News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:From GNU social to Mastodon by jancsika on Sunday August 26, 2018 @08:26PM (#17848684)
Let me see if I understand the problem.

alice register on instance "music"

alice wants to see what's up on instance "books"

Is the problem that the default behavior of Mastodon requires alice to register a new account on "books" just to see that instance's timeline?

Re:From GNU social to Mastodon by elago on Sunday August 26, 2018 @10:25PM (#17849095)
I wouldn't say that's the problem. You do not need to register a new account to see an instance's timeline.

For example this page shows the instance's timeline without logging in: https://mastodon.sdf.org/about

If you like someone's toots there, you can follow and message any user on SDF's instance from your account on any other instance.

As mentioned elsewhere, the only thing you would gain by creating an account on sdf.org is to have your toots appear by default in the local timeline of other sdf.org users.

Re:From GNU social to Mastodon by justinpombrio on Sunday August 26, 2018 @09:03PM (#17848798)
Yes, that is exactly the problem.

Although it might be better to say that that's the manifestation of the real problem. The real problem is that I want to be able to talk about books sometimes, even though I'm a musician so I registered on the musician instance. If there's a way for me to have conversations about books, I don't care whether it's an "instance" or not. I just don't want to manage two separate accounts. (As an end-user, none of my end-goals mention the word "instance".)

Re:From GNU social to Mastodon by jancsika on Sunday August 26, 2018 @09:39PM (#17848911)
Yeah, I guess I'm confused about why an instance has any topic whatsoever associated with it.

For a federated design I'd assume the main difference among instances to be code of conduct/ToS.

Re:From GNU social to Mastodon by opan on Monday August 27, 2018 @01:38AM (#17849644)
I've been on one Mastodon instance and one Pleroma instance. Neither really had a set topic, and both pulled in some toots from other instances that were "similar", but my posts are about anything I want, as they would be on Twitter.
Re:From GNU social to Mastodon by jaequery on Sunday August 26, 2018 @11:41PM (#17849301)
Slack also have this same "problem" but strangely enough, it didn't stop them from growing as they are now.
Re:From GNU social to Mastodon by skybrian on Sunday August 26, 2018 @10:47PM (#17849148)
There is a limited "A look inside" view in each Mastodon instance's web interface, but it doesn't compare to reading a subreddit anonymously where you can basically read everything without joining.

More generally, my question is how do you meet people who are talking about something interesting to you? (Considering that there aren't many people using Mastodon yet, I don't expect to chat with people I know.)

The web forum/subreddit model makes it considerably easier to find interesting subject-based communities. This doesn't seem to be what Mastodon was designed for, but it seems like a good idea.