News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by nickthemagicman on Friday September 07, 2018 @02:47PM (#17936685)
Just curious what the difference is? Suffering is your reaction to the pain? Like if you're stoic you acknowledge the pain but continue on with out suffering?
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by kalid on Friday September 07, 2018 @02:53PM (#17936737)
Here’s the best analogy I’ve heard.

Imagine you wake up and your back is sore. Getting out of bed is a struggle, everything aches and you must move slowly.

Without other knowledge, you may get worried, anxious, feel distressed.

If you remember you had a workout yesterday, you may actually enjoy the feeling. It reminds you of the effort you put in, the future progress you’ll make as muscles are repaired.

The physical sensation is exactly the same.

Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by mcculley on Friday September 07, 2018 @05:29PM (#17937812)
I like that example, but it breaks down. I have experienced plenty of pain in the muscles of my back in the form of both delayed onset muscle soreness that follows a good workout and the spasms of pain associated with a torn muscle. The former is pleasant. The latter is not.
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by kalid on Friday September 07, 2018 @06:25PM (#17938131)
Is it necessary for the realization you've torn a muscle to be unpleasant? (It's that realization you're reacting to, not the pain.)

Ultimately, we're making a prediction: my life is guaranteed to be worse off because my muscle was recently torn. Is this true?

https://sivers.org/horses

Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by mcculley on Friday September 07, 2018 @06:54PM (#17938260)
I’m saying they are distinctly different kinds of pain.
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by erikpukinskis on Saturday September 08, 2018 @12:49PM (#17941609)
You’re saying it’s a different set of pain receptors firing, which are more uncomfortable?

The fact that it feels different to you could just be that it’s a different context. Different “metadata” so to speak, with the same pain.

Seems like GP thinks the metadata is making it worse, and you think the data is different. How would you tell the sifference?

Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by mcculley on Sunday September 09, 2018 @09:06AM (#17945732)
I have no idea how pain receptors actually work or if there were different pain receptors firing. All I know is that I have experienced muscle soreness after workouts and I know I can ignore it. The first time I tore a muscle in my back and was carried to the hospital for a diagnosis, I experienced a new level of pain. (That was before my first kidney stone, which set the bar for me.)
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by wilburTheDog on Friday September 07, 2018 @04:17PM (#17937317)
I think the suffering is the result of your desire for things to be different than what they are. It's natural to feel like you want a headache to go away, but it seems to me that the more I accept that this is just the way it is right now, the more I embrace the pain and accept it as a part of me, the less power it has over me. And conversely the more I try to push it away like it's some kind of monster that's torturing me the more it becomes one. I have actually had that experience while meditating with a headache. Fully embracing and identifying with the pain makes it hurt less. It's a weird paradox because you can't start by thinking "I want this pain to go away so I'm going to embrace it". That doesn't work. You have to start with the attitude of "I'm going to be fully present for this moment, whatever it is". That is the path that leads out of suffering.
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by projektir on Friday September 07, 2018 @05:02PM (#17937606)
Suffering is not a desire that humans invent. It's hard-coded into every evolved creature so that the creature then goes on to do things to avoid said suffering. The source of these things that the creature is wanting is distinctly non-human.

There was no council of people who have decided that moving animals need to consume energy in the form of food, and that they would feel pain if they do not consume enough of this energy in time. Yet here it is, and every creature is enslaved by it.

Adult, well-read humans blessed with mental faculties are at times able to cheat the mental pathway and come up with ways to not have it show up at the forefront, but there's nothing self-inflicted about suffering, and assigning quasi-religious themes to this process is not doing us any favors.

Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by adrianmonk on Friday September 07, 2018 @06:18PM (#17938091)
> It's hard-coded into every evolved creature so that the creature then goes on to do things to avoid said suffering.

I like the theory that many emotions, especially negative ones, exist to spur us to some type of action.

Anger means we need a way to resolve a conflict. Fear means we need to take steps to protect ourselves. Regret means we need some introspection to discover how we should do things differently in the future. Revulsion means we need to avoid something. (This applies in less abstract, more visceral ways too. Hunger means we need to eat. Physical pain means we are reaching our physical limits.)

Anyway, a lot of suffering comes about because we don't take any action. When the situation continues to exist, the negative emotion continues to exist.

This isn't to say we should just all act rashly to get rid of our negative feelings. Obviously the right action is important. But sometimes just getting started is enough to help feel better. And if you've already done what you could or should have, sometimes it helps to realize that or remind yourself of it.

Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by projektir on Friday September 07, 2018 @07:44PM (#17938461)
My framework on this matter is much more... negative. I perceive these emotions more as a means of control, a form of slavery, and only a helpful guidance towards the original end. Kind of like you could give a slave some ways of foraging for food and some tools to fend off wild animals, but ultimately only so that the slave would build the pyramid better or faster, and not for the benefit of the slave.

