Re:Chrome 69: “www.” subdomain missing from URL
by Klonoar on Thursday September 06, 2018 @02:27PM
(#17928320)
Same exact reason that api.domain.com or beta.domain.com matters - you're on a subdomain, not the root domain. That the internet and world at large made www the "kind of" root domain in many cases is an unfortunate thing, but I've not seen a modern server configuration that doesn't handle this case by default.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Chrome 69: “www.” subdomain missing from URL
by meowface on Thursday September 06, 2018 @03:16PM
(#17928805)
But when using HTTP(S), you nearly always expect the "www." domain and the root domain to host the same content. It's very, very rare that this isn't the case. Chrome appears to be hiding "m.", too, which is unfortunate (as would api. or beta. being hidden), but "www." is such boilerplate for HTTP at this point that I don't think it matters whether it's displayed or not.
Re:Chrome 69: “www.” subdomain missing from URL
by jlarocco on Thursday September 06, 2018 @04:11PM
(#17929176)
I think it matters, quite a bit actually. My expectation as a user is that the URL I see in the bar is the URL of the site I'm visiting. If it's not accurate, then why show it at all?
Re:Chrome 69: “www.” subdomain missing from URL
by markovbot on Thursday September 06, 2018 @06:01PM
(#17930011)
Because the second level domain is far more important than the subdomain. The second level. www.example.com and example.com usually have the same contents, but are always controlled by the same group.
Re:Chrome 69: “www.” subdomain missing from URL
by hunter2_ on Thursday September 06, 2018 @09:51PM
(#17931322)
It's not true that the second level and third level are always controlled by the same group (most of .uk for example). You can put an SOA record anywhere.
Re:Chrome 69: “www.” subdomain missing from URL
by markovbot on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @03:14PM
(#17962418)
Are they not respecting the public suffix list?
Re:Chrome 69: “www.” subdomain missing from URL
by jlarocco on Friday September 07, 2018 @04:35PM
(#17937422)
But the entity that controls the second level domain always controls all of its subdomains, not just www. Historically www has been a special case, but that's not a requirement and that's on the decline.
It seems like the confusion this change causes negates any benefit it could have.
Re:Chrome 69: “www.” subdomain missing from URL
by meowface on Thursday September 06, 2018 @07:43PM
(#17930637)
Exactly; wish I had added that to my original point.
Re:Chrome 69: “www.” subdomain missing from URL
by meowface on Thursday September 06, 2018 @05:00PM
(#17929505)
>If it's not accurate, then why show it at all?
Don't give them any ideas. They've been moving towards this path for a long time. Full paths being hidden from URLs could be up next.
Re:Chrome 69: “www.” subdomain missing from URL
by archgoon on Thursday September 06, 2018 @04:20PM
(#17929226)
> It's very, very rare that this isn't the case
Those tend to be the cases when I care very much.
Re:Chrome 69: “www.” subdomain missing from URL
by manigandham on Thursday September 06, 2018 @04:42PM
(#17929383)
If it doesnt matter, why even remove it?
Re:Chrome 69: “www.” subdomain missing from URL
by meowface on Thursday September 06, 2018 @05:01PM
(#17929509)
Because it's added visual noise that 99% of end users don't care about and don't need to care about.
Re:Chrome 69: “www.” subdomain missing from URL
by manigandham on Thursday September 06, 2018 @05:29PM
(#17929721)
This is just going in a circle. If they don't care about it then it makes no difference. A few characters in an address bar that they pay no attention to is not significant noise. Meanwhile the people that do care have less information.
Re:Chrome 69: “www.” subdomain missing from URL
by meowface on Thursday September 06, 2018 @07:47PM
(#17930660)
They don't need to care about checking whether it's there or not or seeing it at all. But in a general sense, users do care about reduced clutter and aesthetics, and this is a way of improving aesthetics and creating a more consistent URL bar. It's a tiny bit more consistency and a tiny bit less clutter, but it's not nothing.
The users who truly care can just click the URL bar. (Someone said you also have to press the left arrow, which if true seems like a bad decision. I would agree the full URL should always be visible whenever the cursor focus is in the URL bar.)