News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I survived the Warsaw ghetto. Here are the lessons I’d li... by botverse on Sunday September 09, 2018 @05:01PM (#17947767)
EDIT

Seen the backlash I’m getting with the comment, would like to clarify that what sparked it was this sentence:

> "No nation has a monopoly on virtue – something that many people, including many of my fellow Israeli citizens, still struggle to understand."

Where the author seems to hint to consider all that follows himself.

TIDE

Very powerful message. I would really want to know what Aronson thinks about the situation in Israel with the Palestinians. Of course not to compare the fate of the Jewish people during the savage years of the Holocaust with this of the Palestinians. But Israel seems to have forgotten the humanity of the Palestinians, striping them from their human rights, or passing laws that could affect the rights of Israeli minorities [0].

Obviously condemning the actions of terrorists, atrocities committed against the people of Israel by Palestinians, and that deserving it’s own discussion, just pointing out that because the number of dead Palestinian people is relevant enough and the author who fought for and lives in Israel, was speaking of when countries do dehumanize people and was hoping that in this case there would be voices in Israel that could disagree with the current situation.

[0] - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_Law:_Israel_as_the_Nat...

Re:I survived the Warsaw ghetto. Here are the lessons I’d li... by edanm on Monday September 10, 2018 @08:06AM (#17951132)
No offense intended (really!), but you're talking about a very complicated situation, which it appears that you don't really understand fully.

> But Israel seems to have forgotten the humanity of the Palestinians, striping them from their human rights, or passing laws that could affect the rights of Israeli minorities [0].

The situation of the Palestinians is terrible, IMO. But there is simply no simple solution that anyone has for how to solve it. Sure, some Israelis are terrible people, and are racist, etc, as are many Americans, Europeans, etc. But as a whole, the reason the Palestinian situation continues is partly because no one really has a good answer to how to solve it! It's probably also partly because Israel has more power right now, and the feeling is that the longer the situation continues, the better for Israel, so why not let it drag out? But if there were a decent solution, many people in Israel would push very hard to implement it. The truth is, most Israelis just don't know what to do anymore (and solutions have been tried before, negotiations have happened).

And btw, the new law that you talk about isn't really going to affect Palestinians so much as minority citizens of Israel (and it probably won't actually affect them either, it's more a symbolic thing I think).

> just pointing out that because the number of dead Palestinian people is relevant enough and the author who fought for and lives in Israel, was speaking of when countries do dehumanize people and was hoping that in this case there would be voices in Israel that could disagree with the current situation.

If you think there aren't voices in Israel who disagree with the current situation, you're very wrong. Unfortunately, as I said, many people have "given up", or at least have no idea what to do anymore.

Re:I survived the Warsaw ghetto. Here are the lessons I’d li... by botverse on Monday September 10, 2018 @08:44AM (#17951363)
No offence taken.

> But there is simply no simple solution that anyone has for how to solve it.

I think the problem can be less complicated if there is a sincere open conversation around it.

Let's put some context. In 1948 lots of people were dispossessed of their land and properties, this is still a very controversial thing that is very difficult to talk about. Just go to Jaffa in Israel and ask any Israeli person living in an Arab looking house how their family got to own it and you will realise how of a taboo subject this is. Of course there is no reparations or right of return in the pipeline of the talks.

So the first step to solve a problem is realising of it's existence. Instead, Israel seems to continue putting pressure onto the Palestinians with the appropriation of more land and the creation of more settlements [0].

[0] - https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-45276555

Re:I survived the Warsaw ghetto. Here are the lessons I’d li... by edanm on Monday September 10, 2018 @04:42PM (#17955038)
> I think the problem can be less complicated if there is a sincere open conversation around it.

While I wish that was true, I don't think it is.

For one thing, I don't think the subject is nearly as taboo as you imagine - Israelis love to talk politics, after all!

However I think that most Israelis would disagree with your characterization of what happened in '48. The (I think typical) view is that the UN decided to split Israel into two states, one for Jews and one for Palestinians. However, the Arab countries urged the Palestinians to leave Israel, as they were preparing to attack Israel. They attacked, Israel won, and ended up with all the original land, with most of the Palestinians having fled to neighboring countries in the meantime. Israel didn't really do anything wrong - it simply won a war, which would likely have ended up with Israel destroyed if it had lost. Reparations wouldn't really make sense in that view. (That summary is basically my view of the history as I understand it, so assume the summary would probably be told differently by someone with a different opinion.)

