News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Staying Public by Animats on Saturday August 25, 2018 @03:05AM (#17839923)
Musk still has an "only I can do it" mindset. The guy is working himself too hard, not getting enough sleep, and making bad decisions. As CEO, he should not be trying to fix an assembly line. His job is to build a team to do that, give them enough authority to do the job, get out of their way, and check up on them occasionally.

Here's Tesla's top management, according to Tesla.[1] There's Musk. There's a chief financial officer. And there's a chief technical officer who's a battery electric powertrain expert. Where's the chief operating officer?

There's a VP for manufacturing, Gilbert Passim. But check out his Linkedin page.[2] He's listed as running Tesla's various operations other than direct vehicle production. When he was hired by Tesla in 2010, he was relocated from Pleasanton to southern California. There must be a plant manager and a head of manufacturing engineering, but they seem to be far enough down that they have zero Google visibility.

It looks like Musk set this up so that there's him, and then there's a bunch of people who report to him, none of whom has full authority over manufacturing. It's not working.

[1] http://ir.tesla.com/corporate-governance/management [2] https://www.linkedin.com/in/gilbert-passin-74a36117

Re:Staying Public by goshx on Saturday August 25, 2018 @09:39AM (#17840722)
> Musk still has an "only I can do it" mindset.

That seems to be his mission and it's pretty clear he is willing to do what it takes to accomplish it and the board and supporters know it. I have to disagree that "it's not working", unless you want to ignore all the accomplishments by Tesla.

It's funny how everybody and their dogs are now experts and think they know better than Musk how he should be doing things. I wish more of these people actually started car companies so perhaps we (US market) would have more companies in the "major automakers" category other than Tesla and other 3 companies from the beginning of the previous century.

Re:Staying Public by koonsolo on Sunday August 26, 2018 @04:17AM (#17844883)
> It's funny how everybody and their dogs are now experts and think they know better than Musk how he should be doing things.

This was exactly my thought!

There is not a single person in the world who can advise Musk on how to enter the established car industry with a new company.

But hey, if people think they can advice Elon Musk, go right ahead.

I, on the other hand, would prefer to be advised by Elon Musk. Since that's now going to happen soon, I keep my eyes open and try to learn.

Re:Staying Public by dplgk on Saturday August 25, 2018 @03:32PM (#17842182)
Ok, so what is your support for the idea that he knows what he's doing? Because Tesla still exists? Everybody and their dogs think they are experts but people that support Musk are smart laymen or informed experts?
Re:Staying Public by goshx on Saturday August 25, 2018 @11:21PM (#17844045)
Visit a Tesla store.

Go drive a Tesla.

Buy a Tesla and realize how smooth the purchasing process is.

Take it on a road trip and use the supercharger network.

Use their service centers.

Use their mobile service.

Use their energy products.

Now consider the fact that all this was engineered and built in 15 years, with lots of enemies with huge amounts of capital to make sure they fail, and yet here they are and every single item on this list is a leap of improvement compared to the status quo.

You have to try too hard not to realize that he sure knows what he is doing and fit the “haters gonna hate” club.

Re:Staying Public by shawn on Saturday August 25, 2018 @05:45AM (#17840248)
But it seems to be working, right? Tesla has been hitting their goals, and the stock price has been going up.

Musk's bizarre behavior is concerning, but his organization structure seemed to be working.

Re:Staying Public by slivym on Saturday August 25, 2018 @01:59PM (#17841782)
Sorry but Tesla is not meeting its targets. It has a phenomenal reputation for missing targets repeatedly and finally hitting them in a 'kind of' style. The 5000 is the obvious example - they missed the target by almost a year, had to build a separate outdoor production line (which means the numbers are no longer reflective of their production line) and it turns out their first pass rate was something like 14%.

Tesla is not bankrupt, and it's producing some cars. Its stock price is high. If those are the only criteria you have for success then fine. But they're not successful on the terms that they themselves set.

Re:Staying Public by dplgk on Saturday August 25, 2018 @03:34PM (#17842191)
They have bit been "hitting" their goals. They hit a goal once. Assuming you're talking about their production target for the model 3, which has been reported to have a very high rate (Compared to industry standards) of reworking.
Re:Staying Public by yellowapple on Sunday August 26, 2018 @09:25AM (#17845831)
"Tesla has been hitting their goals"

My impression from reading HN articles over the last couple years has been the exact opposite, the Model 3 being the prime example of that.

Re:Staying Public by greglindahl on Sunday August 26, 2018 @12:24PM (#17846555)
Yeah, plenty of people on HN love to repeat that. Check out how Tesla has been doing with their most recent Model 3 production target, which was announced at the end of 2017:

https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-tesla-tracker/

Here we are, 8 months later, how would you say they are doing?

Re:Staying Public by yellowapple on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @08:38PM (#17864187)
Key point there is "most recent production target". Tesla has been constantly revising its production targets as it fails to achieve prior targets.

For example, in 2016 [1] Tesla set a target of 100,000 Model 3s produced in 2017 and 400,000 in 2018. End of 2018 is getting close, and Tesla's at less than 30% of the 2017 target, let alone 2018.

After that particular failure to achieve production goals, the stated goal for Q3 2017 was revised to 1,500 new cars built [2]. Tesla built 237 instead.

In other words: yeah, Tesla might look like it's "on target" now, but only because it shifted the goalposts after having been very much off target for more than a year now. There are hundreds of thousands of customers still waiting for their cars because of how thoroughly Tesla missed its original production goals.

Tesla's on the right track now, but only after a very rocky road getting there.

--

[1]: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-tesla-suppliers-idUSKCN0Y...

[2]: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-10-02/tesla-sal...