News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by jasonlfunk on Monday September 10, 2018 @12:06AM (#17949312)
This is terrible but blaming WhatsApp is misplaced. If it wasn't WhatsApp, it would have been another service. Either it will be easy to communicate or it won't be. If it is, it can be used as a force for good or a force for evil. The real problem is so much more difficult that it's easy to try to find something you can do, block the technology, so you feel like you are doing something even if it's completely ignoring the root of the issue.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by abalone on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:18AM (#17949553)
> This is terrible but blaming WhatsApp is misplaced. If it wasn't WhatsApp, it would have been another service.

I feel this is a worthwhile piece. It spends considerable time exploring the issues of end-to-end encryption and enhanced privacy and their relationship to the problem of lynchings. It details how whatsapp became more than a mere P2P messaging service in this community. It was the primary source of news, like Facebook but completely private and impervious to intervention. Thus all the negative stuff we've heard about how FB affected our elections, which everybody is ok with "blaming FB" for.. imagine that 10X and actually facilitating lynchings.

Often we've heard that "terrorists will just use another service" but lynch mobs are a different case much more closely tied to the popularity of a social network. WhatsApp has become that and it has also led the charge to make everything super private and impervious to law enforcement.

To be clear, I completely see the positive aspects of E2E encrypted systems and welcome them in my life. But I think it we should support journalistic explorations of the consequences of these systems, especially as they grow beyond simple P2P communication and become the primary source of news in a community, which is the case here.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by rishav_sharan on Monday September 10, 2018 @02:11AM (#17949728)
The real problem in this instance is not technology but a lack of education. Whatsapp is of course an enabler and an easy scapegoat. But mob lynchings have been happening in India's backwards areas for decades. People used to beat up "witches", "thieves" etc to death for long before Whatsapp was a thing. People would kill their own children because a "Godman" told them so.

This will keep on happening whether they police whatapp or block it altogether unless these people are educated and are allowed to develop a modicum of trust in the law enforcement agencies.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by pluma on Monday September 10, 2018 @05:16AM (#17950452)
So when Indians believe propaganda and kill a group of travelers, that's a lack of education.

What is it when white Americans invade an Italian restaurant in search of child abuse or harass firefighters and grieving parents while accusing them of being "crisis actors"?

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by beaconstudios on Monday September 10, 2018 @08:30AM (#17951288)
it's not lack of education in either case. It's just how people are. You believe lies, I believe lies, everyone does - the only reason we feel we can point at mob lynchings and say "backwards!" but look at our own problems (e.g. political riots) and say otherwise is because of differences in culture and perspective.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by rapnie on Monday September 10, 2018 @03:02AM (#17949937)
> The real problem in this instance is not technology but a lack of education.

But WA could certainly help with this education, maybe in the same sense it educates you that a conversation is E2E encrypted. The app could easily provide a clear warning and an additional page with concrete examples of abuse/misuse and dangers.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by beaconstudios on Monday September 10, 2018 @08:32AM (#17951302)
people have a tendency to ignore in-app warnings. Steam puts at message at the top of every chat telling you not to give out your password, but after noticing it once or twice it just blends into the background. The lesson won't stay in the forefront of your mind.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by antoinevg on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:34AM (#17949611)
The thing is... around fifteen years ago there was still at least a semblance of support for folk who were researching these very problems.

When the current culture of "hyper growth at all costs" promulgated by the unholy trinity of goo-face-azons came along they were the first to be made to feel unwelcome.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by reitanqild on Monday September 10, 2018 @12:24AM (#17949367)
Agree. As much as I don't like Facebook and by extension WhatsApp[0] I still think we should be fair.

[0]: to the point where I've encouraged (or rather tried to convince) groups moving to other channels.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by gaius on Monday September 10, 2018 @12:58AM (#17949490)
Either it will be easy to communicate or it won't be.