The other issue with your statement is that even with open conversation around this issue wouldn't really change anything. At the end of the day, the right of return is something that simply can't be granted, not if Israel wants to remain a Jewish country, which is the entire reason it was founded (and in my view, in light of the historical precedents, a totally valid and moral reason). And Israelis simply don't trust the Palestinians with having a state right next to it - which probably doesn't matter much, since Palestinians don't appear to accept such a solution either.

So simply saying "well let's just talk about it and it will work out" is ignoring the fact that, no, there probably isn't a solution right now that both sides will find acceptable, unfortunately, and the structural forces of the situation are probably such that nothing will change anyway (e.g. as I said, Israel being in power and thinking it's probably better to delay action on this as much as possible, Hamas being in power in Gaza and preferring to keep the situation mostly as is).

Re:I survived the Warsaw ghetto. Here are the lessons I’d li... by Udik on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @05:05AM (#17958162)
> The (I think typical) view is that the UN decided to split Israel into two states, one for Jews and one for Palestinians. However, the Arab countries urged the Palestinians to leave Israel, as they were preparing to attack Israel.

Haha. No. The UN decided to split Palestine in two states, giving half of it to the Jews. Of course the Jews had everything to gain from this partition and the Palestinians everything to lose, since they were the sole owners of the place. Of course they rejected the partition and there was a war, but the Palestinians have been actively expelled by the Israeli army. In fact, 200 thousand of them had already fled their villages before Israel's declaration of independence, to escape from violence- episodes like that of Deir Yassin, where a Jewish commando massacred the inhabitants of a Palestinian village- women and children included-, throwing grenades inside the houses. It was a proper ethnic cleansing operation.

> Israel didn't really do anything wrong

No, as far as ethnic cleansing goes, Israel didn't do anything wrong.

> At the end of the day, the right of return is something that simply can't be granted, not if Israel wants to remain a Jewish country

I agree with this. However, I also think that the right of return is mostly aspirational, and given good will on Israel's part, the issue could be just ignored long enough until it's not an issue anymore. By good will on Israel's part, I mean: establish a border once and for all (on the green line), abandon all settlements beyond that border, either renounce completely to Jerusalem east or share the undivided capital with a Palestinian state, completely remove the blockade of Gaza (and create a wide corridor between Gaza and the West Bank). Stop opposing the creation of a Palestinian state, and contribute to it with aids and reparations (that would make up for the right of return).

You'll say: this is a lot to ask from Israel. And it is, because Israel is currently enjoying great profits from its illegal and immoral actions, and there will be no end to the conflict until it decides to abide to international law and moral standards.

Re:I survived the Warsaw ghetto. Here are the lessons I’d li... by edanm on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @07:55AM (#17958852)
> Haha. No. The UN decided to split Palestine in two states, giving half of it to the Jews.

You're right of course, I misspoke, it wasn't yet Israel.

> Of course the Jews had everything to gain from this partition and the Palestinians everything to lose, since they were the sole owners of the place.

I'm not sure that's true - the territory was under British control, then was given over to the UN.

> Of course they rejected the partition and there was a war, but the Palestinians have been actively expelled by the Israeli army. In fact, 200 thousand of them had already fled their villages before Israel's declaration of independence, to escape from violence- episodes like that of Deir Yassin, where a Jewish commando massacred the inhabitants of a Palestinian village- women and children included-, throwing grenades inside the houses. It was a proper ethnic cleansing operation.

Look, this is, to say the least, disputed. I'm not going to say I know any more than you about this - and I think even the most pro-Israeli version of events would still leave a lot of Israelis looking pretty bad (Deir Yassin being one obvious and horrific example). Many of the more pro-Israeli historians will point out the calls from Arab leaders for Palestinians to flee, the pretty clear reasoning that if the Arab countries had won the war, most likely Israel would have been largely exterminated, given even more reason for the Palestinians to flee, etc. I don't either of us can know for sure just how much of the Palestinians fleeing was because of Israeli actions, real fear, imagined fear, or what.

