That uses an offset price of $7/ton, which seems rather low. Otherwise, offsetting the world's emissions would be only about $200b a year (.2% of world economy)
SFO -> JFK direct round-trip in July for about 0.9 metric tons
The problem with a voluntary offsetting regime to calculate damage prices is that the clearing price is the marginal cost of abatement for a voluntarily requested amount of CO2 to be abated. As more CO2 is requested to be abated, the marginal costs go up (less low hanging fruit like planting trees).
Regardless, while you might feel good that you paid $10/ton to abate your flight, the reality is that if everyone else did this, you'd be paying a lot more than $10/ton.
A fun read: http://environment.yale.edu/kotchen/pubs/explain.pdf
(There's also controversy whether a project that produces X abatement credits really is abating that much carbon, but that's another story).
https://www.myclimate.org/fileadmin/myc/files_myc_perf/12_fl...
You know when you travel by plane, you fly over most of the terrain you might have encountered if you took a bicycle? What's more detrimental now? Twain wrote,
"Travel is fatal to prejudice, bigotry, and narrow-mindedness, and many of our people need it sorely on these accounts. Broad, wholesome, charitable views of men and things cannot be acquired by vegetating in one little corner of the earth all one's lifetime."
But read his books, and you'll see how he traveled: slowly.
> a carbon offset for a round-trip cross-country commercial flight is about $10
You can't buy yourself out of your contribution to CO2 in the air. That $10 doesn't remove anything. It buys piece of mind, and the hope that things in the future may be better. For now, the world keeps warming. There's no capitalistic mechanism invented yet that's going to change that.
I agree that a carbon offset doesn't absolve you of responsibility, but like everything in life, it's tradeoffs.
What's so complicated about "tax people that produce CO2, pay people that capture CO2"?