News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft Bug Testers Unionized, Then They Were Dismissed by thrill on Thursday August 23, 2018 @05:32PM (#17830860)
No. I'm an adult. I handle my own issues.
Re:Microsoft Bug Testers Unionized, Then They Were Dismissed by dang on Thursday August 23, 2018 @09:15PM (#17832024)
That's good, but please don't post unsubstantive comments here. Especially not on divisive topics, where the effect will be trollish.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Microsoft Bug Testers Unionized, Then They Were Dismissed by ubernostrum on Thursday August 23, 2018 @05:35PM (#17830883)
Curious: do you also have that attitude toward starting a company? Would you do it with no loans, no investments from others?
Re:Microsoft Bug Testers Unionized, Then They Were Dismissed by thrill on Thursday August 23, 2018 @06:16PM (#17831102)
Why would I think the two should be equivalent or conflated? They are different audiences with different requirements, different risk tolerances, and outside of the shared work, likely different major goals.
Re:Microsoft Bug Testers Unionized, Then They Were Dismissed by ubernostrum on Thursday August 23, 2018 @06:33PM (#17831177)
A corporation is a mechanism for individuals to pool capital and achieve greater return from that capital than any of them would using only their own personal resources.

A union is a mechanism for individuals to pool labor and achieve greater return from that labor than any of them would using only their own personal resources.

The only difference between them is the resource being pooled. As a result, I have great difficulty understanding why people are accepting of one but condemn the other.

Re:Microsoft Bug Testers Unionized, Then They Were Dismissed by rcoveson on Thursday August 23, 2018 @06:54PM (#17831279)
Corporations pool resources to make things or offer services. Unions are just bargaining devices that attempt to tip the scales.

If you want to compare unions to corporations, consider this: What if all the local companies got together and agreed to only pay tech workers minimum wage? By pooling their bargaining power, they can achieve a far better result!

This is of course illegal (at least I'm pretty sure it is), but even if it weren't, it would be easy for startups to take advantage of: Suddenly, there's a surplus of tech workers looking hard for different work. Unions have the same problem: Some people might be happy to work for wages that the union considers unfair, causing the union to collapse. Unless, that is, there were some law requiring the businesses to only hire from the unions.

I'm extremely happy to be employed in a field where I have natural bargaining power that doesn't need to be augmented by legislation. The day programmers unionize is a sad day indeed: It's just a few years before the whole profession is automated or outsourced away.

Re:Microsoft Bug Testers Unionized, Then They Were Dismissed by ChuckMcM on Thursday August 23, 2018 @07:13PM (#17831370)
Interesting question:

What if all the local companies got together and agreed to only pay tech workers minimum wage?

Rather than use a hypothetical, lets use a couple of actual things that have happened; "all the local tech companies got together and:"

   * agreed not to offer jobs to the other's workers
   * agreed to get H1B visas rather than pay hire wages
   * converted previous employee jobs into contracting
These are all things that have happened which could not be counter acted by disorganized labor pools. So when you say "I'm extremely happy to be employed in a field where I have natural bargaining power that doesn't need to be augmented by legislation." I expect you will find at some point in your career that your "natural bargaining power" will erode and you will be in a position where the lack of any bargaining power will benefit the corporation disproportionately.

I think it is great that this hasn't happened to you yet but it would be unwise to assume it will never happen.

Re:Microsoft Bug Testers Unionized, Then They Were Dismissed by ubernostrum on Thursday August 23, 2018 @07:49PM (#17831591)
This is of course illegal

I wonder how it came to be illegal. Did legislative bodies pass laws to protect workers solely out of the pure and spontaneous goodness of the legislators' hearts?

Or did they pass these laws because people organized and agitated and worked to get these laws passed?

If only there were some sort of books of history we could go look this stuff up in to find out.

And I think you'll find corporations have problems and excesses, too, but you seem perfectly willing to tolerate those.

As to the rest, see the other replies: "I have and have always had good bargaining power" does not imply "I will always have good bargaining power". In fact, the belief that how things are now is how they always must be is one of the most basic economic mistakes a person can make.

Re:Microsoft Bug Testers Unionized, Then They Were Dismissed by chimeracoder on Thursday August 23, 2018 @08:08PM (#17831705)
> I wonder how it came to be illegal. Did legislative bodies pass laws to protect workers solely out of the pure and spontaneous goodness of the legislators' hearts? Or did they pass these laws because people organized and agitated and worked to get these laws passed?

Wait, are you really going to try and give unions credit for antitrust laws (ie, the laws that OP is referring to)?

The first antitrust laws outlawed collusion, which also had the effect of outlawing a lot of common union activities as well. Labor unions fought to exempt themselves from antitrust laws.

Re:Microsoft Bug Testers Unionized, Then They Were Dismissed by ubernostrum on Thursday August 23, 2018 @08:14PM (#17831731)
I'm going to give the progressive movements of the turn of the 19th/20th century a lot of credit for antitrust and worker-protection laws. I'm also going to ignore anyone whose response is to try to nitpick and split out individual acts and try to attribute them to completely contextless utterly independent forces that had nothing whatsoever to do with anything else happening at the time in any way.
Re:Microsoft Bug Testers Unionized, Then They Were Dismissed by chimeracoder on Thursday August 23, 2018 @08:27PM (#17831806)
> I'm going to give the progressive movements of the turn of the 19th/20th century a lot of credit for antitrust and worker-protection laws. I'm also going to ignore anyone whose response is to try to nitpick and split out individual acts and try to attribute them to completely contextless utterly independent forces that had nothing whatsoever to do with anything else happening at the time in any way.

