News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by William1000 on Friday August 31, 2018 @11:26AM (#17886313)
His memory has always been laughably impressive: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eNVJFRl6f6s
Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by maxxxxx on Friday August 31, 2018 @12:57PM (#17887094)
I have heard the same about the top Formula One Drivers. After the race they can recall almost every turn of the race in detail with their engineers. It takes hours to get all the information across. It makes sense that a good memory is big asset for an athlete. It allows them to replay a situation and learn from it. When I did martial arts my memory of a fight was pretty vague so I couldn't analyze and learn much.
Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by prmph on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:06PM (#17887172)
I've noticed this ability as well in other fields: it seems those at the very top (chess grandmasters, piano virtuosos, etc) have an incredible ability to remember the details of performances in their field. The question is: is it their existing recall abilities that (in part) helps them to get to the top, or is it the process of becoming that good that greatly enhances their memory?
Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by pterhx on Friday August 31, 2018 @05:53PM (#17888819)
In Peak: Secrets from the New Science of Expertise, Ericsson had chess grandmasters look chess boards of real games, and they could recreate the board in a pretty short fashion.

But when they took chess boards of randomly placed pieces, they could not remember the placement of pieces any better than a random group of people.

The idea is that through practice, you develop the ability pattern match and chunk together the data into more cohesive blocks, and memory fewer of these blocks.

The rough analogy in software is to take a quick look at some code and recognize the design patterns, and remember the design patterns used rather each individual character.

In fact, words are a form of chunking -- we don't remember hundreds of character sequences, but we remember the words instead.

Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by maxxxxx on Friday August 31, 2018 @08:43PM (#17889469)
It's probably like boxing a beginner. They do all kinds of weird stuff you never have seen and don't know how to categorize.
Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by cepth on Friday August 31, 2018 @09:40PM (#17889660)
If you want to see what pterhx was referring to in action, National Geographic did a documentary featuring Susan Polgar a few years back. The relevant clip and timestamp are here: https://youtu.be/LdKHrxcpxrY?t=238.

The difficulty in recalling nonsensical positions is not that it's like "boxing a beginner", it's that the pieces are literally placed in a way that the positions could not have been reached with legal moves.

Analogously, remembering famous quotes or memorable phrases in a certain language is quite easy. If instead, you had to memorize a string of randomly placed words that did not follow established rules of grammar or sentence structure, it'd be a much harder task.

Chunking is context and experience dependent.

Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by code_duck on Friday August 31, 2018 @04:24PM (#17888403)
I think it’s a result of intensely experiencing the event as it happens, and recollecting it as vividly as possibly right away. Essentially they’re thinking hard about the process before, while, and after doing it.

I have 20 years experience as a glassblower, and the apparent duration of the most intense parts has mentally expanded for me over time. Guitar playing is similar - my awareness while under pressure for improvisation or a slick solo has slowly changed over the years. The intensity of opening a wine glass foot is about the same as playing a quick improvised jazz solo. If you asked a musician how a performance went, they could probably tell you how it fell playing each line. Same with a glass collaboration – I can usually recall how making a piece went, but in a setting like a collaboration or competition, I would remember every part of making a 2 1/2 minute piece as if it was a 15 minute story.

When you start out making cups, the process can quickly go wrong in a jumble when it is time to open the rim. The next time, you remember to avoid that mistake… but might make a different one. Or maybe make the same one again. Each time it’s 10 or 20 minutes until you can be at that point again... it reminds me of 8 bit games where you have to go through a level repeatedly to get to a difficult jump, and keep trying til you make it. Eventually, you start finishing the process, and after many repetitions can do it without thinking. After even longer you learn every microsecond of the process - with glass, the feel of the hot bubble folding over and turning from a sphere to a flat disc in about 800 milliseconds, as you spin it in the flame. That’s the part that expands mentally for me - the control during that time. One learns to not fail to pay close attention at that time.

While these moments still feel like they are over in an instant, over time, my ability to make good decisions repeatedly while taking it in stride has increased. I’d sum it up as my level of overwhelmedness has gone down.

It’s as if time is expanded, though it all still happens very quickly. Due to all the practice, my awareness stays active instead of being overwhelmed. This phenomenon could also show up in other activities like sports.