This means that the suffering is not always aligned. This is very not obvious since our association of "feels bad == bad" and "feels good == good" is very strong since it's so obviously hardcoded. But it's not hardcoded for your benefit, it's there for building the pyramid, remember that.

A lot of it is quite obvious in the issue of short term vs long term gratification, but there are more complex interactions. People can drown in guilt when something bad was done to them, and a person may be very happy from a sexual encounter, unable to see the causal link between it and the alimony payments they'll soon be making. Reason is necessary, emotions are a blunt instrument. Intuition is better than raw emotions, but requires calibration. Emotion and intuition can be overwritten, to some extent, which is what most of this thread is about.

But quite often, the incentives do align, as we're one of the more advanced and successful species out there, which means we're less likely to be afflicted with the kinds of sufferings and pleasures that lead to a loss of power (i.e., musth in elephants).

Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by agumonkey on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:47PM (#17939293)
Welcome to stoicism
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by cammil on Friday September 07, 2018 @03:00PM (#17936790)
Suffering is a form of indulgence. The pain can exist and you can be fully aware of it, but if you don't indulge in it there will be no suffering. It just is. One of the components of this is desire for an alternative. This combined with reobservation of the pain leads to a cycle (indulgence) of the mind - the essence of suffering.
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by projektir on Friday September 07, 2018 @05:15PM (#17937711)
How does this make any sense in the concept of animals who are suffering because they're hurt, hungry, etc. What are they indulging in?
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by JeffreyKaine on Friday September 07, 2018 @06:14PM (#17938070)
They might not have the ability to ignore things quite as well as a human can, but the same concept applies. Many dogs will ignore their own pain to help another in need. Not indulging in pain takes a discipline of mind that most animals are incapable of in most situations.
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by projektir on Friday September 07, 2018 @07:06PM (#17938314)
The concept of indulgence implies that indulging agencies are at fault for their suffering, and indulging is a free decision. Which is why that term was used, and why I object to its use. How does it make sense to use this term for an animal?

Me deciding to drink alcohol would be indulging. I know the consequences but I do it anyway. In this sense, the side effects of drinking alcohol would then be caused by me.

But if I wake up one day with a huge cluster headache, why am I considered indulging in it? It makes no sense. I didn't ask for the headache, it showed up on its own. Rather, I may try to resist the headache, but I'm certainly not "yielding to a pleasurable experience", more like I am being attacked and I may attempt a skill check, or I am drowning in an ocean and trying to swim; for neither of these is the term "indulge" appropriate.

And that's the core difference. The original poster used terms like "indulge" and "desire for alternative" to imply that suffering is generated, or manufactured, by humans, that it's a fake thing that doesn't have to exist. My example of animals clearly shows that this is not the case, as most animals do not have enough mental faculties to generate such things in the first place, yet we do not kid ourselves that animals do not suffer.

Suffering is primary. Suffering comes first. "We let suffering happen to us" makes about as much sense as saying a victim is letting themselves get beaten by someone bigger. It's technically true, but not in any kind of useful sense, and the history of those kinds of statements is horrible.

> Many dogs will ignore their own pain to help another in need.

Examples like this are not useful here, because they are not situations of high control. The dog is not ignoring the pain, the dog is, rather, feeling something else that took priority. A human can similarly ignore lots of pain if they are high on adrenaline, but it is not because the human is controlling the situation and actively not "indulging" in pain, but that their body is not interested in supplying pain right the moment. But when the body goes back to being interested in supplying pain, it will come.

Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by burke on Sunday September 09, 2018 @11:41AM (#17946384)
Suffering is built in but requires attention. By completely focusing attention on other things, or even on the raw pain itself, the suffering doesn’t have a chance to tell you its own story about the pain.
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by ollerac on Friday September 07, 2018 @03:32PM (#17937008)
Think of it this way:

Pain: My head hurts. This sucks.

Suffering: My head hurts. It's not going away. Maybe this means something is wrong with me. Maybe it means I have some kind of disease or disorder. What if there's something wrong with my brain, like a brain tumor or a blood clot? What if I suddenly die next week? etc. etc.

Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by smileysteve on Friday September 07, 2018 @05:45PM (#17937912)
And even,

Pain: My head hurts, but that's not going to stop me from having an awesome day.

Suffering: I have a headache, this sucks, let me avoid things that might be fun even with a headache.

Perhaps a better example is the stoicism, Steve Prefontaine famously won an Olympic qualifier with the stitches on his toe ripping; "Yes, my toe hurts, but I want to win, I can fix my toe after I finish."

Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by erikpukinskis on Saturday September 08, 2018 @12:55PM (#17941638)
And then he died at age 24 driving with a BAC of 0.16.
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by lalos on Friday September 07, 2018 @04:35PM (#17937418)
Suffering is a conscious decision, pain is triggered by an outside stimuli. Just like you can feel mad without punching a wall. Punching a wall would be an extreme example of somebody with zero self-control that reacts rather than act. It's normal to have pain or feel mad, it's not 'mindful' to react with the first impulse you get.
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by projektir on Friday September 07, 2018 @05:03PM (#17937617)
> Suffering is a conscious decision

Do you think your cat won't suffer is you stop feeding it? Do you think it's making a conscious decision to suffer if it's hungry?

Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by JeffreyKaine on Friday September 07, 2018 @06:17PM (#17938084)
it might be more accurate to describe suffering as an optional subconscious process. You suffer by default, but you can choose to not suffer with the right amount of mindfulness. As for the cat, again, the cat might not have the mental fortitude to set aside the suffering.
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by lalos on Friday September 07, 2018 @06:46PM (#17938233)
Interesting argument, with a broken premise. There's still debate on what level of consciousness animals have [0]. Is a cat conscious enough to predict that tomorrow it will have less food and save some for tomorrow to avoid feeling that hunger? Does a human have that degree of consciousness to do exactly that? Can a human differentiate itself from an animal by deciding to act instead of reacting like I proposed? Isn't that the one of the key differences between humans and animals?

You know that animals are known to eat their own young [1]? Do you think its a conscious decision? Or they are just on auto-mode like a person that is less mindful is?

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Animal_consciousness [1] https://www.livescience.com/2053-animals-eat-offspring.html

Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by projektir on Friday September 07, 2018 @07:19PM (#17938362)
My premise is that an animal in my care, if left hungry, will suffer, just like I would suffer. The cat's degree of consciousness, or whether or not it belongs to a species that eats its young, is not relevant to that premise. If you think that is a broken premise, I don't know what to tell you, but you might perhaps really enjoy reading Hume.
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by lalos on Friday September 07, 2018 @07:32PM (#17938407)
I was talking about suffering, pain and choice IN humans, you brought animals into the equation. It's a comment on HN so sorry for not specifying that the article and my comment were regarding humans only. Bringing animals in was the broken premise. If it is your responsibility to feed the cat, then yes the cat will suffer. I don't even understand your point, where does the cat get a choice to do anything at all? But that is also nonsensical since cats can't do anything about it but react which was my point to begin with.
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by projektir on Friday September 07, 2018 @08:19PM (#17938655)
I am attempting to reject an absolute statement that I find dangerous by showing a very basic and boring counterexample. If suffering is a conscious decision, it is such in all cases where suffering occurs, and suffering occurs in animals.

"Suffering in humans" is not concrete. You would need to create a distinction between "suffering in humans" and "suffering in animals" and explain where it differs and what is special about it and I don't see any such definition, so I am going to go with "suffering in general".

Many people here are talking about physical pain, which animals can also suffer from, so it doesn't seem obvious to me that your definition of "suffering" would be some kind of a special definition that shares nothing with suffering in animals.

You are likely trying to say some kind of a thing where humans are special and have special mental controls and so when a human feels pain they have more means of control about it than an animal can. This is all well and good but then we get into issues like children or people with limited cognitive capacity. The line between human and animal quickly becomes thin and we're back to square one, the square where saying that suffering is a choice is egregiously wrong and the statement must be qualified.

It seems to me that you're trying to move some goalposts around.

Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by lalos on Friday September 07, 2018 @08:47PM (#17938750)
Ok next time I will write a research paper and post it here as a comment defining cat and human suffering and then after that you will ask but what about suffering in mollusks: "Suffering in humans and cats is not concrete!". I know that HN attracts a crowd that likes to cherry-pick any sentence and treat it as a line of code just to put out a contrarian point of view but come on. Moving goalposts? Nobody mentioned animals you were the one that moved the goalpost.

To be able to be mindful you need consciousness first, to have that you have to be a human. Sorry, either don't move the goalpost and bring animals in, or prove that animals are capable of managing their stimuli with mindfulness.

I'll break it down to you. You receive an input (emotion) and with mindfulness you realize that you ('you' the human, not 'you' the cat) do have a say on how to act based on it. That is all.

Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by erikpukinskis on Saturday September 08, 2018 @01:02PM (#17941690)
> If suffering is a conscious decision, it is such in all cases where suffering occurs

This is the weak point in your argument.

If I have a flat tire, I can get it fixed. I didn’t consciously choose to get a flat tire. But if I don’t fix it, the next day I will have a flat tire I consciously chose to have.

Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by nugga on Saturday September 08, 2018 @03:45AM (#17939953)
The way I see it plenty people s seem to live in what The Bhagavad Gita (a book on yoga and consciousness) describes as 'animal nature', in that they do not necessarily know that they're thinking and that they are constantly moved by the thought stream. They are very reactionary to stimuli.

You may not be able to choose the content of your thoughts exactly, but you may be able to change how they work on you.

I do not know how to scientifically quantify or test this but it is a reported by scores of people and can be understood experientially.

Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by erikpukinskis on Saturday September 08, 2018 @12:57PM (#17941650)
The idea isn’t that humans don’t suffer, or that suffering isn’t real.

The idea is that this very conversation could lessen your suffering for the rest of your life.

If you talk to your cat about stoicism, they might suffer less during starvation, yes.