News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Advice for Haskell beginners (2017) by KirinDave on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @12:27PM (#17819871)
Addenda (relevant to community musings today):

Be aware that as a small and very distributed community, the Haskell world has less power to eject bad actors than more centrally managed and resourced projects have (e.g., Golang and Rust have much more structural power to moderate). Awful and abusive people exist in the community, and it's best to just start blocking and ignoring folks who disrespect you.

The amazing thing about the Haskell community is that knowledge is very well distributed throughout the community these days. The culture, influenced by academia, strongly values writing and publishing ideas rather than sharing them orally or in the workplace. This means that if you're interested in learning, there are a ton of places and ways to do it.

If you're looking for good initial connections to folks who are respectful, well informed, and unlikely to expose you to some of the frustrating cabals in the community, I've got a few recommendations

1. Gabriel Gonzales (this is his blog, and he's @GabrielG439 on twitter)

2. Chris Martin of TypeClasses. I'd also list his partner in crime Julie Moronuki, but her social media interaction is reduced these days. These two focus on helping programmers get up to speed with haskell from a variety of starting points, and they care more about functional programming than haskell specifics.

3. Patrick Thompson of Github (@importantshock on Twitter). A fantastically skilled person who will link you to a network of amazing Haskell folks who do stuff in a positively next-generational way.

Two people who are adjacent to the Haskell community and incredibly interesting, but probably can't answer direct questions for you. Worth a follow.

1. Dr. Edwin Brady, creator of the Idris language. He's widely respected, humble, and has a beautiful vision for how humans and computers should interact to write programs.

2. Dr. Bodil Stokke (@bodil on twitter). Bodil is not so much a Haskell person these days, but she's got a phenomenal breadth of knowledge and always has interesting things to talk about in the FP space. Worth a follow if you're on that platform.

I suppose you can ask me for help too, but I'm certainly not as competent as these folks.

Re:Advice for Haskell beginners (2017) by NickPollard on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @12:56PM (#17820087)
Can second all these suggestions. Also, from my experience all the Haskell events I've been to have been incredibly welcoming and positive, whilst I'm aware there are a tiny subset of abusive people out there, I've never met them nor met anyone who would tolerate them.

Shoutout if you're in the SF area, BayHac (https://wiki.haskell.org/BayHac2018), a yearly unconference/hackathon is incredibly fun, and also there are (roughly) bi-monthly Haskell meetups (https://www.meetup.com/Bay-Area-Haskell-Users-Group/) in SF which are great fun (disclaimer: I co-organise the meetups - find me @Nick_enGB).

Re:Advice for Haskell beginners (2017) by fp_learner on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @01:31PM (#17820326)
> Addenda (relevant to community musings today): [...] Awful and abusive people exist in the community

Are you referring to people saying negative things about Learn You A Haskell?

Re:Advice for Haskell beginners (2017) by KirinDave on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @01:56PM (#17820517)
No. I'm referring to people like Tony Morris. There are more folks I could name, but I think they're less obvious.

Scala's community essentially began to adopt a thinly-coded code of conduct that said, "Don't be like Tony Morris he literally runs people out of the scala community" it got so bad. He continues to be unrepentant and uses his influence to fan a slow but very distressing conflict between the Cabal community and the Stack developer community.

As for LYAH, it's a decent book. It's got its problems (in some cases it does obnoxious and useless things like make fun of overweight people).

Re:Advice for Haskell beginners (2017) by raffael-vogler on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @02:22PM (#17820727)
https://twitter.com/dibblego/status/1032041025240358912

What's his (Tony Morris') point? Is he putting on a show or is that for real?

Re:Advice for Haskell beginners (2017) by KirinDave on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @02:47PM (#17820943)
He's always like this. He may be physically incapable of accepting censure.

He blocked me when he read my prior comment.

Re:Advice for Haskell beginners (2017) by hood_syntax on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @03:40PM (#17821414)
The guy has serious issues, I was shocked at how toxic he gets at the drop of a hat. I was browsing a discussion on the Haskell subreddit and he was incredibly nasty, literally zero good faith given or assumed of others. Technical opinions aside, I would never want him involved with a project I'm participating in. He fails the only rule I care about: don't be an asshole.
Re:Advice for Haskell beginners (2017) by ad_hominem on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @02:30PM (#17820801)
I don't have any personal knowledge of it but I've heard that the code of conduct you're referencing was actually created and weaponized by certain sociopath-types to eject Tony from his own open source library in a hostile takeover.

And not that it excuses his behavior, but I also seem to recall Tony suffering from some very severe back injuries accompanied by chronic pain.

(Not to white knight a person I'm barely aware of but your description seems pretty one-sided based on what I've seen)

Re:Advice for Haskell beginners (2017) by KirinDave on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @02:44PM (#17820927)
> I don't have any personal knowledge of it but I've heard that the code of conduct you're referencing was actually created and weaponized by certain sociopath-types to eject Tony from his own open source library in a hostile takeover.

Not that I agree with this narrative, because AFAICT it wasn't true, but even if it were? Good. That's the power and mechanism open source working as intended. If you're a burden to the project, you're cast off. And Tony is an insufferable burden. The code is free, and owned by the group.

The fact that he expected "ownership" of a project set up with a leadership committee is a good example of the kind of silly behavior I'm talking about.

> And not that it excuses his behavior, but I also seem to recall Tony suffering from some very severe back injuries accompanied by chronic pain.

I was around for two public declarations of dramatic self harm. I'm told there are more. And I hope he finds a way to deal with these problems, they're serious and can be life threatening. I don't wish violence on him.