Your question comes down to basically nature versus nurture, though. Do some people have innate talent, or does it come from training? It seems like the answer is both, of course. My analysis is that some people are better at releasing their minds to accept learning things. Then, it’s a matter of practice and experience. Anything eventually becomes commonplace.

Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by ehaliewicz2 on Friday August 31, 2018 @02:33PM (#17887812)
I'm sure a large part of it is improving your memory, but the very best in the world probably had some advantage to start off with.

For example, if you start off learning a language, there are all kinds of tiny details to pronunciation that you don't even recognize and could never recall afterwards. If you try to repeat what someone's said, you might miss a lot of those details.

But if you've become fluent at a native (or near-native) level, you've trained your brain to subconsciously recognize and focus on all of those details and can recite something that someone's said perfectly.

Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by loblollyboy on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:24PM (#17887315)
Yup - here is a cool one about how baseball players scan things with their eyes https://source.wustl.edu/2006/08/st-louis-cardinals-slugger-...
Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by coliveira on Friday August 31, 2018 @04:06PM (#17888303)
I think this is less spectacular than people believe. If you are extremely focused in a sport event, as is the case for top players and Formula 1 drivers, it is natural that they can remember details with precision. This would be far more difficult for mundane events.
Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by GW150914 on Friday August 31, 2018 @04:19PM (#17888374)
I agree. It’s only impressive if their memory in other areas is at least average. If it’s just a matter of using all of your resources in one limited field then it’s far from impressive. Most people have a less singular focus, and it would be more helpful to compare total performance rather than comparing this one area.
Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by prmph on Friday August 31, 2018 @05:05PM (#17888620)
The point is that such feats of memory do not necessarily have anything to do with the skill itself: a great F1 driver is a great F1 driver, irrespective of how well he/she remembers races; so why do such feats of recall come along for the ride (pun unintended)?
Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by maxxxxx on Friday August 31, 2018 @06:26PM (#17888975)
Driving is only a part of racing. Giving feedback to the team is at least as important so they can set up the car and develop it. I remember reading an interview with a driver who had tested a car together with Ayrton Senna (who became a superstar later). When the team asked him how the car was he gave a few pointers whereas Senna could describe every part of the car in every turn in detail. Guess who is the more valuable driver for the team? Good drivers have more sensors than others and they can record more data.
Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by coliveira on Friday August 31, 2018 @07:57PM (#17889315)
There are two points there: one is the capacity to remember what happened. The other one, however, is the ability to convey this information to engineers. I believe people like Senna are superior not as much on recalling information, but on communicating this information to engineers. A driver with less communication abilities would be far less valuable to the team.
Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by maxxxxx on Friday August 31, 2018 @08:27PM (#17889420)
I would say the top guys have both. They can process a lot of information and convey it later. Schumacher had the reputation to drive at the limit while still discussing race strategy with this team.
Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by codyb on Friday August 31, 2018 @06:08PM (#17888884)
I'm not so sure that's true. I have a feeling when you're flying down the road at 200mph remembering every last detail of that course is particularly important.

Similarly with basketball or any other highly curated group of individuals performing a skill.

Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by brandall10 on Friday August 31, 2018 @03:47PM (#17888209)
I have a feeling it's more adaptive than not.

https://www.wired.com/2011/12/london-taxi-driver-memory/

Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by maxxxxx on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:22PM (#17887293)
I wonder if it's a function of being able to focus.
Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by raihansaputra on Sunday September 02, 2018 @01:42AM (#17895767)
Off the top of my head, this was one of the most important quality of Michael Schumacher. He can really feel the differences between setups and communicate that with the engineers. He really shined in the early 2000s due to the extensive testing he did in Maranello to develop the car and the setups[0].

The current drivers are really impressive too, they have the track layout, the braking points, the turning points of every track they race in their head to the point they can drive it by memory[1][2]. I think this also contributes to the memorisation of the race detail as the track contours and details are in their 'cache' or background memory so they can spend more cognitive capacity in feeling out the changes instead of trying to absorb the whole 'event' or race.

[0]: http://atlasf1.autosport.com/98/bel/schumacher.html

[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0pVBsH5ljnI

[2]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=StqJ40ro56g

Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by RaceWon on Saturday September 01, 2018 @04:26AM (#17890907)
> When I did martial arts my memory of a fight was pretty vague so I couldn't analyze and learn much.

