News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jack Dorsey says in an interview he's rethinking the core... by vkou on Friday August 17, 2018 @10:41AM (#17783130)
Without censorship, Twitter, like any online forum, quickly becomes unusable. Bots, commercial spam, non-commercial spam, users whose sole goal is to drive other users off the platform, extremist groups, et al, will happily take advantage of an unmoderated space. You don't get a thousand flowers blooming, you instead get a thousand Neanderthals with typewriters.

You're pretty much left with trying to determine the degree to which, and the content which you're willing to censor.

Re:Jack Dorsey says in an interview he's rethinking the core... by Proziam on Friday August 17, 2018 @10:49AM (#17783210)
I am conflicted with this because I fall on both sides of this particular fence.

On the one hand, I despise when platforms are over-run by people spouting ridiculous things and driving everything into heated discussions.

On the other hand, I place an extremely high value on individual freedom and feel that because platforms like Twitter are SO large and have SO much control over the public narrative that we can't allow the platform to start picking and choosing lest we end up with their version of the "truth" being the only available version.

I wish I were smart enough to know the answer to problems like this, but my current rationale is that these platforms should only be banning genuine bots and people spouting hate speech with genuine evil intent IE - "Hang XXX person because of YYY racist/sexist/garbage tier human being reason"

Re:Jack Dorsey says in an interview he's rethinking the core... by yifanl on Friday August 17, 2018 @10:55AM (#17783269)
The main issue is that it isn't possible to codify what is genuine evil intent as of yet (and perhaps, ever).

So until then, everyone has to choose between erring on too much or erring on too little.

Re:Jack Dorsey says in an interview he's rethinking the core... by vkou on Friday August 17, 2018 @11:02AM (#17783331)
> The main issue is that it isn't possible to codify what is genuine evil intent as of yet (and perhaps, ever).

It won't ever be possible. This is why, when faced with these questions, platforms set it as "What is considered acceptable by most people in my society" plus/minus some amount of leeway (Which is where the platforms vary). Both the amount of leeway, and the kind of leeway is, naturally, subjective.

Your newspaper's opinions column gives negative leeway. Running your own samizdat publication gives you a lot of positive leeway. Broadcasting through Twitter gives you something in between.

Re:Jack Dorsey says in an interview he's rethinking the core... by abnry on Friday August 17, 2018 @11:09AM (#17783381)
I think it's the retweets that are to blame for this. When you can act on your impulse with the simple click of a button, which in effect spreads misinformation or a negative attitude, then you have problem.

Twitter became successful because of the ease with which you can act out your impulses. At this point, to remain successful, I think they've got to reimagine the site to tone this down.

Re:Jack Dorsey says in an interview he's rethinking the core... by oblio on Friday August 17, 2018 @11:08AM (#17783376)
I've got no clue why you are being down voted. The problem is never censorship, it's lack of transparency while censoring. But censorship is necessary, for the same reason we take out the trash periodically: our house gets flooded with it if we don't.
Re:Jack Dorsey says in an interview he's rethinking the core... by mikeash on Friday August 17, 2018 @10:48AM (#17783201)
Yes, people keep acting like this is new and the internet was a complete free-for-all before, but it wasn’t, not even close. In the early days, anything commercial was out of bounds. More recently, most mainstream platforms disallow things like images of people’s genitals or unauthorized reproductions of copyrighted works. This is a minor adjustment to the details, not some big change.