News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by westoncb on Sunday September 02, 2018 @06:39PM (#17899077)
What about insights into human nature or how to live well? I agree that if your motivation for reading is the experience that will occur in your mind while reading, there can be no substitute; but if we're talking about value-conferring ideas contained in works, it seems likely that they would become common parts of culture given enough time and exposure.
Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by coldtea on Sunday September 02, 2018 @07:20PM (#17899229)
>but if we're talking about value-conferring ideas contained in works, it seems likely that they would become common parts of culture given enough time and exposure.

Even if we constrained them in their "value-conferring ideas", the power of such ideas in those books comes from experiencing the emotions and subtleties involved in their storytelling.

Without that, a raw "takeaway" idea will have neither the required buildup, nor the emotional impact required to affect one hearing it.

Plus, a key part of literature is not about value-conferring ideas, but about experiencing others' lives and ways of thinking and looking at the world. This is totally lost in plot summaries.

Re:Why Read the Classics? (1986) by westoncb on Sunday September 02, 2018 @08:02PM (#17899339)
Hmm, I mostly agree with you. To be clear though, I'm not talking about plot summaries. More like it accretes into shared cultural wisdom and values.