I'm guessing it's because of the adrenaline. I don't remember anything from my first Formula Ford race (and I had years and years of street racing experience at that time and vast databases of memories from those street races), but after a while that level of "combat" actually becomes cherished, you relish the "fight". Then you are in the position to make use of your memory to aid yourself in becoming better when you are not even participating.

I'd say this is probably more true for racers where seat time is very expensive so you must develop the ability to bench race (visualize yourself actually driving, shifting gears, looking into the corner, and so on, and so on) to become competitive.

FWIW, and in my personal experience; when you get to the point where you remember what you were actually thinking right before you made an input, then you are truly in a position to really improve when you are not even actually participating.

Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by beebmam on Friday August 31, 2018 @12:31PM (#17886894)
Wow, this IS truly incredible.

This reminds me of how many chess grandmasters can easily recall and recite and visualize every move in a game from years past. I think James deserves a little more credit than just being on par with chess GMs: to memorize something so complex as a basketball game without even attempting to commit it to memory speaks to his extraordinary intelligence.

Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by fenomas on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:26PM (#17887331)
You probably already know this, but of course the companion trivia there is that chess masters' incredible recall for board positions only works for realistic layouts - when tested on randomly placed pieces, masters apparently remember them no better than beginners.

If basketball is analogous, one could suppose that (A) there may not be anything special about LeBron's memory per se - e.g. he might remember the plays in a cricket match as poorly as anyone else - and (B) it argues that on the court LeBron is thinking out the game, and the implications of each exchange, in a way comparable to how chess masters think out moves (and he probably puts similar mental effort into the other pursuits the article describes).

Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by FPGAhacker on Friday August 31, 2018 @02:16PM (#17887709)
I have heard, though no citations, a psychologist or two on podcasts say that memories as we commonly understand them are reconstructions from fragments and snapshots.

If one accepts that hypothesis then it would make sense that you can reconstruct more accurately things that behave according to a fixed and small set of rules that you understand thoroughly and intuitively.

*small relative to the universe of rules outside of things like chess and basketball.

Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by jmulho on Friday August 31, 2018 @05:18PM (#17888674)
This is presumably because the chess master understands the position. I see three pawns, a king, a rook, and a knight. The chess master sees a castled king. I see 30 pieces all over the board. The master sees the Sicilian Dragon Harrington-Glek variation. I have no idea what happened next. I see eight candidate moves. The master sees three but knows that only one will make this particular opponent uncomfortable. With this level of understanding, it is way easier for the master to remember the game.
Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by jimbokun on Friday August 31, 2018 @06:29PM (#17888989)
It's like a compression algorithm, eliminating redundant details.
Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by philwelch on Friday August 31, 2018 @02:43PM (#17887866)
While true, there are also stories about LeBron having remarkable memory for non-basketball-related details, like remembering the color of the shirt a journalist was wearing the first time they met several years ago.
Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by vertline3 on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:21PM (#17887283)
Steve Kerr said it's common for players at the top, said Draymond was the same way. I imagine Jordan as well.

Did LeBron’s memory of the fourth quarter surprise you?

Kerr: “Not for a great player. I think great players remember everything. It’s like a quarterback.”

Your guys do?

Kerr: “Yeah. Not all of them [laughs]. Draymond would be the same way.

“We’ll be watching tape of a game from, we played Houston in December or something, and guys will be like, ‘Oh yeah, I remember that. This is what happened next.’

“So I don’t think it’s that rare. But the best players generally remember the most and have the sharpest memories.

Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by asimpletune on Friday August 31, 2018 @02:20PM (#17887744)
Draymond is known for also being a very smart player.
Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by jimbokun on Friday August 31, 2018 @06:27PM (#17888980)
Almost as laughably unimpressive is the vapidity of the next question asked, something like "down after one game, how concerned are you?"

Um, 7? 6? 14?

I think coaches and athletes don't necessarily get upset about having to answer questions per se. I think a lot of times they are upset that the people writing about their sport have so little knowledge or curiosity about it.

Zach Lowe, as a counterexample, seems to get a lot of interesting answers out of players and coaches because he makes good observations and thus can actually ask interesting questions.

Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by jl2718 on Friday August 31, 2018 @12:33PM (#17886909)
I’ve noticed a strong tendency toward eidetic memory in people that started in their professions without going to college. Very common in enlisted military, for instance. I think it might actually be quite natural. Education, I think, overloads a person with all of this useless stuff to make them ‘well-rounded’ and they lose their ability to focus on the details.
Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by throwawaymath on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:05PM (#17887166)
The other commenter's reply is a tad aggressively stated but I agree with it. I think your conclusion is probably skewed by survivorship bias. When I began my career I didn't have any college experience and I have a fairly exceptional working and long term memory (as measured by an IQ test and other peoples' remarks on my work). As an example, I can typically recite most lines of dialogue from a TV show verbatim in order after watching the episode once. That does come in handy for professional work. However, I happen to know many people without any college education, and most do not have a particularly good memory; they don't have a particularly bad memory either, just sort of middling.

So trading one set of anecdotes for another: I don't see support for your hypothesis. I think it's plausible that professionally successful people without college education tend to have a better memory, perhaps because they need to in order to compensate for lack of formal education. But even that is unsubstantiated. We probably can't draw any meaningful inferences from the n = 1 example of one of the most successful basketball players of all time. Many of Lebron James' qualities - both mental and physical - are likely several sigma from the mean.

Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by pitt1980 on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:39PM (#17887444)
supposedly Eidetic memory is somewhat common in childhood

"Eidetic memory is typically found only in young children, as it is virtually nonexistent in adults.[5][6] Hudmon stated, "Children possess far more capacity for eidetic imagery than adults, suggesting that a developmental change (such as acquiring language skills) may disrupt the potential for eidetic imagery."[6] Eidetic memory has been found in 2 to 10 percent of children aged 6 to 12. It has been hypothesized that language acquisition and verbal skills allow older children to think more abstractly and thus rely less on visual memory systems."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eidetic_memory

one way to think about what education is, is that its a process for taking your perceptual inputs, and putting them on an abstract lattices

this is an obviously useful process in all sorts of ways

but it probably does change the way you both notice things, and remember things

-------

(there a sort of similar thing going on when you're looking at something to draw it, you have to sort of un-abstract it, instead of putting the lightwaves hitting your eye onto the lattice 'apple', you have to get it back to lightwaves in certain pattern)

Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by throwawaymath on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:51PM (#17887545)
> one way to think about what education is, is process for taking your perceptual inputs, and putting them on an abstract lattice

this is an obviously useful process in all sorts of ways but it probably does change the way you both notice things, and remember things

The problem with this is you're inducing a hypothesis via intuition and analogy. I don't see any reason to think education has the deleterious effect you're proposing. I guess it could, but I don't think there's any compelling evidence for it. It doesn't strike me as the simplest explanation.

From my perspective, I don't think there is any inverse correlation between memory capability and educational achievement. I could just as reasonably say eidetic memory decreases as language skills develop because we no longer have as much need for episodic recollection versus semantic recollection.

But neither of these proposals is grounded in anything empirical, it's intuitive speculation based on limited anecdata. The simpler explanation, by Occam's Razor, is that educational achievement trains memory faculties.

Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by pitt1980 on Friday August 31, 2018 @02:31PM (#17887808)
I'm confused by "you're inducing a hypothesis via intuition and analogy"

how else do you create a hypothesis?

You're correct that I haven't done a peer reviewed study on the question.

(fwiw, I suspect we're talking around each other, I'm not sure I disagree that educational achievement trains memory that fits on an abstract lattice, what I question, is memory that doesn't fit on a lattice, either way, yes, its all mere speculation on my part, imo that's the sort of thing internet message boards are good for)

Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by michaelmrose on Friday August 31, 2018 @12:39PM (#17886960)
Learning makes people stupid is a very strange thesis with zero support. It seems more likely that you have no idea what the instance of eidetic memory in either population, that memory doesn't work like that at all, and that small handful of anecdotes is leading to a spurious connection.
Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by pitt1980 on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:00PM (#17887117)
this seems overly hostile to what appears to be a hypothesis

the idea that what we're trained to notice changes what we perceive, doesn't strike me as strange thesis at all

I'm reminded of this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ahg6qcgoay4

Re:Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014) by michaelmrose on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:46PM (#17887501)
Our brains are trained to find patterns. Prove it is a perfectly valid response to what appears to be a spurious one.