News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by Ygg2 on Friday September 07, 2018 @10:10AM (#17934328)
Holy crap on a stick. These new laws are just stupid.

I don't generally see eye to eye with libertarians (or whoever advocates for minimal interference of state), but out of touch laws like this are just the worst.

[dead]
Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by klmr on Friday September 07, 2018 @10:52AM (#17934686)
That’s pure trolling:

First off, the Article 13 in question was already rejected once by Parliament and is expected to be repealed against (but it doesn’t hurt to be cautious, good on Mozilla).

> GDPR

While not uncontroversial, GDPR is generally seen as a good thing by experts.

> arresting people who train their dog to do a bellamy salute

This didn’t happen. The man was arrested for hate speech, not for gestures his dog made. It’s also unrelated to EU law.

> arresting people for having potato peelers in public

This didn’t happen. The man was arrested for wielding a weapon in public. This weapon happened to be a knife (but not a potato peeler, though it was called that by the press: it had a fixed > 3″ long blade) but the nature of the weapon is secondary; what’s relevant for the arrest was the fact that the man wielded it as a weapon. And, again, this has nothing to do with EU legislation. And some additional context: the knife wielding laws in the UK are indeed pretty draconian but the UK, which is generally pretty low on violent crimes, has a specific problem with knife crimes and is therefore tackling the problem heads-on. Seems reasonable.

> I can't think of a single reason other than vacation days that I'd ever want to live there.

Really? https://www.numbeo.com/quality-of-life/rankings_by_country.j...

(In fact, even with occasional questionable laws being passed on EU levels the legal situation in the EU, both on EU and on country level, is still a lot saner than e.g. in the US.)

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by pjc50 on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:06AM (#17934810)
> the UK, which is generally pretty low on violent crimes, has a specific problem with knife crimes and is therefore tackling the problem heads-on.

Sadly neither the problem nor the solution is new - the ban on knives in public dates to at least 1953.

It's interesting (and very Brexity) that people blame these things on the EU when they're both very much British criminal law independent of the EU.

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by klmr on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:17AM (#17934906)
To clarify: I find the UK’s knife ban stupid, and it affects me personally (I often cook at friends’ places and, if these friends have no proper knives, I bring my chef’s knife; I also own two valuable antique swords but the rules for bringing them into the country are so complicated that they are indefintely stored at my parents’ place in another country). But like you said, it has nothing to do with EU legislation. And there’s a specific historical context which at least gives some explanation as to why the rule exists in the first place.
Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by poooogles on Friday September 07, 2018 @01:18PM (#17935991)
>To clarify: I find the UK’s knife ban stupid, and it affects me personally (I often cook at friends’ places and, if these friends have no proper knives, I bring my chef’s knife

There's nothing in UK law that prevents you from doing this. Bring along a cook book and store the knife securely (and keep it in your bag) and you're going to be fine. If you get stopped by the police mention it straightaway and move from there.

The legislation is written broad enough that discretion is possible in cases like this. Where it's going to look funny is when you're stopped with it in a pub at 9pm on a Saturday night.

So yeah I see both sides (I might go for a beer down the local after cooking on the way home with the knife for example), but really there's not much wrong with your knife laws IMO.

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by klmr on Friday September 07, 2018 @02:37PM (#17936615)
Broad discretion in such laws is the problem. It puts you at the mercy of an individual police officer's whim. More broadly it facilitates discrimination. This isn't a theoretical problem: I know people in London who, due to stop and search, would never dare to carry knives, no matter the reason.
Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by poooogles on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:36AM (#17969833)
>More broadly it facilitates discrimination.

This is also true, I certainly think if you're a white middle class person taking a knife to a friends you're going to get off easier than an someone from a ethnic minority in Tower Hamlets.

It also results in insane things like this [1]. I'm not sure if there's a better way though, it seems much like democracy it's the best of a bad bunch.

1. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/3165489/Gardener-arr...

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by fermigier on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:57AM (#17935313)
"Article 13 in question was already rejected once by Parliament"

-> Article 13 has not been rejected by the EP.

What has been rejected is a proposal to fast-track the proposal with no debate.

See https://juliareda.eu/eu-copyright-reform/

"The Legal Affairs Committee narrowly approved the plans (with slight changes) – but in a surprise move, the Parliament then refused to rubber-stamp the Committee’s position, opening it up for further debate."

