Yes it does. The precedent set by this applies to every case within the 8th Circuit, which was:
> But the FCC may rationally choose which evidence to believe among conflicting evidence in its proceedings, especially when predicting what will happen in the markets under its jurisdiction.
The FCC being able to pick which evidence to consider and which to ignore absolutely impacts residential broadband.
Not that I agree with what was chosen here, but if multiple pieces of evidence are reviewed and they conflict in their findings, they have to choose one in their ruling, right? Technically no matter the decision, they would technically be "ignoring" evidence because the outcome didn't agree with it, correct? It's not ignored, just not believed as much as other evidence from what I gather.
Given conflicting evidence, you have to choose which is right. That is not "ignoring" anything (hence why I put it in quotes), but sadly people use these incorrect/loaded words because they disagree with the decision.
The FCC presented evidence that ISPS will often build up to a mile of wire reach new customers of these high-value service contracts.
> not exactly as dire as the headline makes it sound,
ArsTechnica. I can't recall the last time one of their political articles (which are the vast majority of ArsTechinca articles that ones that reach HN and Reddit frontpage) was an honest explanation of the situation covered in the article.
That is an extremely bold statement, and obviously both technically accurate and utterly misleading on its face.
Sure providers will build out a half mile of fiber to you. For $50k. Exceedingly few are doing a build out for a single corporate customer for free. I've been involved in build-outs where the customer simply moved offices to a lit building because the build-out costs were more expensive than eating an early termination fee on a lease.
Not sure how that is remotely competitive. It's about as close to outright lying to the court as you can get without actually doing so, in my estimation.
Yes, it's not logical, and it's nonsensical, but it's not exactly as dire as the headline makes it sound, and it doesn't relate to residential broadband.