News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Staying Public by rhema on Friday August 24, 2018 @11:34PM (#17839363)
> That said, my belief that there is more than enough funding to take Tesla private was reinforced during this process.

Is this some kind of threat or positioning towards actors somewhere? Is this like someone in a relationship saying, "I know I be with someone else if I wanted to, but this is working out for now."?

What's the point of all of this, besides saying that Tesla has lots of funding options?

Re:Staying Public by jnmandal on Friday August 24, 2018 @11:40PM (#17839383)
I think he is saying this because of the risk of his going to jail. If it comes out that he was bluffing, statements he made could very well be considered securities fraud since it amounted to an announcement on a public forum and he had cited a specific price. So by reiterating in an official press release that he had adequate funding but just chose not to do it, there's kind of a supporting evidence to defend himself against any SEC investigations.
Re:Staying Public by Robotbeat on Saturday August 25, 2018 @12:30AM (#17839547)
Fined at worst. Jail is absurd unless he, like, sold a bunch of shares at the top or something (which he didn't).
Re:Staying Public by karpodiem on Saturday August 25, 2018 @12:53AM (#17839610)
Martin Shkreli is serving seven years in prison for less.
Re:Staying Public by craftyguy on Saturday August 25, 2018 @01:39AM (#17839719)
Meanwhile Brian Krzanich is wandering around as free as a coconut on open water after selling as much as he legally could right before the spectre/meltdown announcement.
Re:Staying Public by slivym on Saturday August 25, 2018 @04:16AM (#17840080)
It's very difficult to say that what Krzanich did was related to Spectre/Meltdown given what we now know was going on. It seems a lot more likely he was lining up his position to resign.
Re:Staying Public by thaumaturgy on Saturday August 25, 2018 @02:57AM (#17839911)
Shkreli is serving that time primarily because he was an unrepentant arrogant ass. He had several opportunities to let people forget about him, but he kept marching back and forth in front of the firing squad telling them all what idiots they were.
Re:Staying Public by slededit on Saturday August 25, 2018 @03:42AM (#17840000)
Justice was never blind, but I do find it disturbing we've lost all pretense.
Re:Staying Public by ThrustVectoring on Saturday August 25, 2018 @01:48AM (#17839743)
Martin Shkreli is also much more hate-able, less charismatic, and less wealthy. It shouldn't make a difference, but it does.
Re:Staying Public by hawkice on Saturday August 25, 2018 @06:32AM (#17840324)
Elon Musk has an obvious technical competence that's very appealing to those who appreciate those skill sets. It's like Paul Graham -- when you listen to him speak, he's mostly soft-spoken and measured (I have no explanation for Musk's Twitter, which seems much more... hyperbolic). It's clear to me this isn't charisma exactly -- he doesn't strike me as charming, just like he cares a lot about understanding his businesses in tremendous detail.

You're absolutely right that this shouldn't matter. But since charisma _does_ matter, the SEC just has to paint him as an angry anorak trying to punish short sellers. I don't think that picture is hard to paint (I can't see into his mind, so obviously I have no idea if it has even the smallest element of truth).

Re:Staying Public by flafla2 on Friday August 24, 2018 @11:46PM (#17839411)
I understood this comment as Elon reaffirming to his shareholders that he was not trying to defraud them, and that there actually was adequate funding to take Tesla private. This could also be part of a preemptive legal defense against the SEC in case Elon is formally investigated / questioned. However I feel that the SEC would be more interested in the specific wording of the "funding secured" tweet, which was blatantly false in light of Tesla's previous post [1] (For those who aren't following along: Elon basically only had a verbal offer to take Tesla private from Saudi investors, not anything in writing).

It's also worth mentioning that the idea of breaking long-term financial news for a Fortune 500 company via Twitter of all places is highly unorthodox and suspect in its own right, so I doubt this comment would have much effect in practice.

[1] https://www.tesla.com/blog/update-taking-Tesla-private

Re:Staying Public by zaroth on Saturday August 25, 2018 @12:05AM (#17839465)
> It's also worth mentioning that the idea of breaking long-term financial news for a Fortune 500 company via Twitter of all places is highly unorthodox and suspect in its own right

The SEC has indicated that Twitter is an approapriate venue for making public statements, as long as the company has indicated that investors should look to Twitter for updates. Tesla did indicate this previously, according to news reports I recall from last week.

I trust Twitter more than just about anyone to ensure no one is getting the jump on seeing the information before anyone else.

And I’ll also mention, Elon has blocked a few user accounts on Twitter. I don’t see a problem with this as anyone can watch Elon’s tweets in incognito mode. The law requires the notice is public, not universal. I can’t think of anything more public than a tweet.

I think the best evidence that Elon was not trying to defraud investors, besides the fact that he did not trade on the news and gained nothing from it, is that it was a contemporaneous tweet he made on his way to the airport.

Re:Staying Public by freerobby on Friday August 24, 2018 @11:57PM (#17839443)
> It's also worth mentioning that the idea of breaking long-term financial news for a Fortune 500 company via Twitter of all places is highly unorthodox and suspect in its own right, so I doubt this comment would have much effect in practice.