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by klmr on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:23PM (#17935528)
We’re saying the same thing. The Legal Affairs Committee isn’t the Parliament, it’s merely a committee. The EP only had two options here: either vote in favour of the article (“rubber-stamping”) or rejecting it. That’s what they did. The procedure in this case is to revise the proposal, which is exactly what’s happening here. This is working as intended. Of course the fact that the defeat was rather narrow is cause for concern, don’t get me wrong.
Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by raverbashing on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:00AM (#17934748)
> First off, the Article 13 in question was already rejected once by Parliament and is expected to be repealed against (but it doesn’t hurt to be cautious, good on Mozilla).

As they say, don't count your chickens before they're hatched

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by klmr on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:17AM (#17934908)
I’m not — I’m actually contacting my MEP.
Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by jotm on Friday September 07, 2018 @03:54PM (#17937175)
Rejected by a very close vote, must I say. That's ridiculous, imo
Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by chimeracoder on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:39AM (#17935134)
> First off, the Article 13 in question was already rejected once by Parliament and is expected to be repealed against

It was rejected rather narrowly (278-318) a few months ago, and only because some of the coalition that voted against it wants to pass a slightly weaker version of the other clauses instead.

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by hhjinks on Friday September 07, 2018 @01:23PM (#17936035)
>The man was arrested for hate speech

And the hate speech he was convicted for was training his dog to do a "Bellamy salute".

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by klmr on Friday September 07, 2018 @02:41PM (#17936640)
This is simply wrong. The judgement clarifies explicitly that the hate speech in question was the antisemitic slogans that were used as cues, and which were audible on the video.
Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by jimmaswell on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:17AM (#17934904)
You seem to have intentionally ignored "and its member states."

What am I supposed to take away from that quality of life ranking? Yes, the US is below a few EU countries and above others. And it's an average, which means it doesn't mean you can't have a better quality of life in the US than you would in Denmark depending on your individual situation. I for one would be much less happy having to deal with more than doubled gas prices and restricted individual freedoms.

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by klmr on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:19AM (#17934922)
> You seem to have intentionally ignored "and its member states."

I didn’t, but your comment insinuates that it’s all the same. As for restricted individual freedoms, this betrays a lot about your background. EU contries value equal opportunity over individual freedom for a select few. For minorities and poor people, the EU fares a lot better on individual freedoms than the US does.

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by chimeracoder on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:42AM (#17935154)
> For minorities and poor people, the EU fares a lot better on individual freedoms than the US does

That's not true at all. All you have to do is go to France to see how far Europeans are willing to go to restrict the individual freedoms of minorities.

Of course, you won't get data on just how much those groups are in the minority, because France has also conveniently made it illegal to collect this data, but you don't have to have exact numbers to see that the French government has no problem passing laws that directly curtail minorities' freedoms.

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by klmr on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:48AM (#17935214)
> All you have to do is go to France

I’ve lived in France for several years. And yes, I agree that France unduly restricts individual freedoms (and protested against it). I’m not claiming that any single country is perfect. I’m claiming that they are, on balance, better than the US (when you’re poor and/or a minority). Basic personal safety is a prerequisite for freedom: If you can’t even be sure that you can afford medical care keeping you alive, or if you need to worry that institutionalised racism means you get shot by police or thrown in jail for a trivial misdemeanour that earns a white person a slap on the wrist … then “freedom” is simply a theoretical concept.

And yes, institutional racism also exists in France (and in every other European country) but it’s much less normalised than in the US.

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by chimeracoder on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:08PM (#17935396)
> And yes, institutional racism also exists in France (and in every other European country) but it’s much less normalised than in the US.

This is the line that white people in France often say, but it's completely wrong. Racism is much more institutionalized in France than it is in the US. Racism is so institutionalized in France that it's almost impossible to talk about it, because it's woven into the legal and societal fabric and so deeply embedded.

> Basic personal safety is a prerequisite for freedom

You are dramatically overestimating the extent to which it is safe to exist in France as someone who is Black, Arab, or Muslim. Which is a common mistake, given that France has literally made it illegal to collect data on police brutality and incarceration rates of minorities in France, the way we can in the US. But that doesn't mean it doesn't happen, or that France isn't also an incredibly dangerous place for minorities - and arguably much more so - as anyone (like myself) who looks Black, Arab, or Muslim and has so much as traveled to France or lived there can attest.

