This is nice in theory but certainly false in practice.
In practice much of the price paid for capital-goods is not for capital at all, but for land and monopoly priviliges. In real estate, the land share of real estate value can be 60% of the total investment.
Payments for land and investment in land purchases are always surplus payments beyond what is necessary to bring land into use as a factor of production, because land is a fixed natural resource which does not have a labor cost of production.
When investment in land increases through land banking, this increases the opportunity cost of investing in businesses which employ labor to produce goods and services, which decreases the demand for labor and lowers wages.
Policies which are designed to increase investment and savings over consumption typically decrease economic output and slow growth, because while increased consumption of labor produced goods and services increases the profits for investing in productive businesses supplying these services and the demand for labor, increased investment does not necessarily increase the demand for labor or the supply of labor produced goods and services at all.
It's possible for policies promoting increased investment and savings to promote nothing more than land banking and investors holding empty parking lots while waiting for a speculative increase in price.
If all land was owned by one evil monopoly, and it was slowly being sold, even at insane prices - is that not productive in the sense that land in the future is more distributed than land in the past? Certainly it seems to me to be at least as worthy as short term entertainment and luxury - particularly ecologicaly - but purely economically too?
Anyhow - you’re not wrong at all - investment in land is certainly one of the things being favored instead of coffee - but this seems exclusively like a value judgment to me (who is to say what the price of land ought to be but the owners of the land?)
Factories producing a lot of income have capital efficiencies much higher than that.
Consumer goods do not have any kind of capital efficiency. This means that typically their total economic efficiency is lower, sometimes much lower, than 1.
(note that certain goods can be considered both capital and consumer, e.g. cars - it depends on use)
- From wages, which are paid by enterprises that create the goods that are consumed
- From investment gains in enterprises that create the goods that are consumed
Its consumption all the way down.
There is an order to things. It all begins with first producing/making something, no matter what segment of the economy you're talking about. Sure, you can start by borrowing (from someone else that has produced something), and eventually you still have to produce to pay for that front loaded consumption.
Further, how do you plan to continue consuming sunlight on your skin, without producing something to then get food and shelter to survive another day or week of absorbing sunlight? How did you buy that living time in the first place, without producing anything to get you food and shelter to be alive in the present? Someone had to produce first.
And if you want to go more elaborately into the concept economically (sunlight based energy generation), you need land and technology to turn that sunlight into consequential electricity. You must produce first to generate and consume the sun-based electricity.
The benefits of sunlight can only be acquired if one has acquired a place on Earth to stand, suitable places to stand have been enclosed by land titles, and land rent or profits which can be acquired from ownership of these titles without having to produce anything make up at minimum 20% of national GDP.
Land and sunlight are consumed by virtue of occupying a physical space on Earth, and play an extremely large role in the economy, but land and sunlight were never produced by the economy or as a result of economic processes. They are instead the product of natural physical processes which pre-existed the evolution of humans.
All goods are certainly not the result of economic production, as this would create a chicken-and-egg problem where human civilization could not exist unless another human civilization was around to produce it.
It is called a durable good. Land is about the most durable of all.
Consumable is another name for a non durable good.
Use of consumer durable goods is not the same as consumption - it is typically considered depreciation.
The process starts with government who can spend money without producing anything. Where do you think the actual currency units came from? Money doesn't grow on trees.
In fact it is the only real capital that exists. The rest is just leverage. In a real economy all debts must be settled with sovereign debt ie currency.
> The government could give everyone a trillion dollars, but whoever actually owns land and factories and natural resources will still be the people with capital.
You've fallen to our own confusion. This is the classic mistake of people who don't understand Marx: the mere presence of assets doesn't make you a capitalist. Everybody has assets. It is only the people with currency (more precisely, the people owed currency) that are capitalists because their assets are sovereign liabilities and therefore must be accepted for all debt settlements. The "inside economy" can actually grow as long as people accept the sovereign debt for payments. The only limit of this process are the sovereign's borders and the existence of foreigners who refuse to be paid with the sovereign debt.
This is important, particularly if you want to understand what's actually happening in China, where the entire system is driven by massive amounts of sovereign debt but the country as a whole has zero external debts (including its external assets). Growth, as the last forty years of China's history makes very clear, is not limited by any kind of exogenous investment. Countries don't need to borrow money to grow despite the narrative pushed by the global bankers.
