News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Really? Windows Phone 7 Commercials by tptacek on Monday October 11, 2010 @07:20PM (#1781693)
This would be interesting if it meant that Microsoft was positioning Phone - As - Peripheral against Apple's Phone - As - Platform. But they aren't; look at their marketing material and they're triangulating and trying to have it both ways, getting you "in and out" when you want to be "in and out" but being "immersive" when that's what you want.

Telling: this ad doesn't really show the product.

Re:Really? Windows Phone 7 Commercials by hammerdr on Monday October 11, 2010 @11:58PM (#1782263)
Not showing the product is not an unheard of marketing technique. Nike is famous for this. There are also other examples such as Wonderbra and Kellog's. http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/05/business/media/05adco.html...

If I had to guess, the WP7 ads deliberately minimize the product itself. The subtext here is that WP7 is not a robot that controls your life or a walled garden from which you cannot escape. Instead, it is a seamless extension of you.

I like the adverts. We'll have to see whether Microsoft takes the spirit of their advertising into their software.

Re:Really? Windows Phone 7 Commercials by potatolicious on Tuesday October 12, 2010 @12:37AM (#1782328)
All 3 of the above examples are (for the most part) commodity products being sold by existing market leaders.

Which is to say, everyone already knows about Nikes, Kellogs, and Wonderbra - raising the brand awareness to a level that transcends the commodity nature of the product (not just "a pair of runners") is the task at hand.

It may not be the best marketing position for a product playing catchup, where public awareness is very poor, and the whole "mobile OS" product is not at all commoditized at this point (though Android is trying, I suppose).

Re:Really? Windows Phone 7 Commercials by bruceboughton on Tuesday October 12, 2010 @05:19AM (#1782790)
I guess part of the problem is there isn't just one clear product (as with iPhone). There are 10.