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by klmr on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:29PM (#17935576)
> France has literally made it illegal to collect data on police brutality and incarceration rates of minorities in France

You’ll need to provide a good reference for that because this is completely wrong as far as I know (AI doesn’t mention it, for instance [1]).

Again, don’t get me wrong: I deeply disagree with the way police acts and is organised in France.

[1] https://www.amnesty.org/en/press-releases/2009/04/france-pol...

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by chimeracoder on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:44PM (#17935697)
> You’ll need to provide a good reference for that because this is completely wrong as far as I know (AI doesn’t mention it, for instance [1]).

Since 1978, it's been illegal in France to collect census information on race. This is done under the guise of providing "equality under the law". In practice, as pretty much any minority could predict, all it does is make it impossible to actually talk about the systemic discrimination which happens[0].

You say you lived in France for several years, and yet you're not aware that it's impossible to legally collect data on anything related to racial, ethnic, or religious minorities (including police brutality and incarceration rates). Which, in a way, is my exact point: making it impossible to talk about these issues in France doesn't mean that they don't happen; it just means that people who aren't affected by them aren't aware of them, and so they can continue believing the illusion that this racism somehow doesn't exist, or isn't as bad as it really is.

[0] https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/politics/how-french...

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by etiennemarcel on Friday September 07, 2018 @04:35PM (#17937424)
Ethnic statistics are not totally forbidden, they're very strongly regulated. http://www.liberation.fr/checknews/2018/01/16/est-ce-que-les...

Yet if tomorrow these statistics were allowed and were to show (for example) that 50% of people in jail are Muslim, what would be the use of that number? The far left would use it as proof of discrimination and the far right that muslims are a danger to society.

Societies like the US where there's a "race" checkbox on forms and where ethnic statistics are legal, are far from being less racist or discriminatory...

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by klmr on Friday September 07, 2018 @02:31PM (#17936570)
Look, I obviously know about this law but this is a completely different thing from what you claimed and it doesn't mean at all that it's forbidden to catalogue police crimes against minorities.

I will concede that it makes it harder to do so by referring to official records (and this is indeed a problem). But your comment sounded like it would be illegal to, for instance, independently collect complaints. And it's emphatically not. Amnesty and others do exactly that, including looking at racial factors.

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by jimmaswell on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:11PM (#17935419)
I remember in high school, my French teacher said racism was much more overt over there and in Europe in general.
Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by distances on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:03PM (#17935366)
For someone having no clue on this topic, could you give some examples?
Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by skummetmaelk on Friday September 07, 2018 @10:42AM (#17934595)
Come on now. You cannot compare this to GPDR. GPDR was about protecting individuals, this is about protecting corporate interests. That's why this seems batshit crazy and GPDR is reasonable.

The rest of your points are worthless anecdotes. Yes it may have happened once, and yes it was stupid, but it's not like you will be chased down by the police if you walk around with a potato peeler. You cannot seriously believe that.

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by timrichard on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:10AM (#17934848)
> GPDR was about protecting individuals, this is about protecting corporate interests

Or how about both rooted in a power-grab by an aspiring superstate that has long been resentful of the influence the US and it's corporates has over it's Internet-dependent citizens?

Or perhaps I'm being too cynical. The remote, barely accountable, hard-lobbied politicians are only looking out for individuals. These new content filter and link tax proposals as just anomalies.

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by kodablah on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:29AM (#17935027)
Please stop judging a law on what it's about but instead on its real life consequences. Intent matters little if people/companies are unnecessarily hurt.
Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by Tomte on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:25PM (#17935545)
People aren't hurt by less data-selling.

I love the GDPR. It came out of nowhere (I hadn't heard much about it before the big hubbub), I couldn't believe they were doing something so bold, and it reinvigorated my belief in the European Union.

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by kodablah on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:48PM (#17935732)
> People aren't hurt by less data-selling

You're doing the intent thing where you are saying what you think is the case or the intent instead of the reality. People are hurt by the money they spend applying reasonable compliance risk avoidance measures when new laws come out. People running companies, employees of those companies, customers of those companies, and society as a whole. Maybe you feel the harm is worth it, but please stop pretending it doesn't exist.

And it didn't come out of nowhere, data protection laws had existed before, didn't work before, so they doubled down on the already-failed legislative approach with the same not-working institutions instead of taking more practical or incremental approaches.

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by Tomte on Friday September 07, 2018 @01:27PM (#17936061)
I'm a strong believer in the primacy of politics over companies.

