Re:Bullshit Jobs
by wool_gather on Thursday August 30, 2018 @08:33AM
(#17876146)
Plumbing and other trades like it are the opposite of bullshit jobs, though. They require specific training and skill. They have tangible results that clearly improve the world (even if they're reactionary and small-scale, i.e., fixing a broken sink drain).
Yeah, don't dump on the trades. When you get down to the real nitty-gritty, most jobs are technically bullshit. If everything were reduced to rubble and ash tomorrow, CxOs, lawyers, programmers, HR, police, teachers, entertainers, salesmen, advertisers, and countless others become useless occupations.
Even doctors lose some of their cachet.
Farmers, carpenters, engineers, plumbers, electricians, etc all become way more valuable as they can actually rebuild the bits of society that are important to everyone.
I don't think 'would be useful in a post-apocalyptic wasteland' is the usual definition (or a very good one) of a non-bullshit job. It's more about how much genuine value the job creates in the real world today.
The problem is defining "value". Some would say entertainment provides some value, some would say otherwise.
I'm focusing on something approaching "minimally viable society".
Re:Bullshit Jobs
by TelmoMenezes on Thursday August 30, 2018 @07:07AM
(#17875682)
AI is not a binary event. Technological progress gradually removes the need for labor. Consider simple unsexy things such as automatic cashiers at supermarkets, McDonald's, etc. How many jobs have they made redundant? And do you know that "computer" used to be a profession? Do you know that the majority of blue collar work in 2018 will be made redundant by self-driving vehicles? And so on.
You say I am overestimating technological progress. Ok, then explain to me why work hours are increasing. They should at the very least be staying the same right?
Re:Bullshit Jobs
by toomuchtodo on Thursday August 30, 2018 @09:09AM
(#17876348)
Work hours are increasing because of the decline in unions, and along with it, worker bargaining power.
Re:Bullshit Jobs
by tonyedgecombe on Friday August 31, 2018 @11:18AM
(#17886245)
Re:Bullshit Jobs
by toomuchtodo on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:00PM
(#17887122)
They are for the US, while they're declining for the EU countries you selected (which your graph shows).
I'm all in favour of us having a life of leisure or fun jobs (actor, ski explorer etc) and everyone having a basic income from the state. Sadly though the AI robots are not here and getting someone to fix your plumbing is still a pain, plus many other jobs. Maybe in the future we can go that way.