Re:US Court of Appeals: An IP address isn't enough to identi...
by Dylan16807 on Monday September 03, 2018 @12:52AM
(#17900407)
> Suppose you lived alone
The best way I can interpret this is that your post was being deliberately misleading, because you implied that roommates won't invalidate IP authentication, but you actually meant that lying about having roommates won't invalidate IP identification.
Am I missing a more reasonable interpretation?
Re:US Court of Appeals: An IP address isn't enough to identi...
by reitanqild on Monday September 03, 2018 @02:02AM
(#17900662)
> Am I missing a more reasonable interpretation?
I think so. I think in more than one way.
GP, if I read correctly, tries to limit the expectations we can have based on this ruling since the circumstances where unusual. (Read GPs post again for more details.)
English is not my first language but GP seemed very clear and easy to read.
The court is saying "Look, you can't just saying the IP address is the person, you need to offer a reasonable claim that it is". It is not saying IP addresses are useless or that your identity must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt.
Neither my first post nor this post were meant to be normative -- I'm not from the US, the country I am from makes passive filesharing (i.e. uploading while torrenting) more or less legal, and I would be very happy if legal rulings stopped piracy fishing expeditions. I just wanted to describe the substance of the ruling in a more substantial way than the headline did.