I agree with and accept your points about debts and liabilities etc., and they don't seem to conflict with what I was saying otherwise.
Maybe we just agree and are clarifying semantic terms…
Yes, we agree. My point is that "private ownership" is just another way of saying that people have accumulated sovereign debt. There's no reason the sovereign must issue these debts by the way, the sovereign could directly seize control of all assets and try to satisfy all wants itself, but these days everybody pretty much agrees the sovereign should issue debt and not try to do everything itself.
When it comes to growth, (the original question, "Where does the capital come from that flows in to savings?"), all of the debt in the system (particularly the private debts that are created when capitalists borrow and lend money) must be leveraged off existing stock of sovereign debt. If there was no sovereign debt there would literally be no money (in any form) to invest or borrow.
As far as creating currency, as I understand it, it works out to be a lot more effective and efficient for the state to issue that debt-currency (and create demand for it through taxing it back) and thus create markets using it than to directly manage resources through a top-down bureaucracy. (To be simplistic admittedly)
Just ask Venezuela how monetary production with collapsed supporting production works out.
Yeah, this isn't how it works at all. Not surprising that people like you don't grasp very basics but try to think this through carefully:
Governments can and do regularly summon and dismiss debts out of thin air. It's the very definition of sovereign.
Venezuela's problems, like all sovereign debt problems before and since (see Germany, Zimbabwe, Rome), are due to its external dependencies. It has external debts. That means it participates in relationships where it is not a sovereign. Do you really think if Venezuela didn't need to import certain items (and therefore didn't need to borrow dollars) it would have any problems at all? And so no, "monetary power" actually has nothing to do with production capacity.
If we live more consuming lifestyles, we drive up the demand for resources which could increase the motivation of people to get them and thus drive economic growth short-term, until/unless we use up the resources entirely. And that all still ignores externalized costs (pollution and other harms) that can come from the extra consumption.
Taking this to an absurd extreme, the last human alive could have all the money in the world and it would do them no good at all -- all that money would have exactly zero value (well, the cash could be used as fuel or toilet paper, but that's it, and most money isn't and wouldn't be cash anyways).
Now, a society might be able to survive having an inverted population pyramid for a while, or even a very long time (generations) but e.g., dedicating more of its economy and people to elder care, by automating more of elder care, and so on. So it's exactly not all bad. Nor am I saying that fertility rates should be above replacement rates -- we all know that we can't have exponential population (or even economic) growth without end on Earth. But do note that an economy with a long-term inverted population pyramid tends to be inflationary: the elderly will have a lot of money (as usual), yes, but it will be chasing a smaller population of service providers.
Talk about Childhood's End.
Sustainability yes, self-destruction no.
In the long-term I do assume -perhaps wrongly!- that countries with negative population growth will eventually stabilize their fertility rates at replacement rate (probably with an overshoot on the upswing).
When the imports get more expensive because of tariffs it's by definition the tariffs imposed by importing country, i.e. China in this case.
I'm not an economist, but from what little I know, the Neoclassical / Solow-Swan model¹ ² defines output as a function of Labor, Capital and Productivity. Long story short, consumption doesn't drive economic growth.
__________
The primary impetus of the development of neo-classical theories economics excluded was United States government land grants to railroad companies during the westward expansion of the 19th century. The railroad barons took over the economics departments of private universities which were previously controlled by the clergy, began firing professors which held to classical economic theories, as there was no tenure for professors at the time. They instead began funding professors such as John Bates Clarke, who repckaged Marxist economist theory that capital was 'jelly' and land and natural resources no longer exist.
"Neo-Classical Economics as a Strategem against Henry George" documents how land and natural resources were removed from classical economic theories during the development of neo-classical economics in order to promote the interests of wealthy land owners in the United States during the 18th century:
http://www.masongaffney.org/publications/K1Neo-classical_Str...
Well, the problem with using that statement to downplay consumption is that it starts with the objective of wanting to increase production. But why would one want to increase production? Because demand(consumption) demands it.
And rightly so. It's basically an indicator of how fast a society is turning resources in trash for profit. Probably it wasn't always like this, but nowadays I think that's the only metric it represents.
