Tesla is not bankrupt, and it's producing some cars. Its stock price is high. If those are the only criteria you have for success then fine. But they're not successful on the terms that they themselves set.
My impression from reading HN articles over the last couple years has been the exact opposite, the Model 3 being the prime example of that.
https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-tesla-tracker/
Here we are, 8 months later, how would you say they are doing?
For example, in 2016 [1] Tesla set a target of 100,000 Model 3s produced in 2017 and 400,000 in 2018. End of 2018 is getting close, and Tesla's at less than 30% of the 2017 target, let alone 2018.
After that particular failure to achieve production goals, the stated goal for Q3 2017 was revised to 1,500 new cars built [2]. Tesla built 237 instead.
In other words: yeah, Tesla might look like it's "on target" now, but only because it shifted the goalposts after having been very much off target for more than a year now. There are hundreds of thousands of customers still waiting for their cars because of how thoroughly Tesla missed its original production goals.
Tesla's on the right track now, but only after a very rocky road getting there.
--
[1]: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-tesla-suppliers-idUSKCN0Y...
[2]: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-10-02/tesla-sal...
Musk's bizarre behavior is concerning, but his organization structure seemed to be working.