Re:Blackened Buildings of Manchester Before the Clean Air Act
by crc32 on Friday August 31, 2018 @04:27AM
(#17883878)
A good example of government regulation improving quality of life!
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Blackened Buildings of Manchester Before the Clean Air Act
by qlm on Friday August 31, 2018 @07:35AM
(#17884650)
Can one of the HN free-marketeers explain how this sort of thing would arise "naturally" through market forces, without regulatory intervention?
Re:Blackened Buildings of Manchester Before the Clean Air Act
by village-idiot on Friday August 31, 2018 @08:43AM
(#17885048)
It's not possible, because pollution is an externality[0], something that's well known to destabilize free markets. Without regulation, purely profit driven actors have no incentive to reduce pollution one bit, since doing so gives them an economic disadvantage against their polluting peers.
Re:Blackened Buildings of Manchester Before the Clean Air Act
by pmorici on Friday August 31, 2018 @07:49AM
(#17884735)
If you were allowed to sue polluters for damages to your property is a common example I've seen. So for example you notice your building is being blackened and sue the coal fired plant down the street for the cleaning fees to restore it's facade.
Sounds good but it is totally impractical if you've had any experience with the legal system.
Re:Blackened Buildings of Manchester Before the Clean Air Act
by qlm on Friday August 31, 2018 @08:22AM
(#17884895)
What if there are many factories owned by different businesses producing the pollution? Do you sue all of them?
What if the cost of cleaning is smaller than the cost of changing business practices to protect health and the environment?
Re:Blackened Buildings of Manchester Before the Clean Air Act
by pmorici on Friday August 31, 2018 @07:35PM
(#17889240)
Yes, one of the many reasons it is totally impractical.
Re:Blackened Buildings of Manchester Before the Clean Air Act
by gnud on Friday August 31, 2018 @09:14AM
(#17885263)
Great, if I'm dying of poisoning I can sue, at least. Helpful.
Re:Blackened Buildings of Manchester Before the Clean Air Act
by monort on Saturday September 01, 2018 @03:51AM
(#17890800)
Tort law. It was the government, that prohibited suing polluters in the first place (in the name of a progress). Free-market cities probably wouldn't have ICE cars or fabrics nearby, because it would be prohibitively expensive to buy a permission to pollute from each land-owner in a city.
Re:Blackened Buildings of Manchester Before the Clean Air Act
by fabatka on Friday August 31, 2018 @09:09AM
(#17885225)
I think biology would have "solved" the problem in this case. Without regulation and sustained pollution, the population would eventually decrease enough (through migration and increased mortality rate) to reduce pollution.
Re:Blackened Buildings of Manchester Before the Clean Air Act
by mrob on Friday August 31, 2018 @03:30PM
(#17888128)
Pollution can harm quality of life for everybody, but mostly kill elderly people who've already had children.
Re:Blackened Buildings of Manchester Before the Clean Air Act
by ghufran_syed on Friday August 31, 2018 @11:48AM
(#17886508)
https://mises.org/library/libertarian-manifesto-pollution
Or rather, how this sort of thing happens because of the ‘wrong sort of’ government action
Re:Blackened Buildings of Manchester Before the Clean Air Act
by ghufran_syed on Friday August 31, 2018 @04:25PM
(#17888407)
Or more explicitly - governments choose to deny citizens certain property rights with the aim of increasing economic development (possibly run by friends of, or contributors to, those in government). So citizens harmed by externalities such as pollution cannot sue for redress
Re:Blackened Buildings of Manchester Before the Clean Air Act
by falsedan on Friday August 31, 2018 @05:33AM
(#17884154)
This is just cleaning the facades! Edinburgh prohibits this kind of cosmetic work in ordr to keep the historical character of buildings (tho sandstone doesn't go as black as limestone).
Re:Blackened Buildings of Manchester Before the Clean Air Act
by handelaar on Friday August 31, 2018 @08:49AM
(#17885085)
When I was small most of Edinburgh looked exactly like these photos, and they didn't start washing it until the late 80s.
(edit: come to think of it, entire central Edinburgh area still smelled of coal smoke in the mornings until about then, too, though Musselburgh even more so)
Re:Blackened Buildings of Manchester Before the Clean Air Act
by arethuza on Friday August 31, 2018 @05:44AM
(#17884204)
Are you sure - most buildings in central Edinburgh seem to have been cleaned in the last couple of decades?
Re:Blackened Buildings of Manchester Before the Clean Air Act
by stevekemp on Friday August 31, 2018 @05:54AM
(#17884247)
I remember the cleaning of the Scott Monument was a very contentious issue - which was eventually abandoned. Nowadays you can see the contrast between the old/dirty stone and the new pieces used for restoration.
Re:Blackened Buildings of Manchester Before the Clean Air Act
by arethuza on Friday August 31, 2018 @06:14AM
(#17884322)
I'm actually sitting in an office in George Street looking out of my window at a stone wall where I can see that the entire one building has been cleaned and the next door one hasn't! :-)
The National Galleries near the Mound was cleaned entirely a few years back - it's actually starting to collect dark marks on it again.
Re:Blackened Buildings of Manchester Before the Clean Air Act
by blockedTwitter on Friday August 31, 2018 @05:30AM
(#17884141)
Well, it would have happened sooner and more efficiently if the invisible hand of the market were only permitted to operate freely.