P.s. Houses are a consumer
As for good and bad investment, let's take an absurdist example for fun and clarification. A savings bank lends individuals' savings to two farmers for their yearly crops.
Farmer A plants a 10,000 seeds of barley, and his neighbor Farmer B plants what are essentially small stones, 10,000 sterile seeds (perhaps he's been duped by someone or by his own misguided ideas into believing that they're fertile).
Both farmers will spend the same on labor, water, perhaps the same on the seeds, and so on, so the savings will be turned into spending as Hazlitt says, but their harvests will clearly be different. Farmer A will reap a growth in total value, while the planter of sterile seeds -- Farmer B -- has created no new value despite having spent the savings lent by the bank, which he now must repay. Because of his bad investment he can't repay the bank and must sell his farm.
If it turns out that many other farmers also planted these sterile seeds and can't repay their loans (other people's savings) the bank will default and great harm will be done to the community (who, if this is an idealized small and local economy, must also deal with a reduced supply of grains).
Instead of farmers planting sterile seeds, in China you have local governments planting sterile infrastructure projects and borrowing heavily to do so. The debt on these and other projects is mounting at an alarming rate. Why are these sterile seeds being planted? Because the easy infrastructure investments have already been made, and there is little other means to create 6% GDP growth without either increasing exports (ahem) or increasing demand, in other words increasing consumer spending so that savings could be invested in the creation of products and services to be sold to households rather than in sterile infrastructure projects.
The best explainer of this stuff that I know of is Michael Pettis, who teaches finance at Peking University. Here's a relevant article from his excellent blog: http://carnegieendowment.org/chinafinancialmarkets/72997
EDIT: By the way, increasing household income is the best justification I've heard for Xi Jinping's extreme and otherwise frightening power grab, because a shift like that (increasing household income) requires going against mighty interests: local governments and the wealthy.
I tend to celebrate such fair, intellectual posts! But in this case… consumption as economic indicator isn't just troubling, it's horrific.
Our economic measures are not just mediocre, but actually destructively backwards. They are measures that actively push us to catastrophes, unhappiness, destruction…
GDP etc. would triple instantly if we just paid our neighbors to do one another's housework.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons
[2] https://www.georgesoros.com/2012/06/02/remarks_at_the_festiv...
Edit: I agree with you. If you'd dropped the lead sentences you wouldn't have been downvoted. HN as a whole seems to react badly to hyperbole, but positively to unjustified, broad, faux-intellectual claims. Haha :)
My hyperbolic-seeming opening line was actually emphasizing that it's not even hyperbole. AND I CAN'T EDIT to emphasize that I was NOT being sarcastic! (I realize now people probably guessed I was sarcastic when I was actually sincere).
The classic models of economics really are that bad, no exaggeration. The post I was replying to was both correct and truly understated.
I think the tragedy of the commons is just an example of a whole class of similar phenomena that exist and that classic economic models ignore.
And you're plainly right about the "mass psychology" macro-level stuff, but that's also not the whole picture.
The core issue is that macro level phenomena are real. So much economics today actually claims that macro is nothing more than aggregate micro (and they get micro wrong too, with simplistic understanding of psychology when considered at all and so much else).
I heard this analogy from a friend (don't know the original source though): assuming we can understand macro by studying micro is like saying we can understand the behavior of a gas by simply tracking the isolated locations and movements of single molecules!
But from a purely economic standpoint - saving is not a bad thing. Murray Rothbard wrote the following (fairly obvious statement):
"To increase production, man must form capital. To create it, he must restrict his consumption and transfer his labor for that period to producing immediately-satisfying consumers’ goods."
The article explicitly mentions the -goals- of those who are saving - to buy homes or raise children. Henry Hazlitt writes:
"But when money is invested it is used to buy capital goods–houses or office buildings or factories or ships or motor trucks or machines. Any one of these projects puts as much money into circulation and gives as much employment as the same amount of money spent directly on consumption. “Saving,” in short, in the modern world, is only another form of spending."
In other words - Why would it ever be bad that people are -expanding- the time horizon of their goals (favoring long term investments over short term ones - ie: houses instead of lattes)? If anything, this ought to be an indicator of a strengthening economy, even if it means "slumping" share prices in the meantime.