That is neither substantive matter, nor the actual state of the country. Please, have a look around with me; consider multiple factors:
The economy's doing well, the country is not pushing towards Russia - neither economically nor geopolitically; instead we've diversified trade and geopolitics; see the recent adventures with China. The political process is chugging along as it ought to, there's plurality of voices in the media and it seems to be growing. The political and economic protests & demonstrations are well attended and mostly well behaved. We've even managed to hold our own against EU's meddling in our internal politics, during recent changes to the judiciary. Oh, and we're one of the very few states in Europe that managed to weather the migrant crisis. Meanwhile we host - no, scratch that, we gainfully employ and well integrate with - a vibrant community of war refugees from our neighbor, the Ukraine.
If there's one thing I still seriously worry about, it's the retirement pension system. Frankly, I plan on avoiding relying on that.
Hey, we've on a better trajectory than our western neighbors, and we've made a few friends along the way. Cheers!
> the country is not pushing towards Russia
Look at any independent rating regarding media freedom, rule of law, tolerance. We are changing towards Russia.
> we've diversified trade and geopolitics
yeah, from being "friends" with EU and USA we changed to what exactly? China isn't our ally, we're doing business, like we did before. Meanwhile we're completely marginalized in EU, and have no bargaining power in relations with USA (which was pretty well showcased during that crisis with stupid Holocaust law). Even if PIS doesn't want us to exit EU - it constantly portraits EU as the worst threat to Poland. Such propaganda may easily end with Poland leaving EU - see Cameron debacle. PIS is feeding extreme right to marginalize liberal opposition, same as Fides did in Hungary with Jobbik. Then PIS remains the "lesser evil". This is a very risky strategy, and is already hurting Poland.
> there's plurality of voices in the media and it seems to be growing
https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-press/2017/poland
> Poland’s status declined from Free to Partly Free due to government intolerance toward independent or critical reporting, excessive political interference in the affairs of public media, and restrictions on speech regarding Polish history and identity, which have collectively contributed to increased self-censorship and polarization.
Government openly talks about nationalization of foreign owned media. That's the plurality you speak of?
> We've even managed to hold our own against EU's meddling in our internal politics, during recent changes to the judiciary
Or, if you aren't brainwashed - we managed to destroy independent judiciary and still remain in EU (for now). Great job.
> Oh, and we're one of the very few states in Europe that managed to weather the migrant crisis
The rest of the European countries seem to exist as well. Maybe try to travel more :)
> war refugees from our neighbor, the Ukraine
These are war refuges like the +- 2 000 000 of Poles in UK, Ireland, Germany are war refuges. So - not at all. They are economic migrants, and benefit Poland much more than we benefit them. Still a good thing, but changes nothing.
Money remained in the private economy rather than in the central budget? Is that your point here?
>>>marginalized Poland outside of EU. And that in turn ends with Poland (...) - as a "proudly independent" vassal state of Russia.
>Look at any independent rating regarding media freedom, rule of law, tolerance. We are changing towards Russia.
Shifted goalposts. Of course we need to exit EU before the EU crashes. Good thing we haven't switched to euro yet, and we're building a competing block in the form of V4 and external trade ties. Nobody here trusts Russia enough to go join their block; certainly we remember history and current events in there.
As for "low freedom, rule of law, tolerance" - that's why I noted the government pays attention and reacts to peaceful citizen protests, while not heeding to EU's (and other external actors') pressure too much. That's how it's supposed to be ran in regard to internal politics. Facts over words, and if you still prefer the ratings ratings over observable reality, I have a bundle of 2006-vintage, AAA-rated mortgage-backed securities to sell to you.
>government intolerance toward independent or critical reporting
>excessive political interference in the affairs of public media
Public media are the minority of media. Every government packs KRRiT. The previous team wasn't any more neutral, it just was speaking in other tone. Which is the whole point of the OP - "is language representative of actual socio-political changes?" Wake me up when the nationalization gets any traction in the society.
>and restrictions on speech regarding Polish history and identity
Holocaust lies were prohibited in Germany and other countries well before in Poland. We're catching up in that regard, if anything.