Elon can't have this both ways, though. Tesla has disclosed that it will use social media for financially material announcements, and Elon has embraced this. It can't be legitimate most of the time and illegitimate when it makes for a convenient defense.

Personally, I don't think Elon's intention was to defraud -- I think he was impulsive and careless, and I expect the SEC will reach the same conclusion. But I think if he's going to use Twitter to talk about such things, his tweets need to carry the same weight as an equivalent SEC filing.

Re:Staying Public by zaroth on Saturday August 25, 2018 @12:15AM (#17839500)
> But I think if he's going to use Twitter to talk about such things, his tweets need to carry the same weight as an equivalent SEC filing.

A tweet is not an SEC filing and it can never be one. It’s 140 characters typed on your phone. It is not reviewed by corporate counsel. It is not reviewed at all.

I’m going to step out on a limb and say this is an important mode of communication. I like having this window into Musk’s operations.

But a tweet is just a tweet. It’s never the whole story. Here we are dissecting two single words, and some people are saying jail a man.

I say no two words on Twitter can jail a man. Fine him a million dollars a word if you have to.

Re:Staying Public by taneq on Saturday August 25, 2018 @01:33AM (#17839702)
> I say no two words on Twitter can jail a man. Fine him a million dollars a word if you have to.

By convention, with two words you're 1/3 of the way to a hanging.

Re:Staying Public by freerobby on Saturday August 25, 2018 @07:43AM (#17840466)
> A tweet is not an SEC filing and it can never be one. It’s 140 characters typed on your phone. It is not reviewed by corporate counsel. It is not reviewed at all.

Right, but this is exactly the downside of disclosing things via Twitter. If Elon uses tweets and SEC filings interchangeably (that is what he's doing here -- this would ordinarily be disclosed in an 8-K), the rules are going to apply to both. It's not that I'm unsympathetic to his intentions, but the SEC can't carve out exceptions for impulsive behavior just because it happened on social media -- traders are acting on this information in real time and need to be able to trust it.

(I agree the calls for imprisonment are beyond insane; I focus on the Twitter vs 8-K part of the story because I find it more interesting, and I'd like to see more CEOs speak directly to followers as Elon does but with a bit less impulsivity).

Re:Staying Public by matthewwiese on Saturday August 25, 2018 @12:59AM (#17839619)
> I say no two words on Twitter can jail a man.

What about "I confess"? :)

Nevertheless, I think the spirit of your argument is mostly valid. Musk is doing the equivalent of Roosevelt's fireside chats. Granted, he should be smarter than to tweet willy-nilly, but I suppose we can say the same for just about everybody on Twitter nowadays...

Re:Staying Public by dixie_land on Saturday August 25, 2018 @12:13AM (#17839490)
I also don't think pumping up stock price to avoid a convertible bond conversion is fraud. And of course OJ is innocent too.
Re:Staying Public by zaroth on Saturday August 25, 2018 @12:18AM (#17839513)
This is clearly not what happened, and never was planned to happen.

The bonds don’t convert for another year.

You don’t send a tweet about something that will immediately have a thousand people banging down your door for answers and expect it to move the stock price a year later.

There was zero personal financial incentive for Musk to deceive with the tweet.

As it happens, the criminal statute requires that a purchase or sale of securities takes place, so I can’t see how it applies.

Re:Staying Public by dplgk on Saturday August 25, 2018 @03:41PM (#17842235)
No, he wasn't trying to defraud his shareholders. Quite the opposite - defraud his skeptics aka short sellers.
Re:Staying Public by dforrestwilson on Friday August 24, 2018 @11:37PM (#17839376)
This past week was about covering the legal angles so that Elon doesn’t go to jail while still attempting to mollify bulls.
Re:Staying Public by mdorazio on Friday August 24, 2018 @11:38PM (#17839379)
It's almost certainly an attempt to stave off the SEC investigation into misleading statements by Elon when he tweeted originally that funding was secured.
Re:Staying Public by meritt on Friday August 24, 2018 @11:41PM (#17839390)
If Tesla was actually going private his "Funding Secured" tweet wouldn't be viewed with as much scrutiny. Instead, coupled with his on-going public threats against short sellers, that tweet is now even more likely to be viewed as intentional market manipulation.

This will only continue and reinforce the SEC investigation.

Re:Staying Public by karpodiem on Friday August 24, 2018 @11:43PM (#17839403)
This does this opposite. This is the opposite of 'funding secured', because now he has to PROVE that funding actually was secured. It wasn't.
Re:Staying Public by tedunangst on Friday August 24, 2018 @11:37PM (#17839377)
Blame the shorts, blah, blah. "I could totally squeeze the shorts at 420 but I won't because I don't care even one bit about the shorts."
Re:Staying Public by dawhizkid on Saturday August 25, 2018 @12:56AM (#17839613)
He’s saying it because if it was totally untrue then he likely committed massive securities fraud
Re:Staying Public by freerobby on Friday August 24, 2018 @11:39PM (#17839382)
It reinforces the narrative that this was his choice about what is best for Tesla, and not a market-driven outcome to remain public in spite of a desire to privatize.