Still, even after all this - is what happened so unprecedented by historical standards that leaves most people singling out Israel as a particularly immoral country? I mean, barely 3 years earlier WW2 had ended, in which millions were killed, in bombing of civilian populations, in the use of nuclear weapons, and in many other ways. Do you consider Germany to be an immoral country today because of what they did during WW2? Or England, the States, Japan? What bothers me is the (seeming) double standard, where people consider Israel to be so much worse, for doing so much less than almost any other country. The main reason we're still talking about this is because there are a lot of vested interests in keeping the Palestinian population in their terrible situation (including Israeli interests, but not only!). The birth of Israeli was far less terrible than many contemporary episodes (e.g. the situation in Syria, in which the death toll was sometimes as high as 10k per day iirc; not to say that this is the bar I set for Israel).

> By good will on Israel's part, I mean: establish a border once and for all (on the green line), abandon all settlements beyond that border, either renounce completely to Jerusalem east or share the undivided capital with a Palestinian state, completely remove the blockade of Gaza (and create a wide corridor between Gaza and the West Bank) [...] You'll say: this is a lot to ask from Israel. And it is, because Israel is currently enjoying great profits from its illegal and immoral actions [...]

First a minor point - the blockage isn't Israel's alone. It's also Egypt's.

Secondly - I personally agree with a lot of your points and wish Israel behaved differently. E.g. I think the settlements are terrible. I understand why many people support them from a real-politick perspective (and of course some support them from a religious/"greater Israel" perspective too). Many Israelis don't support the settlements, but the right has been in power here for a long time.

Still, you're ignoring the main issue for people like me - most of what you ask puts Israel at great risk. Splitting our capital, helping create a Palestinian state that's right on our border - it's pretty hard to do with a population of people who appear to be pretty hell-bent on killing us. Of course not all Palestinians would really want the destruction of Israel, and of course a big part of the reason they continue to attack Israel is because of their terrible situation, largely caused by Israel itself. That's the unfortunate reality we have to contend with - would you agree to put a bunch of people who are currently constantly trying to kill you, right on your border, and give them total freedom?

Again, I'm not saying (nor have I ever said) that the situation is good - I think it's terrible. I just said that there are no simple good solutions here - and it's not just a matter of "Israel needs to sacrifice" - not when the sacrifice is opening up Israel to people who might kill 10s and even 100s of thousands of people.

Btw, just to give one example - Hamas is constantly smuggling in things through the border, and using funds given to aid Palestinians, in order to do things like build tunnels into Israel, to allow them to perform terror attacks on Israelis (usually - go in and kill a bunch of civilians). Under this circumstance - which is the reality right now - do you really not see why Israelis are reluctant to open up the borders more? It's pretty obvious that doing so will directly result in more Israelis being killed. Do I think steps like this must happen to bring about peace? Yes. But that doesn't make it easier to take these steps.

Re:I survived the Warsaw ghetto. Here are the lessons I’d li... by Udik on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @09:35AM (#17959561)
> the territory was under British control, then was given over to the UN.

It doesn't really matter who had control of it. Ireland wasn't any less of the Irish people when it was controlled by England, or Poland less Polish when it was controlled by the Nazis. The Palestinians lived there, therefore it was their land.

> the pretty clear reasoning that if the Arab countries had won the war, most likely Israel would have been largely exterminated

You don't "exterminate" a country, you exterminate people. And I don't think the idea of the war was to exterminate the Jews, but to get back the country to their legitimate owners.

> Do you consider Germany to be an immoral country today because of what they did during WW2?

No. I consider Israel immoral today because of what it is doing today. Germany did unspeakable things, but it suffered all the consequences, and has paid to the last cent, and there is practically no relationship between what the country is today and what it was 70 years ago.

> What bothers me is the (seeming) double standard, where people consider Israel to be so much worse, for doing so much less than almost any other country.