But I want him to stop making communities worse with his senseless negativity and hostile communications. If he has problems in his life that impair his ability to interact in this fashion, we should not enable his abusive behavior out of charity. That's actually disrespectful, and while it may benefit Tony in the short term, in the long term he finds himself forced out of communities that no longer can or will bear the weight of his presence.

> your description seems pretty one-sided based on what I've seen

It's certainly one sided: it's my side. I for one ran into him a lot. It seems like he took special delight in demanding I take his impromptu "quizzes" in Scala and he'd hound me ceaselessly until I did. His ultimate goal was to prove I was "not a functional programmer." He's been cut off by a lot of longtime members of the FP community for a reason.

Re:Advice for Haskell beginners (2017) by ad_hominem on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:06PM (#17822669)
Defending Tony Morris isn't really the hill I want to die on, seeing as how I have no experience with the situation and I unfollowed him a long time ago to get away from the negativity myself. I was just repeating what I heard some prominent people mention here and there, but I guess I got a bit too caught up in playing devil's advocate.

Thanks for sharing your unfortunate experience, and I agree that health problems or things like that should not be an excuse to behave poorly. Take care.

Re:Advice for Haskell beginners (2017) by NickPollard on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @02:39PM (#17820872)
Absolutely not. The code of conduct was created to help produce a welcoming and supportive community, and if Tony being kicked out for being neither welcoming nor supportive counts as 'weaponizing', then that's a very strange view. I've met many of the people who were involved in this and they are amongst the nicest, friendliest, accepting people you could meet, and about as far from 'sociopath' as you can imagine.

This idea of a hostile takeover and such is a figment of Tony's imagination and a deliberate distraction equivalent to Trump's referring to the Mueller investigation as a witch hunt.

Re:Advice for Haskell beginners (2017) by ad_hominem on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:16PM (#17821766)
I haven't met any of the people involved but I recall other folks saying the CoC was being used inappropriately

https://twitter.com/puffnfresh/status/519887926327390209

Re:Advice for Haskell beginners (2017) by KirinDave on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:04PM (#17822178)
We're actually conflating two separate but correlated events here, as a few folks in that thread have later acknowledged.

Most folks agree that Tony should be off the project. The problem of one overzealous person trying to get Tony to shut up is a separate and regrettable decision on his part. CoCs act to protect people from behavior like Tony's, not to be a cudgel. AFAIK, it's faced subsequent edits to improve that.

It's unfortunate that Tony's become so incapable of modulating his behavior in public that he forces these issues. It's doubly regrettable that folks associated with the same projects he has contributed to could not handle the unusual situation with more grace and poise.

Re:Advice for Haskell beginners (2017) by CJefferson on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @01:35PM (#17820362)
No, they are (unfortunately) referring to a (small but vocal) group of people who seem to get enjoyment out of insulting, upsetting and demeaning other people, particularly beginners.
Re:Advice for Haskell beginners (2017) by ad_hominem on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @02:00PM (#17820543)
> Dr. Bodil Stokke (@bodil on twitter)

Speaking of "frustrating cabals" just be prepared for a hefty infusion of socialist ideology[1] into your stream with this follow. Might get a bit grating if that's not your politics, your family is currently fleeing Venezuela, you don't enjoy irony in the contrast with her interleaving pictures of her expensive toys and housekeeper-maintained upper-class London apartments paid for by her FinTech job, etc. (inb4 "there's no such thing as ethical consumption under capitalism").

[1]: Unfortunately this is pretty common in PL Twitter and is a downside to the "influenced by academia" notion you bring up (https://theotherlifenow.com/occupations-and-their-ideologies...)

Re:Advice for Haskell beginners (2017) by dang on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:42PM (#17822903)
Please follow the site guidelines in cases like this. There's a reason they ask you not to introduce extraneous flamebait.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Advice for Haskell beginners (2017) by KirinDave on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @02:51PM (#17820972)
These kinds of comments are why I was very careful to pick who I was mentioning. Bodil is a very public figure and more than capable of taking care of herself. Hopefully, I (and more importantly she) won't regret that decision.

But anytime you make a list of "here are people who are helpful and won't demand much but courtesy in return" in the Haskell community folks like you pop up demanding I mention your favorite guy like he's relevant or necessary. Go write your own list if you want your gab.ai fp follow list.

Re:Advice for Haskell beginners (2017) by ad_hominem on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @03:37PM (#17821395)
I think otherwise your list is great. And I think if you're of a similar political persuasion as her, Bodil's a good choice as well. I enjoyed her content for a time but the constant drip of misandry and political hypocrisy got to me after a while. YMMV, maybe I'm just fragile.

I don't have a "gab.ai fp follow list" because I don't like mixing politics with programming precisely because it devolves into the kind of tribalism on display here.

I'm sorry you took offense to "these kinds of comments" but I don't see how you're entitled to put Tony Morris on blast for your experiences but I can't share my own (admittedly passive) experience with Bodil?

Re:Advice for Haskell beginners (2017) by KirinDave on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @03:52PM (#17821536)
For someone who doesn't like to mix politics and tech, you're the singular voice having that conversation here while everyone else seems indifferent. Maybe you do actually like to do it.

Perhaps follow your own claimed ethics and don't pollute this conversation with politics? It's not like my list wasn't quite diverse in the political spectrum.

Re:Advice for Haskell beginners (2017) by ad_hominem on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:22PM (#17821824)
I also don't like hearing about religion while I'm trying to listen about programming - guess that makes me a religious person too?
Re:Advice for Haskell beginners (2017) by KirinDave on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:55PM (#17822571)
Why are you bringing it up then?

I'm doing my best to avoid concrete assertions about your personality or preferences. But I can't help but notice that you're acting in a manner contrary to your stated preferences.