Nobody's saying that these were "utterly independent forces". I'm pointing out that the relationship between them was the exact opposite of what you claimed. Labor unions opposed antitrust laws which outlawed the sorts of behavior OP described; they certainly weren't responsible for it like you tried to claim.

It sounds like you're interested in ignoring the actual details of the history which disprove your point, in order to paint a certain narrative. In that case, there's probably not much point in discussing further, because that's not what a good-faith discussion looks like.

Re:Microsoft Bug Testers Unionized, Then They Were Dismissed by rcoveson on Thursday August 23, 2018 @10:21PM (#17832298)
> As to the rest, see the other replies: "I have and have always had good bargaining power" does not imply "I will always have good bargaining power". In fact, the belief that how things are now is how they always must be is one of the most basic economic mistakes a person can make.

But I didn't imply that. What I said was that it makes me happy to be in that position. Requirements may change in the future, but I am capable of change as well. Rather than invest in a union to protect me as I become obsolete, I'll invest in my own development to do my best to ensure that doesn't happen.

Programmers are hired without unions for a reason, not because nobody's thought of it yet. Unions are a last-resort crutch to prop up unsustainable employee-employer relationships. Nobody should want to transition from being beholden to no-one to owing their employment to both a union and a government. I could scarcely live with myself.

Re:Microsoft Bug Testers Unionized, Then They Were Dismissed by xvector on Thursday August 23, 2018 @07:13PM (#17831372)
> If you want to compare unions to corporations, consider this: What if all the local companies got together and agreed to only pay tech workers minimum wage? By pooling their bargaining power, they can achieve a far better result!

And this would be totally fine if we valued corporate rights over individual rights.

But as a society, we value individual rights over corporate rights, which is why we allow for unions but not corporate collusion. Any individual cannot stand up to a corporation, but a union of individuals certainly can, supporting the subjective values of our society.

Re:Microsoft Bug Testers Unionized, Then They Were Dismissed by chimeracoder on Thursday August 23, 2018 @08:10PM (#17831719)
> And this would be totally fine if we valued corporate rights over individual rights. But as a society, we value individual rights over corporate rights, which is why we allow for unions but not corporate collusion.

Unions are corporations. They are corporations which claim to represent their members' interests, but under US law, they are not obligated to. (And fittingly, there is actually plenty of evidence to suggest that many do not, which is one of the reasons for decline in both overall union membership and the decline in support for unions among union members).

Re:Microsoft Bug Testers Unionized, Then They Were Dismissed by bdcravens on Thursday August 23, 2018 @09:20PM (#17832044)
Many companies start with no outside investment or debt. Like unions, it's a risk assessment: do you give up control in exchange for stability?
Re:Microsoft Bug Testers Unionized, Then They Were Dismissed by s73v3r_ on Thursday August 23, 2018 @07:07PM (#17831335)
That kind of obstancance isn't a sign of being an adult.
Re:Microsoft Bug Testers Unionized, Then They Were Dismissed by AmericanChopper on Thursday August 23, 2018 @07:26PM (#17831433)
Unions are by their very nature levelling mechanisms, the only real situation they can be of any use is in non-competitive and relatively low skilled labor markets. Anybody who wants to develop their skill set and advance their own careers would want to have nothing to do with unions. If a union negotiates a contract for me, they're not actually doing it for me, they're doing it for everybody, which will mean that I walk away with compensation equal to the average value of all people in the union. If I negotiate compensation for myself, then I can get employer to pay me what I'm actually worth, and none of my salary will be used to subsidise other less ambitious/competent union members.
Re:Microsoft Bug Testers Unionized, Then They Were Dismissed by MereInterest on Thursday August 23, 2018 @08:18PM (#17831760)
That's a very optimistic view, and does not take into account the vast discrepancy in leverage between an employee and an employer.
Re:Microsoft Bug Testers Unionized, Then They Were Dismissed by AmericanChopper on Thursday August 23, 2018 @09:37PM (#17832100)
That leverage only exists in non-competitive labor markets, which are almost exclusively low-skilled. That discrepancy can only arise when labor supply greatly outstrips demand. In such cases, you could make an argument that the disadvantages of the levelling mechanism are outweighed by the protection that unions provide. However, no matter where unions exist, they will always restrict individual contributors ability to advance their own careers, as well as their ability to seek remuneration appropriate for the value of their contributions.
Re:Microsoft Bug Testers Unionized, Then They Were Dismissed by s73v3r_ on Friday August 24, 2018 @12:13PM (#17835833)
"That leverage only exists in non-competitive labor markets, which are almost exclusively low-skilled"

That is flat out not true.

Re:Microsoft Bug Testers Unionized, Then They Were Dismissed by AmericanChopper on Friday August 24, 2018 @05:30PM (#17838016)
It absolutely is true. Employers cannot possibly have a disproportionate amount of leverage in competitive labor markets. what high-skilled markets do you believe are non-competitive? It’s certianly not software engineering, employers compete relentlessly for talent in this market.