I find it almost sweet that Jews seek their normalcy by trying to catch up on all the horrid stuff that other countries did before we could call them civilised by the modern standards. Jokes apart, what bothers me as a European observer is not only, and maybe not mainly, the substance of what Israel is doing. In your comment you mention Syria- and there are a lot of conflicts, ethnic cleansing and genocides going on in the world. What really bothers me is both the fact that Israel is a western country, and the level of support it gets from other western countries. There's a lot of people that get caught red-handed stealing, big deal; it's a completely different thing if it's a family member that gets caught, and then keeps insisting, beyond any plausibility, that he wasn't in fact stealing, that the purse was disputed. Pure chutzpah. I hope this expresses well my feelings.

> the blockage isn't Israel's alone. It's also Egypt's.

I'm not sure about this, but I believe that Egypt does it to appease Israel- what other reasons would it have for the blockade otherwise?

> Many Israelis don't support the settlements, but the right has been in power here for a long time.

The settlements are the occupation of somebody else's land to settle your own civilian population in it. This is not just any political disagreement. It's utterly unacceptable. You should storm the parliament and the government until every single Israeli has been relocated inside the borders. How many people living in a settlement you know? How easy is to choose to do it because it's probably cheaper than renting of buying in Israel?

> it's pretty hard to do with a population of people who appear to be pretty hell-bent on killing us

We were talking about de-humanising the enemy in order to better kill it. There it is. Palestinians are not hell-bent on killing you, they're rightly enraged for what you're doing to them. Stop doing it now, be cooperative, and their rage will fade. But of course it's much better to proclaim, as Israel does, that you'll be taking and taking until the Palestinians will stop hating you. Which is of course, never.

Re:I survived the Warsaw ghetto. Here are the lessons I’d li... by Udik on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @03:56AM (#17957898)
> But if there were a decent solution, many people in Israel would push very hard to implement it. The truth is, most Israelis just don't know what to do anymore (and solutions have been tried before, negotiations have happened

There are perfectly good solutions. The problem is that they require Israel to give up what has appropriated during these years of violence, and stop appropriating more. And Israel doesn't want to do it, because it knows it can get away with it.

That's it. Enough excuses.

Re:I survived the Warsaw ghetto. Here are the lessons I’d li... by vxNsr on Sunday September 09, 2018 @07:25PM (#17948349)
I'm gonna give the answer you don't wanna hear, and that is incredibly unpopular on HN and really any left of center arena.

Israel has not forgotten the humanity of the palestinians(1). It has not striped them of their human rights(2) and it has not passed laws that "could affect minorities."(3)

(1) Israel takes great care to protect all human life in any conflict and tries especially hard not remove the dignity of or prejudge people who are bent on murdering its people. When rockets are being launched from hospitals and "army" headquarters are in the backrooms of pre-nurseries innocent civilians and children will be caught in the crossfire, whether it's mortar misfires or drone counter attacks. Anyone asking about the imbalance in death counts is really just a dog whistle for "why don't more jews die". When you have an entire city refusing to give up the names of the people responsible for the stabbing and cold blooded murder of a 1 year baby in it's crib (along with the rest of the family) or the kidnapping and murder of 3 teenagers, it may appear like the Israelis don't care about those whose house they are turning upside down but in reality they could just raze the city in a matter of minutes like Assad does in Syria, or SA reacts in Yemen. the fact is that Israel does its utmost to avoid loss of life while being stabbed from behind by Hamas and being led-on by the PLO who do not want peace and are doing everything to destabilize the region at every turn.

(2) The laws here are not so clear cut, but at the very least Israel is not responsible to give people living in what is essentially another country free access to its own services, if that means 3 hour long lines because a visa process has been proven ineffective at preventing terrorist attacks then so be it. I'm not really sure if you have anything specific in mind here but until you can show how Israel is stripping people of human rights I don't know what else I can say.

(3) This law is no different from many laws that exist across the European and Asian continents. If you would like to argue that all those laws are racist, I wouldn't agree with you, but by singling out Israel for special scrutiny and failing to mention them on a discussion that in fact is about the rise of racism in European countries, you do appear to be guilty of at least some anti-semitic sentiment.

I'm not arguing that Israel is faultless but the way you've tried to frame the argument appears at least ignorant or else decidedly malicious.

