising? They are end to end encrypted.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by gooddelta on Monday September 10, 2018 @12:46AM (#17949443)
That's partially true – but end-to-end encryption is different than zero-knowledge. I design the latter.

Although LifeHacker isn't a great source, they do a good job of pulling more credible sources together into this article: https://lifehacker.com/stop-using-whatsapp-if-you-care-about...

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by nradov on Monday September 10, 2018 @02:21AM (#17949762)
A chat app is about as neutral as platforms get. What specifically should they have done differently?