Re:Running C++ code from C# Dotnet Core
by HippoBaro on Friday August 17, 2018 @06:05PM
(#17785791)
This is arguably not C++ interoperability, but C interop. Big difference there. The author conveniently doesn't show how to pass parameters (especially non-POCO objects), for example.
Re:Running C++ code from C# Dotnet Core
by snarfy on Friday August 17, 2018 @06:33PM
(#17785890)
Yeah, I saw the title and was excited, then I saw
#ifdef __cplusplus
extern "C" {
#endif
This makes it C interop.
If it were C++ interop, I would be able to DllImport a C++ library (without the C linkage) and get a C# wrapper class of the C++ classes automatically.
It's not C#'s fault. C++ is the one without an ABI. To properly DllImport C++ you would need to define the so/dll name in the import and also the specific C++ compiler version and build, since the binary changes underneath, e.g. foo.msvc_x64_debug.dll, foo.gcc_x86_release.dll, etc. Then C# might have a chance of importing a c++ library, but not today.
Re:Running C++ code from C# Dotnet Core
by sebazzz on Saturday August 18, 2018 @01:40AM
(#17787048)
> If it were C++ interop, I would be able to DllImport a C++ library (without the C linkage) and get a C# wrapper class of the C++ classes automatically.
If you count COM as being C++, it would be possible.
Re:Running C++ code from C# Dotnet Core
by zamalek on Saturday August 18, 2018 @02:00AM
(#17787109)
I studied calling conventions too long ago, but wasn't ECX (registers and then stack, in general) stdcall on Windows? I could stand to absolute correction there, just curious.
If it were C++ interop, I would be able to DllImport a C++ library (without the C linkage) and get a C# wrapper class of the C++ classes automatically.
It's not C#'s fault. C++ is the one without an ABI. To properly DllImport C++ you would need to define the so/dll name in the import and also the specific C++ compiler version and build, since the binary changes underneath, e.g. foo.msvc_x64_debug.dll, foo.gcc_x86_release.dll, etc. Then C# might have a chance of importing a c++ library, but not today.
If you count COM as being C++, it would be possible.
It should be theoretically be possible to call C++ via interop:
[0]: https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/cpp/cpp/thiscall