>increased self-censorship and polarization
There's no discussion of police monitoring, nor of straight up delegalization of whole political party in Poland, again unlike certain western countries. We still seem to hold higher plurality standards, and for that we suffer from the Popper's paradox of tolerance towards intolerance to certain political options, as witnessed in this discussion.
>> We've even managed to hold our own against EU's meddling in our internal politics, during recent changes to the judiciary
>Or, if you aren't brainwashed - we managed to destroy independent judiciary and still remain in EU (for now). Great job.
Not a great job; I was disappointed in how it was rushed and kind of botched. Nonetheless, the point of protecting internal politics from foreign meddling still stands. Contrast that with, for example, Italy and Greece.
>The rest of the European countries seem to exist as well. Maybe try to travel more :)
With much weakened political scenes and societies split along partisan lines; with low trust and dialogues in the nation, and towards immigrants; with Chemnitz and all that. Meanwhile here in Poland we trade with the immigrants just fine, and when that one immigrant was attacked, it was huge shock to everybody, decried widely, and stayed in the news for several cycles.
>> war refugees from our neighbor, the Ukraine
>economic refugees (...) Still a good thing, but changes nothing.
It's an observable fact that we and them integrate just fine. While opinions peddled online would have you believe we are some sort of xenophobes by default.
Have a nice day, ajuc; I'm off to buy a coffee from Nadia at the Żabka.
My point was that Polish government is using nationalistic propaganda, and I'm pretty sure I was clear. Regarding economy (which is an offtopic you started) my point is, that the government increased spending to buy votes to the point that even at the peak of global economic boom we can't balance the budget. How will it work when the boom will inevitably end? It is not sustainable, especially not in the face of demographic crisis (and contrary to the propaganda 500+ isn't going to help - Poland still has negative net change of population, and it's getting worse).
But economy worries me less than the government playing with fire and supporting antiliberal, nationalist, xenophobic propaganda. Because economy you can fix in a few years. Fucked up society you're stuck with for decades.
> we're building a competing block in the form of V4 and external trade ties
V4 votes differently than Poland on vast majority of sessions in EU parliament. Any sort of V4 or "intermarrum" alliance as an alternative to EU or NATO is a pipedream. We have few common interests, potential candidates have no reason to ally us except on immigrants crisis, and even then we have little to offer them. And if we forced them to choose Poland or EU they will choose EU every time.
> The previous team [of public media] wasn't any more neutral
Demonstrably false. https://i.imgur.com/NkSbLtm.jpg Also with more details (but different period) https://www.wykop.pl/wpis/22910245/pamietacie-zapewne-te-akc...
There was never such a biased public media in Poland since communism fell. Data says so, it's not subjective.
> Wake me up when the nationalization gets any traction in the society.
PIS supporters generally agree with the proposition to buy foreign owned media (and even some Polish independent media) by national companies. Government can do it very cheaply - making laws that make private media in Poland unprofitable, buying the media cheaply, then reversing the law. That's how Hungary did it.
> Holocaust lies were prohibited in Germany and other countries well before in Poland
The problem is - Poland tried to prohibit some Holocaust truths as well. Also it's funny how even government admitted it was bad, and you're still defending it. More Catholic than the pope :)
> We still seem to hold higher plurality standards
No we don't. If you think we do please show data confirming it.
> [western EU survived immigration crisis] with much weakened political scenes and societies split along partisan lines
Just like Poland, then? And we had no crisis to blame this on, just Jarek playing with fire.
> with low trust and dialogues in the nation
Poland consistently scores worse than western Europe (especially than Scandinavian countries) on rankings about trust in society and trust in public institutions. For example https://www.researchgate.net/publication/282817518_Social_an...
> Meanwhile here in Poland we trade with the immigrants just fine
"3rd Reich integrated Austrian immigrants well, therefore they weren't xenophobic."
I'll buy a vacation house on the cheap/s. Also, try convincing the greens that it's a bad thing. Also, try convincing anybody that with growing population we'd somehow save our pension system. Or maybe we'll invite some immigrants from compatible cultures to work with us and integrate into the society. Oh well.