So if society decides to solve a problem, "it costs some money" is simply no argument against it.

Companies are free to operate in some failed state if they wish not to contribute to society.

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by adrianN on Friday September 07, 2018 @10:39AM (#17934571)
GDPR is not a crazy law and it's pretty much the opposite of what you'd expect in a '1984' state.
Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by jimmaswell on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:41AM (#17935149)
It unnecessarily limits the freedom of anybody who owns a website and doesn't grant any actual freedom to anybody else, almost as if the governments want to be the only ones allowed to collect data.
Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by M2Ys4U on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:49AM (#17935222)
The right to privacy is a human right.

It's like saying that laws against torture limit the freedom of anybody who owns thumb screws. Well, yes, because _not being tortured_ is a right that everybody has.

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by jimmaswell on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:13PM (#17935439)
Why is it your human right that if you write your name on a piece of paper and give it to someone, you can use the state to force them to give you the paper back or destroy it? That's GDPR.
Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by lucozade on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:35AM (#17935085)
You are absolutely correct. If you have ever owned a potato peeler or a right-leaning dog, it is imperative that you never set foot in Europe. It's just not worth taking that chance.

I'm sure the poor folk in Europe will manage to struggle on without you and they thank you for your concern.

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by interfixus on Friday September 07, 2018 @10:48AM (#17934645)
Some of us actually do live here. And some of us absolutely share your views.

But you need look no further than this very forum to see one country's feeble attempts to leave the sorry cirkus habitually likened to the end of civilisation as we know it.

We're on a road to nowhere good whatsoever.

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by pjc50 on Friday September 07, 2018 @10:54AM (#17934702)
I'm assuming that "bellamy" is a weird autocorrect for "Hitler", in which case I refer to my recent comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17927075

The illegal act was sending the threatening message "gas the jews" through a telecommunications system.

The potato peeler incident: https://dailycaller.com/2018/05/03/british-man-arrested-for-...

Homeless man with learning difficulties wielding a knife-like object in public?

In both cases the relevant law is UK domestic criminal law, not EU law.

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by GW150914 on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:52AM (#17935259)
Actually the Bellamy Salute was a thing.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bellamy_salute

The Bellamy salute is a palm-out salute described by Francis Bellamy, the author of the American Pledge of Allegiance, as the gesture which was to accompany the pledge. During the period when it was used with the Pledge of Allegiance, it was sometimes known as the "flag salute". Both the Pledge and its salute originated in 1892. Later, during the 1920s and 1930s, Italian fascists and Nazis adopted a salute which was very similar, and which was derived from the Roman salute, a gesture that was popularly (albeit erroneously) believed to have been used in ancient Rome.[1] This resulted in controversy over the use of the Bellamy salute in the United States. It was officially replaced by the hand-over-heart salute when Congress amended the Flag Code on December 22, 1942.

Along with the swastika, just another thing the fascists stole and corrupted.

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by ethelward on Friday September 07, 2018 @10:51AM (#17934672)
> GDPR

“My oh my, we won't be able to sell people online life without them knowing it”

> local movie quotas on services like Netflix

Promoting local culture, what a shame.

> arresting people who train their dog to do a bellamy salute

Of course, if someone is training their dog to do a “Bellamy” salute when prompted by statements including “Heil Hitler” and “gas the Jews”, the chances that this guy is a closet neo-nazi are so low[0] – BTW, you're the only one presenting it as a Bellamy salute, that sounds like if you were trying to cover a neo-nazi.

> I can't think of a single reason other than vacation days that I'd ever want to live there.

Nah, even for vacations, please don't come here, it's awful, you wouldn't like it.

[0] https://www.haaretz.com/world-news/europe/scottish-man-who-t...

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by jimmaswell on Friday September 07, 2018 @11:29AM (#17935024)
I meant having a guaranteed number of vacation days.

And I don't care if the guy was a neo-nazi; it shouldn't be the government's job to decide what jokes are too offensive.

Re:EU copyright reform: the facts by Tomte on Friday September 07, 2018 @12:28PM (#17935567)
Strange how Anmericans always think it's bad that parts of Europe ban outright Nazi symbols and speech, when it was America that forced us to do so.

Americans even shut down newspapers after WW2 and only gave out licenses to start a newspaper after background checks and ideological checks.

Strange how things you made us do somehow morphed into something that you cannot accept at all.