Re:I survived the Warsaw ghetto. Here are the lessons I’d li... by Udik on Monday September 10, 2018 @02:49AM (#17949883)
> (1) Israel takes great care to protect all human life in any conflict

For example by having snipers shooting unarmed protesters, women, children, journalists. Sometimes they kill them, but preferably they hit them in the thighs: many of the injured will lose a leg or be in a wheelchair for the rest of their lives.

> "why don't more jews die".

Yes, how many innocent Palestinian lives is an Israeli life worth, exactly?

> Israel is not responsible to give people living in what is essentially another country free access to its own services

You're lying. Queues are to move between one city and the other inside the West Bank. Israel has cut the Palestinian territory into little controllable pieces, building a wall inside that territory and around their illegal settlements.

Finally, while the Palestinian minority is essentially just tolerated in Israel, what makes Israel an apartheid state is their treatment of both populations outside its borders: citizens if they are Jews, people without any right if they are Palestinians. Your house or your entire village might be razed to the ground, fanatic settlers can fence off your land or take your home, or build entire roads or cities where you're not allowed to enter. And if you protest, it's the military court for you- while Jews are subject to a normal tribunal.

Re:I survived the Warsaw ghetto. Here are the lessons I’d li... by edanm on Monday September 10, 2018 @08:16AM (#17951201)
I disagree with most of your post, which I don't think accurately portrays the behavior of Israel. I mean, Israel does a lot of bad things, as do many countries, but it is by no means the standard. And a lot of times, things are reported inaccurately, by e.g. talking about unarmed civilians being shot, when it later turns out that most of the people shot were in fact armed (or among armed protesters).

> Finally, while the Palestinian minority is essentially just tolerated in Israel, what makes Israel an apartheid state is their treatment of both populations outside its borders: citizens if they are Jews, people without any right if they are Palestinians

I mean, this is literally what every country does though - US citizens have rights in the US, and everyone else doesn't. English citizens have rights in England, and everyone else doesn't. (And to prevent other people being pedantic - of course other people do have rights and I'm not being literal, but Palestinians also have rights in Israel, so you're not being literal here either).

If your concern is with Israel singling out Jews as the only ones that are automatically citizens of Israel, that's a valid concern, but it does not make Israel an apartheid state, any more than if England decided that anyone who can prove that in the last 5 generations had English ancestors, was automatically an English citizen.

And I'd argue that it's a completely valid and moral thing to do to create a state that automatically makes all Jews citizens - considering the reasoning for the existence of such a state in the first place. Hell, I'd rather live in a world in which the fact that I am Jewish doesn't mean that I have to protect myself from other people - I'd rather an ethnicity-blind world. But unfortunately, I don't live in that world, so I think it's very valid for me to want to be part of a country in which I will not be discriminated against.

Re:I survived the Warsaw ghetto. Here are the lessons I’d li... by Udik on Monday September 10, 2018 @10:22AM (#17951986)
> I mean, Israel does a lot of bad things

Definitely. It has settled 1/10th of its civilian population in an occupied territory, something that is for obvious reasons forbidden by the Geneva Convention. It declared undivided sovereignty on Jerusalem, has annexed the Golan Heights. It has closed almost 2 million people in a total embargo- nothing goes through the land and sea borders or the airspace of Gaza without the approval of Israel, be it people or goods- this means that the entire region is close to the collapse. In the recent border protest (which took place inside Gaza's border) Israel has fired live ammo on protesters day after day, killing 168, wounding 17 thousand! The UN General Assembly passed a condemnation resolution that was voted against only by Israel, the US, Australia, and a few tiny atolls of the Pacific. Every other nation in the world condemned Israel or (cowardly) abstained. Among those who voted to condemn Israel are Switzerland, Ireland, Japan, France, Finland, Norway, Belgium, Spain and Portugal.

> as do many countries

No other country that we consider civilised, no.

> this is literally what every country does though - US citizens have rights in the US, and everyone else doesn't.

Here I'm not sure whether you don't understand or just pretend not to. It's not that non-citizens don't have political rights inside Israel. It's that Israel is applying its law and jurisdiction outside its borders- so on Israeli and Palestinians alike- but only the former have political and civil rights. It's almost a clever technicality: Israel is not an apartheid state, it's just that, in the Occupied Territories, the State is wherever the Israelis are. The others, even if they happen to live only a few hundred metres away, have no rights.

