News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I inspected the mastodon.social website by mikekchar on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @07:46AM (#17858047)
Kind of off topic, but like the author I was looking at Mastodon yesterday (reading the ruby code, ha ha!). One thing struck me, though. The documentation seems to imply that it doesn't matter what instance you're on and to simply look for an instance that has people you get along with. However that doesn't seem to be a good idea in some cases and I'm wondering if I'm wrong.

Some instances are blocked by other instances. And even though some are only "silenced", if you happen to join an instance that is blocked by a lot of other instances, then nobody will see what you are writing. For example, I joined mstdn.jp because it's in Japan (which I am as well), and it's popular. I thought it would be convenient to join that instance because then I can follow more Japanese people and improve my Japanese. But then I found out that mstdn.jp is blocked by some other instances due to fears over lolicon material (it hasn't shown up in my brief troll of the federated feed, so I wonder how prevalent it actually is -- also, I wonder if my information is old news and it isn't actually blocked by people now...).

So potentially anything I write will never show up in the federated feed in those other instances (and may be completely blocked by other instances). So I should pick a different instance. Sounds easy, but which one?

The problem is that (as I mentioned earlier), I want to follow content on the main Japanese servers. So I need to find a server that doesn't block those servers entirely. Except there doesn't seem to be any way to find out exactly what servers people are blocking (except for a handful who helpfully tell you that they are following the tootcafe blocklist[1]). That kind of solves my particular problem because the main Japanese servers are not blocked on that list.

But, for me it illustrates a pretty serious problem. How do I know that the instance I'm on isn't blocked by the majority of the fediverse? If I'm writing and I'm interested in a wide variety of people reading what I'm writing, how do I ensure that I position myself in the right place? And if I like an instance (regardless of a lack of moderation that is causing it to be blocked by the world), how do I remain connected with the people on that instance without maintaining a presence there?

It almost seems to me that I really need multiple accounts on multiple instances to ensure that I can get what I want -- but since the client is tied to the instance (as a web sever), that's a difficult trick...

Sorry for the length (for people who got this far). My ideas are still a little unformed.

[1] - https://github.com/tootcafe/blocked-instances

Re:I inspected the mastodon.social website by WorldMaker on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @01:17PM (#17860682)
> And even though some are only "silenced", if you happen to join an instance that is blocked by a lot of other instances, then nobody will see what you are writing.

If you are on a "silenced" instances you can still be directly followed by users on the instance doing the silencing and they will see all of your posts on their Home timelines. From what I've seen, any boosts/replies by those users following you to your statuses still make those individual statuses eligible for them to show up on Federated feed on that instance, even if your every post is not eligible.

Arguably the game is the same whether or not you are on a majority "silenced" instance: the more people that directly follow you the more likely you show up in people's Home timelines and thus the more likely you show up in Federated feeds. You don't necessarily need to know if a remote instance is silencing your instance if you make enough friends on that instance that are directly following you.

I'd also argue that worrying about which Federated feeds you show up on is counter-productive in Mastodon. As with Twitter, it's better to reach users in their Home timelines, with direct relationships, or in some cases on Local Timelines for interesting interests, than to ever count on Federated feeds. Many instances the Federated feed isn't that useful (too busy, for instance) and people don't bother checking it anyway. (My main account is currently the only user on a small instance and the Federated feed is mostly repetitive with stuff on the Home feed and so I check it very irregularly.)

Instance "suspensions" obviously are a different matter entirely, but I don't feel like it is worth worrying about "silences".

> It almost seems to me that I really need multiple accounts on multiple instances to ensure that I can get what I want -- but since the client is tied to the instance (as a web sever), that's a difficult trick...

It's easy enough to just open multiple tabs in your browser and tab between them, if that is what you want to do. There are also some native clients with good multi-account support.

Re:I inspected the mastodon.social website by nailer on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @07:56AM (#17858087)
> https://github.com/tootcafe/blocked-instances

Wow. tootcafe, according to their own page, blocks any instances where free-speech is tolerated. Not threats, or harassment, just social views they deem unlikable.

Re:I inspected the mastodon.social website by nl on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @08:32AM (#17858262)
I’m 100% behind the idea that instances should be able to refuse to carry (literal) nazi propaganda (read the footnote; this is what we are talking about here. I agree that isn’t great wording though).

