News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brilliant design: RCA student radically improves the UK plug by ars on Tuesday October 12, 2010 @09:30PM (#1785674)
You must deal mainly with very old poorly maintained houses (rentals?), because all those problems do not exist in normal outlets.

You have soot on your contacts???? Corrosion? Did it rain inside your house?

NEVER tighten aluminium contacts! You will cause exactly those problems that you describe. If there is a problem with it you need to remove it, apply the anti-oxidant paste and reinstall.

But aluminium to the contacts is very rare in america these days, where it does exists it's usually been pigtailed with copper.

Re:Brilliant design: RCA student radically improves the UK plug by enneff on Wednesday October 13, 2010 @12:38AM (#1786105)
I have visited the USA twice this year, and found the power outlets in expensive hotels, serviced apartments, and office buildings to be of a much lower build quality compared to those of my home country, Australia.

In my two months in the USA, I observed more arcs and electrical crackling noises than I have in the rest of my life in AU.

Just my anecdotal 2c.

Re:Brilliant design: RCA student radically improves the UK plug by brc on Wednesday October 13, 2010 @12:50AM (#1786131)
I'll add my anecdotal 2c :it's the same as you. The UK plug is overkill, IMO, but the US plug is downright nasty. The lack of 'off' switches in the majority of them is a problem. I always figured the problem stems from the original design, which was probably a version 1.0, as the USA was the first to get electricity into homes. That's why other countries have superior systems - they had time to learn from the problems and design better systems, with built-in grounds, isolating switches at the point, and higher voltages (220/240 vs 110).

But I could be all wrong, as I'm no expert beyond having a drawer full of adapter plugs.

Re:Brilliant design: RCA student radically improves the UK plug by jacquesm on Tuesday October 12, 2010 @09:49PM (#1785726)
> You must deal mainly with very old poorly maintained houses (rentals?), because all those problems do not exist in normal outlets.

Rural areas, farmhouses, but one building I lived in in Toronto had a problem (a bad one) with one of the sockets and it was a fairly recent upgrade from what I remember.

> You have soot on your contacts???? Corrosion? Did it rain inside your house?

No, simply an installation from the 70's still operating in 2005. There are millions like that. And I don't live there anymore, I'm back Europe now.

> NEVER tighten aluminium contacts!

Not over-tighten, tighten. You should do it to the proper torque (there are special tools for that).

> But aluminium to the contacts is very rare in america these days, where it does exists it's usually been pigtailed with copper.

Yes, that's the slightly newer method, also since outlawed (and used as a way to fix problems).

The biggest problem I think with the alu wiring was not even that it could not work, but that people would use it with the wrong connectors, the al specific sockets were pretty pricey.

The only place where I know that aluminum is still used in residential wiring is on the entrance wire from the pole to the transformer, usually that's a very tricky connector that uses wedges to make the contact.

If I found myself in a house with aluminum wiring I'd probably rewire the whole thing just for safety. Costly (especially with the US system which staples cables to studs) but worth the peace of mind.

Re:Brilliant design: RCA student radically improves the UK plug by ars on Tuesday October 12, 2010 @10:55PM (#1785899)
No, I mean don't tighten it at all! Not unless you open it and add anti-oxidant. If you tighten it you break the air seal, and allow it to oxidize, and aluminium oxide does not conduct.

The correct installation uses anti-oxidant to seal it, then you tighten it enough to crack the aluminum oxide, and the anti-oxidant protects it. If you tighten it without fresh anti-oxidant you are creating a hazard.

And pig tails are not outlawed - quite the opposite, they are the recommended way to handle aluminium wiring.

Re:Brilliant design: RCA student radically improves the UK plug by jacquesm on Tuesday October 12, 2010 @11:00PM (#1785922)
> No, I mean don't tighten it at all! Not unless you open it and add anti-oxidant. If you tighten it you break the air seal, and allow it to oxidize, and aluminium oxide does not conduct.

Ah ok, I see what you mean now, yes that makes good sense.

As for the pigtails, as far as I know you can not make any new wiring with Aluminum in residential installations, pigtailed or not (I left my code book in Canada because it is of no use to me here, maybe there is some up-to-date online resource). Industrial use is still ok I believe.

Re:Brilliant design: RCA student radically improves the UK plug by ars on Wednesday October 13, 2010 @01:26AM (#1786187)
> as far as I know you can not make any new wiring with Aluminum in residential installations, pigtailed or not

Yes. But if you already have aluminium wiring you can - and should - add pigtails to it to make it safer.

Re:Brilliant design: RCA student radically improves the UK plug by Vivtek on Tuesday October 12, 2010 @10:46PM (#1785871)
I've seen soot on contacts. But then I have wiring in my house that Thomas Edison personally came and installed.