News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Flatpak 1.0 Released, Ready for Prime Time by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Monday August 20, 2018 @09:52AM (#17799845)
> The split between package vendor and package maintainer has classically been the primary reason for malware being rare on Linux.

It's also one of the reasons users and proprietary software have been rare on Linux.

Re:Flatpak 1.0 Released, Ready for Prime Time by dec0dedab0de on Monday August 20, 2018 @09:56AM (#17799877)
> The split between package vendor and package maintainer has classically been the primary reason for malware being rare on Linux.

It's also one of the reasons users and proprietary software have been rare on Linux.

It may be why proprietary software is lagging, but I think most users prefer an OS level package manager. They just didn't know about them until the Appstore.

Re:Flatpak 1.0 Released, Ready for Prime Time by digi_owl on Monday August 20, 2018 @01:16PM (#17801772)
IMO proprietary lags way more because you do not know if your chosen framework (unless it is Qt, heh) will function 5-10 years down the line with minimal investment in updates.

The Linux kernel is everywhere thanks to Torvalds (overly late in the opinions of some BSD devs) declaring the API/ABI sacrosanct, and holding the other kernel developers to that (much to the chagrin of some that want to do hail mary changes for sake of security or ego).

But the userspace above had been reimplemented again and again because the various libs and such are fundamentally unstable. In far too many cases you can even do a x.y.z+1 update without getting some kind of breakage.

Often because someone decided that spec adherence was more important than real life stability, and thus pushed a patch through that altered the API behavior to be more in line with a spec that nobody had complained about for a decade or more.

Re:Flatpak 1.0 Released, Ready for Prime Time by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Monday August 20, 2018 @10:03AM (#17799937)
Which is why everyone loves the Windows Appstore and uses it exclusively.

The Appstore works on phones and tablets because they are primarily consumption-only devices, and because users are not given any other choice (also, the installer/uninstaller model has a lot of its own suck). I don't know about you, but that's not what I want out of personal computing.

Re:Flatpak 1.0 Released, Ready for Prime Time by TingPing on Monday August 20, 2018 @10:54AM (#17800420)
Most complaints about the appstore revolve around things like it being slow, clunky, failing to work, being designed around DRM, forbidding win32 early on, etc.

Nobody is complaining that applications are in a central location.

Re:Flatpak 1.0 Released, Ready for Prime Time by blacksmith_tb on Monday August 20, 2018 @03:09PM (#17802891)
I am assuming that's sarcasm when it comes to Win10, but 'exclusively using the app store' comes closer to the truth for non-dev macOS users, at least that's my impression.
Re:Flatpak 1.0 Released, Ready for Prime Time by deadbunny on Monday August 20, 2018 @09:57AM (#17799881)
Strange. I have a whole load of proprietary software on my laptop, all installed via native packages.
Re:Flatpak 1.0 Released, Ready for Prime Time by ynniv on Monday August 20, 2018 @10:29AM (#17800163)
The packaging system has very little to do with user adoption of a more complicated interface, or the success of proprietary software in a purposely open system. From the user's standpoint, package management on Linux is usually just hitting the "update" or "install" buttons.

Edit: I have no idea why you think this is condescending.

Re:Flatpak 1.0 Released, Ready for Prime Time by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Monday August 20, 2018 @10:38AM (#17800247)
It's this kind of condescending attitude towards users that keeps Linux a non-option for people. What happens when a user wants to install something that isn't in the repo? Or do you just imagine that "average users" don't do that (and that no one else matters)?

Edit response: It is condescending because it imagines the user is incapable or uninterested in the way their system actually works, as a mere pusher of buttons to make the blinkenlights go. Sure, some users are like that, but largely it is a convenient excuse to dismiss criticism.

Re:Flatpak 1.0 Released, Ready for Prime Time by xorcist on Monday August 20, 2018 @10:53AM (#17800414)
Everything you say is completely applicable to Android as well, and it's not clear how that is making the platform a non-option for people. Very few people installs third party packages.

The market share of any PC desktop operating system has mostly to do with the type of office work that took place in the 90s, when computers took over.

That's slowly changing as the web is taking over, and Chromebooks, Android, Mac, and "regular" Linux desktops becomes a viable platform for sharing your work with others.

Re:Flatpak 1.0 Released, Ready for Prime Time by shittyadmin on Monday August 20, 2018 @11:57AM (#17800990)
On Android, software developers package applications and push directly to the repo - no 3rd party is involved for a packaging step. Developers have a high degree of control in the application's packaging.
Re:Flatpak 1.0 Released, Ready for Prime Time by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Monday August 20, 2018 @10:59AM (#17800472)
> Everything you say is completely applicable to Android as well, and it's not clear how that is making the platform a non-option for people. Very few people installs third party packages.

Consider that the usecase for a personal desktop computer may be different from that of a smartphone or tablet. There's more to personal computing than a web browser.

Re:Flatpak 1.0 Released, Ready for Prime Time by xorcist on Monday August 20, 2018 @11:31AM (#17800760)
Right, but the Android comparison was meant as a counter example to how packages outside the main repository being difficult to install is somehow a deal breaker to ordinary users. It's not. Desktop computer market share is mainly due to historical reasons.

Of course an easier to use third party packing system would make the desktop easier to use, but that's not where the pain points are. (Especially since most third party binary packaged software is just something you unpack and run.)

Even the most easy to use packaging system you could imagine wouldn't impact the Linux desktop market share measurably.

Re:Flatpak 1.0 Released, Ready for Prime Time by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Monday August 20, 2018 @12:14PM (#17801165)
> Desktop computer market share is mainly due to historical reasons.

Historical reasons like it being an open platform that developers could target without the requirement of third party approval, among other strengths.

Re:Flatpak 1.0 Released, Ready for Prime Time by IshKebab on Monday August 20, 2018 @01:22PM (#17801825)
Android is very different. You only need to make one file for many different stores, and that file is pretty trivial to install even if it isn't in a store.

Linux doesn't have anything like that traditionally. You have to make a deb, rpm, whatever Gentoo uses, etc. And ./configure && make && make install is laughably unintuitive.

Re:Flatpak 1.0 Released, Ready for Prime Time by digi_owl on Monday August 20, 2018 @05:58PM (#17804382)
It depends. If you use the NDK you have to make sure you can build for both x86 and ARM (the play store will hand out the relevant variant silently).

Also, Google have done some serious work to ensure at least some backwards compatibility (and providing a support library, that i fail to recall the exact name of, for backporting various functionality).

While the FOSS world seems to lean on "compile it" along with "lacking resources" as an excuse for not maintaining anything more than incidental compatibility across releases.

Re:Flatpak 1.0 Released, Ready for Prime Time by ynniv on Monday August 20, 2018 @10:53AM (#17800413)
What problems does Flatpak solve from a user perspective? Assume the user is already using Ubuntu, and will download and run any shell script without a second thought.
Re:Flatpak 1.0 Released, Ready for Prime Time by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Monday August 20, 2018 @11:01AM (#17800497)
That shell script may not actually work because it makes assumptions about the structure of the underlying OS that may have changed 10 minutes ago on the arbitrary whim of a distro developer.

The installer/uninstaller paradigm is almost as bad as the package manager paradigm in my opinion.

Re:Flatpak 1.0 Released, Ready for Prime Time by Sir_Cmpwn on Monday August 20, 2018 @12:00PM (#17801021)
Good. Proprietary software doesn't belong on Linux, or anywhere else for that matter.