Re:California to become first state to require companies to ...
by r_smart on Friday August 31, 2018 @12:00PM
(#17886611)
>If the law required a 50/50 gender split on boards
I'm curious why you would see that as an improvement. Care to elaborate?
Re:California to become first state to require companies to ...
by gizmo686 on Friday August 31, 2018 @12:31PM
(#17886890)
As written (assuming the article is an accurate portrayal), the law is a blatent violation of the equal protection clause, as it provides a protection for women that it does not provide for men. A neutral requirement is not such a blatent violation. Although it still runs the risk of a disparite impact argurment and, perhaps more damming, seems to be in direct contradiction with federal (and likely state, but more specific wins there) anti discrimination laws. Or rather, compliance would involve violating other laws, at least in some cases.
Re:California to become first state to require companies to ...
by r_smart on Friday August 31, 2018 @12:52PM
(#17887044)
Ah, gotcha. It seems more wrong to me, but I guess I'm thinking in terms of 'What would this do' as opposed to 'Is this law a violation of various laws / legal philosophy'.
Re:California to become first state to require companies to ...
by syntheticcdo on Friday August 31, 2018 @12:33PM
(#17886906)
The law permits all female boards but does not permit all male boards. This is discrimination.
If the law required a 50/50 gender split on boards, or at least one member of each gender or similar, I wouldn't find it offensive. As is, it allows all-female boards and bans all-male ones.
Laws like this are what energize the Trump political base.