> Hell, I'd rather live in a world in which the fact that I am Jewish doesn't mean that I have to protect myself from other people

The precondition to not have to protect yourself from other people is to be in peace with your neighbours. Tit-for-tats, or imposing your dominance, don't work (unless you want to just exterminate your enemy- which today is not an option). Israel was born with the original sin of seizing half of the country from their original inhabitants. We can't and don't want to go back on this, but Israel has to find a firm moral rule, define its own borders once and for all in agreement with what was established (at least the 1967 borders) and start building a cooperation with Palestinians. The issue with Israel is that it lives in a conflict of interest: on one hand, it wants not to be attacked; on the other hand, it's more than happy of acquiring new territory, which is only possible if the borders are ill-defined and through the cycles of provocation, violence and retaliation.

Re:I survived the Warsaw ghetto. Here are the lessons I’d li... by Latteland on Monday September 10, 2018 @04:11AM (#17950204)
I'm sure it's incredibly difficult to defend your country against endless attacks and probing for weaknesses, as Israel faces. But I think they aren't doing a good job protecting the lives of non-combatants like the Palestinian protesters who have been killed over and over again, met with live fire, as happened this summer. It's just not acceptable to shoot relatively indiscriminately into crowded areas when you aren't under immediate attack. I've never really heard any explanation about why shooting hundreds of people, including aid workers is necessary. Here's an article I found at Reuters that talks about some of these things. The situation looks like a border defense area, and there has probably been shelling and the shots toward the station. There's some kind of fence, and at this time there are many hundreds to a thousand protesters. They approach the fence. You can't just shoot them. You've got to figure out how to control you military and not just maim protesters.

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-israel-palestinians-prote...

Re:I survived the Warsaw ghetto. Here are the lessons I’d li... by vxNsr on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @11:22PM (#17965347)
> I'm sure it's incredibly difficult to defend your country against endless attacks

I'm not Israeli. I just find the left leaning dialog on this topic to myopic and one sided.

> as happened this summer

It was shown following an investigation that most of those killed with live fire were in fact armed terrorists. There was no "relative indiscriminate shooting into a crowded area." There was targeted sniper fire at terrorist hiding among agitated people intent on breaking through a recognized border in an attempt to do real bodily harm to Israeli citizens. The fact that you've phrased things the way you have makes it pretty clear that you do not in anyway believe that Jews have a right to life.

In addition this was in no way a peaceful protest of civilians, it was an angry mob that was flinging molotov cocktails, burning and bomb laden kites and balloons, burning tires and all sorts of other things in an attempt to break through a designated border area that they were repeatedly warned away from. There was a "nurse" who turned out to be throwing grenades who was shot but for a good 48 hours the left-leaning publications ran with a story that the Israelis had killed her in cold blood until the video was released of her throwing grenades. There was video of a child "shot and killed" who was later "shot and killed" again in different clothing before being seen in a later video getting up from the ambulance and walking away.

More innocent civilians have been killed in the ukrainian civil war in the last two years than by Israel in the last 10.

> You've got to figure out how to control you military and not just maim protesters.

The military is under rigid control, so much so that their lives are often in the balance because they're afraid to use the necessary force for fear of unfounded international condemnation.

Re:I survived the Warsaw ghetto. Here are the lessons I’d li... by Latteland on Friday September 14, 2018 @01:20AM (#17984869)
Can you provide a reference for the fact there were were armed terrorists? I just did a web search on this and found that there were investigations about the live firing by the Israeli military (https://www.timesofisrael.com/in-first-idf-opens-criminal-pr...) and that some of those protesting and injured or killed were in fact terrorists but they were just marching with the crowd and weren't armed (https://www.timesofisrael.com/hamas-says-5-members-among-16-...). I mean it could be that it was a massive terrorist tricky attack, but all evidence that I see is that it was not terrorists who were approaching the border.

Any you are very wrong that "I do not in anyway believe that Jews have a right to life". I do think they have a right to a safe life and protection, just like I want for Palestinians. But I don't think anyone's right to protection extends to indiscriminate killings just because they feel a little bit threatened; of course this applies to my own country too, the us.