>the government playing with fire and supporting antiliberal, nationalist, xenophobic propaganda
Says the online panic. Liberalism is upheld, with pluralism; it's the "single political option or bust" mentality that gets rightfully criticized. Nationalism is what people want; you don't have to agree, but that's the price of living in democracy. Transferring that warm fuzzy feeling to the whole federal state of EU doesn't make it better or worse; it's just that - transferring it. "Xenophobic", nope; it's not "us vs them", it's "some ideas and cultures are specific threat by refusing to integrate, all others are welcome". Come on, don't you see the foreigners around you at work, at the mall, in the schools? Don't you have any immigrants in your social circles?
>V4 votes differently than Poland on vast majority of sessions in EU parliament.
Whole EU is made of countries with different economic and geopolitical interests, votes split and join all the time, and we manage a working consensus. You've just put forth example of the process working as expected, not of some sort of roadblock. What's the alternative - complete unity of opinions under one leadership? We've been there just a few decades ago, we don't want a repeat of that. Let's keep discussing and trying for the best option. That's how progress is made.
>Any sort of V4 or "intermarrum" alliance as an alternative to (...) NATO is a pipedream.
Wouldn't make geopolitical sense either. NATO is our best bet and we will stick with it, especially given the recently re-floated ideas of EU-ran army[1], which would effectively be an anty-brexit "police" stationed all over the EU. With no moderating influence from USofA, unlike NATO. As for V4 being an alternative to EU - I don't know. Maybe, hopefully. Better to make friends than to keep betting on one option that looks increasingly shaky. Especially as EU has this ugly habit of buying our allegiance with structural funds pumped into our economy, making us feel dependent on them.
>[stats about public media] You show proportional representation in the public media of the governing fraction - back then, PO-PiS coalition, right now, PiS government. You made a point the public media reflecting the political reality. I naturally agree with you and chalk that down as system working as expected. Watch it change once the leading political fraction - as it always did. Worth repeating that Public media are the minority of media in here; the majority of viewership and readership are the private ones.
>The problem is - Poland tried to prohibit some Holocaust truths as well.
Was that fixed? Great, process works as expected. Ask for a lot, bargain some, settle on what you really wanted. Politics 101.
>and you're still defending it
I didn't, and never will. I value freedom of speech above state-enforced truth. I am unhappy with legislating what is the official truth. The whole point of my post was that we're on a better trajectory than other countries. Not perfect, better. Reliable process grounded in our centuries-long democratic traditions[3] over centrally-managed perfection.
>> We still seem to hold higher plurality standards
>No we don't. If you think we do please show data confirming it.
We're having productive discussions across political aisles. We scream a lot, protest in Warsaw a lot, and continue to run the country. {edit}What we don't do is "don't talk to those people; deplatform those people; don't hire those people". For neither political, nor national/cultural factors of "those people". Which is a real problem in the internet-outrage-mob fueled countries{/edit} The political scene covers almost full left-to-right spectrum, and it is expected to swing the other way in an election cycle or two. We don't import antisemites en mass, and the immigrants here don't close up into enclaves; instead they live, work and play among us, speaking our language and marrying locally.
The most popular subjects among my politically-active friends are healthcare, pension system, and internet freedoms. Those aren't left-right, or nationalist-internationalist subjects; those are economic bargains we want to tweak and improve. Or, hopefully, overhaul. EU and immigration are somewhat distant subjects exactly because we managed to minimize the impact.[2] {edit}We appreciate GDPR and open market and other goodies from EU in the same sitting we criticize immigration quotas and umpteenth copyright extension and other hare-brained ideas.{/edit}
> Poland consistently scores worse than western Europe (especially than Scandinavian countries)
Is your data showing Germany (re:Chemnitz) as unified and highly trusting their four-time PM? Is your data showing the french happy about soldiers patrolling the streets of Paris? Are the greeks and spanish trusting the government to run it efficiently and stand up to EU when proper to protect their interest? Are your sources glossing over the growing antisemitism in the west? Also, funny you should mention Scandinavia. How's that Swedish experiment with humanitarian superpower going? Please page me when our government issues civilians with leaflets on civil defense preparations. For now, concern dismissed with prejudice, due to biased sourcing.
> [Godwin's law]
Godwin's law.
--
[1] https://www.politico.eu/article/emmanuel-macron-angela-merke...
[2] I think a lot of people here gave up on the idea of government-ran highway system. Sad.