But ease-of-use is only one product dimension. Different tools encourage different modes of communication. The kind of discourse and the use cases of tool A and tool B will be different and which is better depends on what outcome you are trying to achieve - substantive debates for the good of humanity, or “engagement”.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by gooddelta on Monday September 10, 2018 @12:13AM (#17949331)
That's the entire problem with this industry – we make the assumption that someone less ethical than us will come along and build the shitty product anyway, and use that as justification to do something we likely shouldn't.

Blaming WhatsApp is misplaced, in some sense – the blame lies with startup culture, and with each of us that choose to make that excuse.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by p1necone on Monday September 10, 2018 @12:47AM (#17949447)
Are you suggesting that basic text communication apps should not exist?

This is fundamentally very very simple functionality - there's no social media algorithms surfacing different content to different people or anything like that.

Are you seriously advocating that we should just disallow digital communication. (Not to mention advocating it using digital communication)

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by toofy on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:29AM (#17949590)
I didn’t get the sense that they were implying chat messengers should cease to exist. While they certainly could have been more explicit, I think that’s a rather uncharitable interpretation.

The larger conversation seems to be revolving around the question of “While we continue to build these infrastructures, are we currently—in a serious way— searching for ways to mitigate against these types of things from happening? And if not, why not?”

Which, from what we’re seeing— with how vulnerable many segments of populations seem to be, with misinformation and these types of mob behaviors—this is a timely and important question.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by user111233 on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:46AM (#17949648)
There are multiple organizations trying to find ways to stop misinformation but it seems next to impossible. What is the truth? Who gets to decide what is and isn't the truth? No doubt Google will come up with some API that reports if a statement is true or not and all algorithms will use it to hide any information google says is false.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by closeparen on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:10AM (#17949518)
"The shitty product" is text chat. We "likely shouldn't" build text chat? Startup culture is morally defective because it built text chat, and we share in the moral capability by "making excuses" for text chat?
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by p1necone on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:16AM (#17949545)
Exactly. This is the tired old pattern of "humans do human things and technology is coincidentally involved because we live in the 21st century, obviously it's the technologies fault."
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by user111233 on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:47AM (#17949654)
In many cases is genuinely is the technologies fault when it uses UI patterns to shape behavior and algorithmic sorting to selectively show ideas to the user. But that is not the case here.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by Tempest1981 on Monday September 10, 2018 @02:42AM (#17949858)
The article mentions forwarded hoax videos:

“each said they’d done so after watching shocking videos on WhatsApp warning of outsiders abducting children.”

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by sometimesijust on Monday September 10, 2018 @12:40AM (#17949427)
> "They said that as long as their children are safe, they have no regrets." [The lawyers of the murderers]

While in general I agree that everyone should share responsibility for maintaining a safe society that very feeling seems to be what these murderers were operating on. Given the lack of remorse I think it is clear that there is a deeper issue than unfiltered efficient communication in these communities.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by mwfunk on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:44AM (#17949643)
In this case, I would blame lynch mob culture, not startup culture. No matter how these people received their misinformation, what they did was infinitely worse.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by projektir on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:53AM (#17949674)
Yes, I don't see how this is on WhatsApp in the slightest unless we're going to say communication apps shouldn't exist...
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by ryandrake on Monday September 10, 2018 @12:43AM (#17949437)
There's no shortage of ignorance and gullibility offline--it's not something that was just invented with social media. It's easier to blame "startup culture" than have a hard look at the unpleasant parts of one's own culture.

> "Mob lynching isn’t a new phenomenon in India. According to some reports, there were more than 2,000 lynchings in India between 2000 and 2012 — well before WhatsApp was around."

I don't know, crazy idea: Maybe the blame should fall on... the people who think it's OK to lynch strangers.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by sterlind on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:26AM (#17949581)
The article makes it clear that the people of Rainpada are extremely uneducated, many lack literacy and tend to trust their tight-knit social groups. They don't see many locals, and they genuinely believed the strangers were harvesting organs. Try hard, and imagine being completely naive to internet hoaxes, and not even knowing how to read and write (note that the video had audio dubbing, precisely to target unsophisticated viewers.)

