News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by coldtea on Sunday August 19, 2018 @03:29PM (#17795786)
>I am a Taiwanese millienial and I am deeply offended by this comment. Why would you say that the claim is understandable? ? Taiwan has been an independent democratic country with its own military, economy, culture, government, rules of law, and international relations for over 50 years.

Doesn't this answer your own question? 50 years are nothing in historical terms.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by NeedMoreTea on Sunday August 19, 2018 @03:37PM (#17795819)
Go back further and Taiwan was under Japanese occupation and the People's Republic of China didn't yet exist.

So if the short timescale discounts Taiwan shouldn't it also discount China?

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by coldtea on Sunday August 19, 2018 @06:01PM (#17796406)
Well, occupation shouldn't matter -- else Korea would be Japanese too.

The way I see it, PRC is just the current regime, China is the whole culture/nation. Tomorrow China might not be RPC, but China and Taiwan peoples will still have much longer historical ties.

It makes sense for Taiwanese people to want to have their own regime (after all the whole regime there was defined in opposition to the communist change in China), but it also makes sense for the mainland culture to consider them a part of their nation.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by skh on Sunday August 19, 2018 @05:17PM (#17796222)
I think the point is there are different perspectives that have some merit to them. Both sides have compelling points. But one thing is clear, the PRC have always considered Taiwan part of the China and currently they will not countenance a different view on the matter. Will the U.S. be vigilant enough for long enough so that Taiwan remains independent. Personally I’m skeptical that this is so.
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by NeedMoreTea on Sunday August 19, 2018 @05:46PM (#17796353)
Always seems quite a stretch. China didn't first invade Taiwan until 1700 or thereabouts. They've been outside China for the last 120 years or so. China even formally ceded the territory to Japan in 1896 after the first China-Japan war.

Of course what should matter is what the people of Taiwan want. Will the West provide enough response if it were needed? Sadly I suspect not.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by skh on Sunday August 19, 2018 @06:56PM (#17796669)
The PRC is younger than the ROC. The PRC, the government, have always considered Taiwan part of China. It’s in their constitution I believe.
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by neya on Sunday August 19, 2018 @03:32PM (#17795800)
By that logic, you could say the same for any country that has gotten its independence recently (say, Singapore)..
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by coldtea on Sunday August 19, 2018 @06:16PM (#17796477)
That logic applies in context though, not as a blind rule.

So, if those places had historical and cultural ties with other nations that go way back (like Chinese and Taiwanese people have), then yes, a recent split might not mean much for the legitimacy of a new country.

If those places were merely occupied for centuries/millennia and "gotten their independence" then no.

Heck, colonial powers designed and build states based on all kind of splits in existing peoples to "divide and conquer" them. Statehood comes and go, actual historical and national cultural ties are what's long lasting.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by cmurf on Sunday August 19, 2018 @03:48PM (#17795852)
China's current government is 69 years old. China and Taiwan governments are roughly the same age, arguably Taiwan is older by 2 year based on the earlier formation of its constitution, the government fled to Taiwan the same year the PRC was formed, 1949.
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by tsuabing on Sunday August 19, 2018 @03:35PM (#17795809)
what does that even mean??? South Korea was established in 1948. Estonia was established in 1991. The world recognizes these legitimate countries.

From your past comment histories, it is clear you are pro China in every sense of the word. Maybe you should reexamine your values and see why you are so supportive of a disgusting government.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by dang on Monday August 20, 2018 @06:09PM (#17804462)
Nationalistic flamewar is an abuse of HN and will get your account banned here. It doesn't help to create a throwaway account to do it, and in fact will eventually get your main account banned as well.

Your feelings are easy to understand, but HN is an international site and people have strong feelings on all sides of such questions. For HN to continue as a forum for thoughtful discussion, we all need to remain respectful. If you can't do that, please don't post here.

Creating an account and showing up in the threads gunslinging is not ok, and levelling personal accusations against another user for political or nationalistc reasons is a bannable offense.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by twblalock on Sunday August 19, 2018 @03:40PM (#17795828)
From your comments, it is clear you are pro China in every sense of the word. Maybe you should reexamine your values and see why you are so supportive of a disgusting government.

That's quite an overreaction, considering the person you are replying to did not mention China at all.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by coldtea on Sunday August 19, 2018 @06:06PM (#17796429)
>Maybe you should reexamine your values and see why you are so supportive of a disgusting government.

I'm not supporting any governments, I'm for supporting peoples and exposing hypocrisy.

I have my issues with the Chinese government (for their internal behavior to their people), but Chinese foreign policy ain't it.

People from places who actively invaded tens of countries that did nothing to theirs (and meddled with mine and others nearby), cry crocodile tears about China's horrible behavior -- the drop of tourism in some Pacific islands they have a beef with...

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by knuththetruth on Sunday August 19, 2018 @03:36PM (#17795812)
The British tried a similar narrative with the War of 1812, and we in America are still alive and kicking. I hope the same for Taiwan and their independence.
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by Naga on Sunday August 19, 2018 @04:54PM (#17796125)
If you remember, the United States declared war on Britain, not the other way around. Britain also arguably won the war since the result was status quo ante bellum, which is all that Britain wanted since they were at war with France at the same time for over a decade.
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by jonathankoren on Sunday August 19, 2018 @07:13PM (#17796749)
Are you Canadian?
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by coldtea on Sunday August 19, 2018 @06:18PM (#17796491)
Only the British and Americans weren't the same people (from a nationality perspective). Americans were merely British subjects -- from a hodge-podge of nationalities.

A split into two countries South / North post Civil War would be a better example.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by ardy42 on Sunday August 19, 2018 @08:14PM (#17796950)
> Only the British and Americans weren't the same people (from a nationality perspective). Americans were merely British subjects -- from a hodge-podge of nationalities.

That seems like a distinction without a difference for this topic.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by coldtea on Monday August 20, 2018 @05:55AM (#17798706)
It's only an inconsequential difference for people from not homogenous countries like the US. Peoples with cultural and historical ties with people in nearby nations do consider them extremely important.
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by ardy42 on Monday August 20, 2018 @09:38AM (#17799758)
I find it somewhat hard to believe that the United States' ethnic homogeneity (or lack thereof) has anything to do with the legitimacy of its independence from Britain (as reckoned in 1776 or anytime since).

It really seems like you're trying delegitimize the idea of Taiwanese independence by being extremely selective with the criteria you consider, to the point of introducing irrelevant ones to deter analogies that are favorable to it.

Yes, Taiwan is ethnically and culturally Chinese, but it's also a de-facto independent nation that's a prosperous democracy. If they want to subsume themselves into the PRC's Communist dictatorship, the decision should be up to the Taiwanese and the Taiwanese alone. If they chose independence, that choice is entirely legitimate, despite any ethic or cultural ties that may exist.

Similarly, if it's so important to the PRC that mainland China be politically united with Taiwan, they're also perfectly free to dissolve their government and place the mainland under the jurisdiction of the ROC.