[3] an enjoyable read at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17781330
> Nationalism is what people want
Precisely. And it's because (among other things) government is actively working to make them want it. And it's a very bad idea, which was the whole point of the original article we discuss here. So mentioning Poland was totally justified.
With that settled I'm done with this discussion. I dislike talking with people jumping on 1000 tangentially related points when they can't answer it. It's a cheap and timewasting tactic.
As for >[changing subject, skipping questions, jumping on 1000 tangents], I opened up with the very reason: "It strikes me as a narrow view taken to extreme". I then went on to show that the broad socio-political processes work well in our country. Sure, there are some kooky outcomes here and there. We will fix them in democratic way.
Economics is of utmost importance; as long as voters perceive it as going well, they don't go for extremism promising a "quick & easy fix" that of course is neither.
If you asked 10 years ago if brexit can happen people would laugh at you.
The EU has a ton of structural problems and staying skeptical is in Poland’s best interest.
Why do you think that is unreasonable?
The truth is political opponents will lie and mislead.
The truth is the media lies all the time.
The truth is other left wing EU governments do want Poland to fall in line.
We have a government that builds its ideology on the notion that Poland was always innocent and heroic, Poles were always the victims, we should be proud of our country, anybody who says otherwise is a traitor, leftist, marxist, or other kind of undesirable.
They build their support on historic resentment towards Germans (because WW2 but also because now they are leftists and want to put terrorists in our country), EU in general (because they are leftist and lie to us, they only give us money to abuse us, we would be better off outside), Jews (because they are lying that Poles were killing them and helping Germans in WW2, because they want our money from reperations, because they are behind every leftist conspiracy ever). Among the enemies of the people are also private media, NGOs, ecologists, liberal and socialist governments anywhere, liberal media. Whoever criticizes any particular thing government did becomes a part of conspiracy, and then it suffices to show that this guy is in any way connected to any previously ostracized group - and you can safely ignore whatever (s)he says.
There's this paranoia that people abroad say "polish death camps" and think that death camps were created by Poles. So they post every single mention in foreign media of the term, and there's public outrage.
There was a stupid law recently introduced that was punishing "blaming Polish nation or state for Holocaust or other crimes against humanity". It was unconstutitional obviously, but constutitional tribunal isn't working anymore. It was also stupid, because there were crimes against humanity done by Poles (although on small scale).
It was introduced, predictably Israel, USA, and others protested - government used it as a way to portrait everybody opposing this law as a traitor paid by Jews. That was the rhethoric. And USA obviously is only protesting because Israel forces them to (because government at once tries to show USA as an alternative to EU which is the big devil according to them, and to show that USA when it criticizes Poland is the enemy too). It's funny how they contradict themselves sometimes.
For like half a year the law was suspended, and government blamed everything evil on Jews for opposing it. There was a huge antisemitic campaign in the media, both traditional (public TV, radio, etc), and social media. People were posting every single story from WW2 where a Jew did something bad (because that makes Poles collaborating with Germans ok somehow :) ).
There was a 50 anniversary of 1968 expulsion of Jews from Poland by communist regime. Somehow, despite current government dislike of communists - they managed to make it look like 1968 was bad, but Jews had it coming.
USA blocked all high-level meetings between our governments, and that was the end of that. Government backpedaled, law was canceled. But the propaganda remains.
It sometimes feels like I'm in 1930s. Have you ever listened to Michałkiewicz or Grzegorz Braun? People like that always were there, but they were marginalized. Nowaydays their rethoric is repeated by prime minister and public TV.
It's terrifying to see my own parents buying into this crap. People who were always teaching me to be tolerant, not to believe government when it shows "these people are your enemy". Now they are repeating the same shit that is in TVP. Every few months there's new public enemy - from ecologists, through "homolobby", european courts, NGOs, private media, Jews, France, Israel, USA, Germany, Ireland. Everybody out there is just waiting to destroy our pure, innocent Poland.
That is bullshit, and the fact that people are buying into this is scary as hell. I will manage, I'm working in IT. I can go abroad and live well. But I'm also a patriot, and I don't want to move. And I'm very pessimistic about the general direction Poland took recently. It ends with isolated, marginalized Poland outside of EU. And that in turn ends with Poland going the Belarus way - as a "proudly independent" vassal state of Russia. I would very much want to be mistaken, but we're so far hitting every point on the checklist.