News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:HTC Willfully Violates the GPL in T-Mobile's New G2 Andro... by jrockway on Monday October 11, 2010 @07:48AM (#1779429)
The same is true of bookshelves, cordless drills, computers, and anything else that people can buy. Someone will always find a way to fuck up the assembly, modifications, or general use. But there is no EULA on my bookshelf saying I can't modify it.

So why are mobile phones different?

(My guess: "because we can". Nobody has figured out how to make a bookshelf that I can't put something too heavy on. But people have figured out how to ensure I can only run Verizon's adware on my phone, so they don't cripple my bookshelf but they do cripple my phone. Follow up question: why does the market allow this? Nobody would buy a crippled bookshelf with an EULA.)

Re:HTC Willfully Violates the GPL in T-Mobile's New G2 Andro... by Pyrodogg on Monday October 11, 2010 @10:24AM (#1779793)
Before and at the time of purchase most people don't think about the EULA or it's consequences. It's merely part of the shrink wrap that needs to be removed to enjoy the shiny new product.

Perhaps if it were something consequential instead of something to click through it would actually affect peoples habits.

Re:HTC Willfully Violates the GPL in T-Mobile's New G2 Andro... by sbov on Monday October 11, 2010 @01:34PM (#1780441)
Most EULAs are atrocious. I shouldn't need to hire a lawyer to buy a consumer product.

The people making these products probably don't want them heavily enforced either. If things actually got to that point nobody would buy their products.

I think they like the current status: you technically owe them your first born but still buy their products. If you do anything they don't like, they can stop you. But people still buy their stuff. Its the best of both worlds for them.

Re:HTC Willfully Violates the GPL in T-Mobile's New G2 Andro... by Pyrodogg on Monday October 11, 2010 @01:54PM (#1780522)
"The people making these products probably don't want them heavily enforced either. If things actually got to that point nobody would buy their products."

That's exactly my point. There currently isn't anything that forces the consumer realize what they are getting themselves into. If they did, they probably wouldn't be buying the products.

Re:HTC Willfully Violates the GPL in T-Mobile's New G2 Andro... by Jach on Monday October 11, 2010 @08:31AM (#1779500)
Is your follow-up question rhetorical? Nevertheless: the market isn't rational. Plus people are used to skipping over EULAs and not reading contracts. Plus the people that actually care are a minority. Etc. etc.