Western businesses don't have an inherent right to market their products in India. Group messenger apps, at least those lacking in sovereign moderation powers, are clearly causing harm in illiterate/hoax-naive demographics. Is India getting a deal that outweighs the human costs of violence, or should they develop their own?

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by user111233 on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:43AM (#17949639)
If the government thinks the locals are unable to handle the internet then it should either educate them or restrict the usage.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by sterlind on Monday September 10, 2018 @02:33AM (#17949824)
they cut off internet access for 24 hours following the murder, and within two hours ordered the local news channel to air an admonishment about the misinformation on repeat, along with a warning for prosecution for further spreading it.

the village is now a ghost-town; most of the men fled, and the women and children stay inside. elders are ashamed to mention their hometown.

there are two educational efforts: the police have posted numerous warning signs in public areas, and a group of students are traveling around giving a play to demonstrate how spreading rumors on WhatsApp caused a lynching.

in addition to those efforts, what can WhatsApp do to keep this from happening? India is doing their part. If WhatsApp thinks it's unable to handle the situation, they should turn administrative control of their service over to the government.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by davchana on Monday September 10, 2018 @02:42AM (#17949854)
WhatsApp already took some actions after getting forced by government. Now, in India, a user can not forward a message on WhatsApp to more than 5 contacts in one go. Earlier it was select as many as you wish, but now you can choose only 5 contacts.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by sterlind on Monday September 10, 2018 @05:21AM (#17950469)
That change only affects the latest version of the app. Only a single phone among those surveyed in the village by BuzzFeed was running the latest version. I'm not sure what Facebook can do about it technically, but the change won't be effective any time soon.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by gooddelta on Monday September 10, 2018 @12:49AM (#17949453)
You're not wrong – part of the blame obviously lies there.

But even if it is simply enabling and perpetuating an existing problem, why haven't we asked ourselves why technology isn't addressing the issue? How is this future we've created any better? Because it's faster? Because the UI is nicer?

It's rare to see startup culture produce anything that I would call true innovation. Maybe I just have a higher bar than most folks. That could be what I'm arguing here, and that doesn't change the fact that you have a point – I just believe we have to do better.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by ryandrake on Monday September 10, 2018 @12:56AM (#17949483)
Yea, I happen to agree with that too. Although I don't think WhatsApp is necessarily an unethical software, far too often, we see stories here of startups and bigger technology companies, totally tossing ethics aside in search of their "engagement" or "reach" or whatever stupid metric they're chasing. As software engineers "on the inside", we have both an obligation and unique opportunity to stop these things before they start. Or at the very least not contribute toward it.

For every unethical piece of software that gets written, there's at least one engineer... one of us, maybe even someone reading this very post... who said "Sure, boss, I could totally write that!"

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by esalman on Monday September 10, 2018 @02:31AM (#17949811)
This argument is invalid. Even more so after what happened in the 2016 US election. Silicon valley companies created the beast(s), they have an ethical obligation to tame it.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by IBM on Monday September 10, 2018 @12:49AM (#17949455)
>The real problem is so much more difficult that it's easy to try to find something you can do, block the technology, so you feel like you are doing something even if it's completely ignoring the root of the issue.

Blocking WhatsApp would be a perfectly justifiable solution! Regulating it would be as well. Facebook and Google want to airdrop their products into all of these emerging markets for growth, ignoring all the negative externalities until someone holds them accountable. None of these countries need to be fatalist about technology or these companies.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by stordoff on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:28AM (#17949587)
How is blocking WhatsApp justifiable (or indeed useful -- this could be accomplished with more or less any communications app)?

I know it pails in comparison, but the London riots of a few years ago were (in part) organised over BlackBerry Messenger. I don't recall many on HN advocating for blocking BlackBerry Messenger. I feel this comment from the time applies as much here as it did there:

> Neither Blackberry, Twitter, nor Facebook fuelled the fire under London's riots, any more than the internet, radio waves, or electricity did. Violent, hateful people did that.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by p1necone on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:17AM (#17949548)
WhatsApp is a text chat app. You are advocating just banning digital communication. This is inane.

