News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Photo School by frostburg on Sunday August 19, 2018 @01:25PM (#17795209)
The APO part doesn't matter, but the flat field of focus of a macro lens might have relevant there given the subject.

Exotic gear only matters if your're trying to do something hard (for example big prints from 35mm film or extreme macro or high speed photography...) and I say this as a Contax/Leica/Hasselblad shooter/gear snob. Merely decent gear is important - smartphone pictures are universally awful when given a closer look.

Re:Photo School by jdietrich on Sunday August 19, 2018 @05:10PM (#17796193)
>smartphone pictures are universally awful when given a closer look.

A few years ago, I would have agreed with you. The latest generation of flagship phone cameras (iPhone 8, Pixel 2, Galaxy S9) are comparable in quality to a good compact camera. I really can't see much difference between a modern smartphone and an old favourite like the Powershot S120. You wouldn't want to make big prints, but you can get genuinely good images from a flagship smartphone, especially with a third-party app like Camera+ or ProCamera.

Re:Photo School by frostburg on Sunday August 19, 2018 @06:41PM (#17796598)
I have had "flagship" phones since 2007 or so, currently on a Note 8. I agree that some phones have acceptable resolution in optimal light for small prints, but basically everything else about the image is still bad: character of the out of focus areas (with -exceptionally- ugly results when using double camera setups to simulate a narrow depth of field), out-of-focus to in-focus transitions, noise structure, tonal smoothness, color reproduction, dynamic range, avoidance of the rolling shutter effect, ghosts, flares, coma... I could go on for a while.

Oh, right, the most important thing: almost everyone shoots portraits with smartphone cameras, which are too wide to give a flattering perspective (yes, even the 50mm equivalent "telephotos", which are also even worse cameras technically).

Re:Photo School by lmilcin on Sunday August 19, 2018 @06:34PM (#17796554)
Smartphone cameras are excellent quality. The pictures are bad because statistical user is a person who never tried to become better photographer. There is A LOT of excellent smartphone photos, they are just being drowned in deluge of random photos.
Re:Photo School by frostburg on Sunday August 19, 2018 @06:42PM (#17796601)
I'm not in any way implying bad faith here, but have you ever used a good camera?
Re:Photo School by lmilcin on Sunday August 19, 2018 @06:52PM (#17796649)
Depends what you call good camera. For the past couple of years I have been using Nikon D600 with Nikkor 17-35 f2.8, Nikkor 70-200 f2.8 VRII and Nikkor 50 f1.4 as my workhorse.

Camera doesn't mean much. I give my camera to random people and guess what, I get random photos exactly as if they were done with a smartphone.

It is not the camera, it is the photographer that takes the picture. The picture is the light field that was present at the moment of taking it -- your job as a photographer is to create or find an interesting light field and the camera is just technical means of preserving it. CAMERA WILL NOT MAKE YOUR PHOTO INTERESTING.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NGsmVw4tCWY

Re:Photo School by frostburg on Sunday August 19, 2018 @07:04PM (#17796705)
That's some very good practical gear. My inner snob would say that the 50/1.4 is no Summicron, that I would rather use a 135/2 Apo-Sonnar than the (actually not cheaper) 70-200 and that retrofocus wide angles meant to work well with digital sensors are inferior in the more rarefied markers of image quality to non-telecentric designs like the biogons, hologons and super-angulons of old. This doesn't matter, you probably know that you cannot obtain the same results from a smartphone camera (which doesn't mean that one cannot take an artistically valid picture with a phone, it's just going to be technically inferior).

We're not talking about bad photographers here, we're talking about someone that knows what he's doing trying to use a smartphone camera seriously. All the skill and knowledge can't do much against rolling shutter or banding in gradients that should be smooth, etc.

Re:Photo School by lmilcin on Sunday August 19, 2018 @07:25PM (#17796791)
Part of making good picture is knowing limitations of your gear.

My first camera I used when I started this hobby was Fuji X100. This has a lot of limitations. Extremely slow focus, fixed 35mm (equivalent) f2.0 lens. This forced me to study its limitations and what I can get with it.

I have quickly learned, it's not about being able to do everything, it is about being able to do something, very well.

Re:Photo School by rangibaby on Monday August 20, 2018 @01:52AM (#17797965)
35mm f/2 should be a very good lens.

In my experience the main limiting factors of smartphone are the tiny sensor size (noisy, low DR). Image processing keeps getting better but there are physical limits to what can be squeezed out of a given sensor.

If smartphones could trigger flashes at reasonable shutter speed (I guess 1/125 or 1/250) I could see myself using one to take real photos in an emergency.

There are also different definitions of what good gear is. I have several 40-60 year old lenses that are excellent for studio and street photography, but people who want edge to edge sharpness (blah blah blah) would probably laugh at them.

Re:Photo School by microcolonel on Sunday August 19, 2018 @03:50PM (#17795862)
> ...smartphone pictures are universally awful when given a closer look.

Which is another way of saying: smartphones tend to take pictures which are acceptable or good under a smaller set of viewing conditions than pictures taken by a skilled photographer operating an optically/electronically advantaged camera in equivalent circumstances.

Re:Photo School by frostburg on Sunday August 19, 2018 @03:55PM (#17795881)
No, you don't need something very advanced. You can take better pictures with consumer film cameras from the forties. The issue with smartphone pictures is that digital sensors cannot be made that small with good results yet; dynamic range is garbage especially if you move from base iso (which is often 32 or so) and even in optimal circumstances forcing your phone to take a correct exposure is generally very frustrating even with "manual" modes.
Re:Photo School by microcolonel on Sunday August 19, 2018 @07:30PM (#17796809)
> You can take better pictures with consumer film cameras from the forties.

That's not exactly a fair comparison. In a film camera, you're essentially replacing the "sensor" every time you add a new roll. '40s film (largely) has terrible dynamic range (far worse than an upmarket smartphone camera), is incredibly noisy under conditions smartphones can handle gracefully. Color film compatible with common cameras had only existed since 1930, and it remained disappointing well into the '70s.

Re:Photo School by jacobush on Sunday August 19, 2018 @07:48PM (#17796868)
People tend to forget that say, Kodak Portra 400 is a technological marvel and pretty recent too. (2010)