Isn’t that the whole idea of federation? Instances can do what they want?

Also Nazism is a threat. I have Jewish and gay friends and Nazis want them executed.

Re:I inspected the mastodon.social website by nailer on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @08:37AM (#17858295)
> I have Jewish and gay friends and Nazis want them executed.

Same here. Wanting someone executed is already covered by banning threats, as mentioned in the comment you're replying to.

Removing unwanted speech which isn't threatening isn't necessary. The most likely outcome of blocking free-speech nodes is control of conversation, eg, deeming supporting national borders as 'hate speech'. Which is fine if you want that, but makes tootcafe seem like a play pen for people who don't like to be around others who disagree with them if you don't.

Re:I inspected the mastodon.social website by yorwba on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:44AM (#17859133)
> The most likely outcome of blocking free-speech nodes is control of conversation, eg, deeming supporting national borders as 'hate speech'.

Why would that be the most likely outcome? I'm pretty sure that "deeming supporting national borders as 'hate speech'" is a fringe position, which would be unlikely to take over a popular instance. Even if it did, people whose posts about national borders are deleted could easily move to another instance with a different policy.

Filtering what you see and share with others isn't inherently wrong. Sure, if I'm on an instance that considers national borders equivalent to hate speech, I might lose out on interesting discussions about that topic. But if I'm not (and that's much more likely), then I won't be bothered by strangers reacting angrily to my posts they see as hate speech, because they'd be blocking me instead.

I think the upsides of not seeing what I don't want to see outweigh the downsides of not seeing everything, given that there's too much content to see everything anyway.

Re:I inspected the mastodon.social website by nailer on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @12:29PM (#17860180)
> I'm pretty sure that "deeming supporting national borders as 'hate speech'" is a fringe position

I'm not sure if you use Twitter or live in the bay area but it's relatively common in both these places. Even TechCrunch UK recently described supporting Brexit as a racist position.

> Filtering what you see and share with others isn't inherently wrong.

Totally agreed, but the mischaracterisation of networks supporting free speech as a place where "It's OK to be a Nazi" is. It's also not particularly original, with similar arguments being commonly used by most totalitarian regimes.

That said, the 'nazism is OK on those instances' may have been accidental (or perhaps just unthinkingly partisan) - I've sent a PR with a fix: https://github.com/tootcafe/blocked-instances/pull/22

Re:I inspected the mastodon.social website by nl on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @05:44PM (#17863185)
deeming supporting national borders as 'hate speech'.

Making up stuff like that doesn’t help your argument here.

Re:I inspected the mastodon.social website by kup0 on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @09:40AM (#17868120)
And? There are plenty of other instances to choose from and that is the beauty of Mastodon.

Some may choose to have very strict rules about what is allowed, others may be wide open.

I don't see a problem here.

Re:I inspected the mastodon.social website by whostolemyhat on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @08:17AM (#17858186)
> "Free speech zone": a place where it's okay to promote e.g. National Socialism because the argument is that open discussion is more important than people's sensitivities or the denazification laws of Germany/France/etc.

It blocks hate speech, as clearly mentioned in that link.

Re:I inspected the mastodon.social website by nailer on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:02AM (#17858466)
Yes, I read that. That massive (and likely deliberate) mischaracterisation of free speech is exactly what the comment you're replying to is objecting to.

> it's okay to promote e.g. National Socialism

Not, it's not OK. If you promote Nazism I'll point out you're an idiot and so will most right minded adults. Something being not banned in not the same thing as it being 'OK'.

Re:I inspected the mastodon.social website by 0xcde4c3db on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:43AM (#17858723)
Note that it's quoted, in contrast to the other definitions. This is presumably in reference to the abuse of "free speech" rhetoric by neo-Nazis and the like (who typically do not value freedom of expression beyond their own views), rather than tootcafe making that claim about free speech. Maybe that presentation is too subtle to get the point across to most people, but I think it's a valid distinction to make.
Re:I inspected the mastodon.social website by nailer on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @12:27PM (#17860155)
> the abuse of "free speech" rhetoric by neo-Nazis

How common are neo nazis in 2018? There's a fringe element on the left who believes anyone on the right of, say, Bernie Sanders, is a Nazi. Tootcafe seems to subscribe to this convenient way of dismissing people that disagree with one's current viewpoint.