If you're actually serious I'd love to hear your justification, but I feel like you just haven't thought about this very hard.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by gooddelta on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:25AM (#17949576)
Dude, nobody is arguing that we should ban digital communications at all. Take off the tinfoil hat, chicken little. What I'm suggesting is that if we are going to make PLATFORMS available (i.e. WhatsApp) that are capable of amplifying and making individual communications instantaneous, we mightttt need some more thought, collectively, about how to combat fucked up human nature. Like, just a pinch of consideration for the fact that the notion of free speech didn't evolve during a time in which any asshole could pull a thought out of their ass, hit send, anonymously, and reach a thousand people.

EDIT: Sorry, I realize that I was speaking condescendingly here. I'm just trying to get the point across that asking us to actually solve the hard problem of platforms before unleashing them on the world shouldn't be too big a burden to bear. Some (myself included) would argue that our entire society is destabilizing because of the lack of ingenuity in solving this problem. It gets frustrating.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by closeparen on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:37AM (#17949619)
The “lack of ingenuity” in regulating speech is a hard-fought, hard-won tenet of liberal democracy that a citizen ought to be willing to sacrifice his life to protect. Arguments about the need for paternalistic stewardship to protect the masses from their flawed human nature are bog-standard apologia from authoritarian regimes seeking to justify repression.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by gooddelta on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:45AM (#17949646)
Did I say "regulating speech"? No. If we're going to try to have a cogent conversation, please stop putting words in my mouth.

Free speech != the right to a platform, which is synonymous with saying that, just because you have a voice doesn't mean your message has immediate merit, or that it is the truth, or that people have to give your voice equal weight to others, or that people have to listen to you.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by closeparen on Monday September 10, 2018 @02:22AM (#17949768)
You cannot compel a platform to carry a message against its will. This is true.

Restricting the messages a platform may carry according to the state's view of merit or truth, on the other hand, is exactly "regulating speech."

EDIT: To be clear, I am responding in the context of the upthread "Blocking WhatsApp would be a perfectly justifiable solution! Regulating it would be as well." Your argument seems less puzzling in the context of the very different assertion that Whatsapp itself should exercise editorial control. Apologies if this is what you meant.

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by cwyers on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:52AM (#17949671)
The problem is that there's no solution to "deplatforming" people who incite lynch mobs that also doesn't give the power to "deplatform" peaceful protest against repressive regimes. You can't come up with a knife that only cuts what you want it to cut.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by sooheon on Monday September 10, 2018 @02:31AM (#17949813)
I'm pretty sure poster above is taking for granted that they (or other like-minded) would also wield the knife.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by cwyers on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:41AM (#17949632)
What if there aren't any technical solutions that are likely to work, and no top-down regulatory solutions that are likely to be worth the cost? What if the only mitigation that works is "culture change?" Culture change is messy and slow and self-directed.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by closeparen on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:17AM (#17949549)
Accountable... for letting people send text to each other?

Shall we block or regulate the printing press? Hold its inventors and users accountable for its negative externalities? After all, none of these countries/churches need to be fatalistic about the printed word or these heretics...

Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by gooddelta on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:22AM (#17949568)
Printing creates a barrier to entry. You have to have enough conviction in your idea and determination to actually write the statement, lay it out, and print and distribute it. You don't just type "oh shit closeparen should be hanged lmao," hit send, and reach 100 people.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by dang on Monday September 10, 2018 @02:25AM (#17949778)
Please don't copy and paste what you posted elsewhere. That lowers the signal/noise ratio.
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by user111233 on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:51AM (#17949668)
So we should just ban the internet because some village in india couldn't use it right?
Re:How WhatsApp Destroyed a Village by dang on Monday September 10, 2018 @02:23AM (#17949773)
This comment breaks the site guidelines, which ask: "Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize."

If you'd review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and follow the rules when posting here, we'd appreciate it.