At least with key escrow we could laughably pretend that the government would keep their master keys secure. You are suggesting that all portable devices ship with security that can be defeated with a screw driver and hoping nefarious people don't react by installing actual security in software.
Only if they could also secure Apple's cooperation. That's what I was addressing when I said "the extracted key is encrypted and can only be decrypted by Apple".
Once apple has the keys to the kingdom what is stopping the government making apple give the government such keys ensuring that no warrant is required.
What is stopping users from using software that is ACTUALLY secure.
The same thing that's stopping them from silently requiring Apple to include backdoors into every device today.
> What is stopping users from using software that is ACTUALLY secure.
It's the same as with a regular phone line. Users are free to speak in code or use an analog scrambler. Just because a particular interception technique isn't perfect doesn't mean it wouldn't be valuable to law enforcement.
There are things handset makers could do that would allow law enforcement access to a device without compromising the security of every person using that device. For example, they could add a connector to the logic board that grants access to the keys after a fuse is blown. It would only work on devices that law enforcement have in their possession and once they blow the fuse, the device is otherwise useless so you don't have to worry about using a device that's been compromised. It could even be designed so that the extracted key is encrypted and can only be decrypted by Apple after they receive physical possession of the phone and a court order.
A scheme like this would individual phones that law enforcement have in their possession to be accessed. It wouldn't allow mass decryption and so normal users are still protected. That seems like a reasonable compromise to me.