Exponential growth will ultimately trump all other linear factors, even if the exponent is small. And that's also what makes small differences in that exponent so important (hence why computer scientists go through great pains to reduce complexity of matrix operations from O(2^2.51) to O(2^2.36)). Even if the investment only earned 1% per year, he can just sock it away in a 100-year trust fund:
>>> 1000 * (1.01 ** 100)
2704.8138294215287
>>> 523 * (1.005 ** 100) * .45
387.54342961962465
BAM - 85% "marginal" tax rate.Plus, he has deliberately framed his scenario to take the maximum hit from taxes at every step. Corporate tax eats into his dividends? OK - invest in a growth stock instead of an income stock, and pay capital gains taxes when realizing the profits instead. Estate taxes steal most of the money from his heirs? How about he write a check to the university on behalf of his grandkids -- Uncle Sam won't see a dime of that.
A less comprehensible explanation is available from the IRS here: http://www.irs.gov/businesses/small/article/0,,id=108139,00....
But I think you probably mean mikeryan. I don't think he was talking about a marginal dollar. His point was that the first $12k ($13k in 2010) gifted are taxed differently than dollars beyond that threshold.
I suppose the real question is the relative importance of the behavior at the margin versus the behavior for the first dollar. For the ultra-rich, $13k is obviously irrelevant, but for someone near the $250k annual income threshold like Mankiw, I don't think it is. The present value of $12k per year given every year for 30 years is substantially larger than the same amount invested and then hit by estate tax at year 30.
Not a good way to rid yourself of millions, obviously.
None are as populous, large, and diverse as the US -- so each may have an easier time (politically and operationally) centralizing and nationalizing services with consensus support.
But alternatively, why wouldn't we be getting economies of scale which make an equally high tax burden (as a percentage of GDP, which is the measure you seem to be using) unnecessary?
Also, the US is on average wealthier than many of those countries. Why wouldn't tax-funded goods and services -- being as they are for the benefit of people of all incomes -- be inferior goods, whose proportion of income should decrease as a consumer -- in this case, the nation -- becomes richer? We have a lower 'food burden', as a percentage of national income, than many countries -- yet few would argue we must increase that number for our national benefit.
The times of strong growth and high taxes occurred post-WW2, when the US had an uniquely unassailable competitive position, and much of the rest of the world had ludicrously high taxes, too. The whole world moved away from those peak rates; implying we could today have the same "unprecedented" world-beating export economy of the 50s/60s with similar ~70-90% top marginal tax rates would be insane.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_tax_in_the_United_States...
As far as Canada is concerned, this statement is false in certain cases. For example, the small business (income < 0.5 mln) corporation tax rate here in BC is 13.5%. This is combined state + federal, and will go down to 12.5% in 2011. The corresponding rate for the US is 40%, I believe.
Income taxes rates are also lower for certain income brackets. When they lowered taxes here a few years ago, the claim was that people making $90K/year face the lowest tax rates in North America. Here is a somewhat informative table of taxes paid for various income brackets: http://www.wolrigemahon.com/txrates.html.
Where the US makes up for lost ground though is through the myriad tax deductions that are sprinkled to various special interest groups, e.g. mortgage interest deductions, etc.
Of course, the bigger flaw with Mankiw's argument is that it evades the point of those taxes, which is that they buy things that our society has deemed worth having. It is not totally outside the bounds of reason to suggest that we'd have less entrepreneurship if every potential business owner had to worry about providing for 100% of their parents medical expenses.
We cannot have everything we want. At some point, the goal of having the "Happiest Possible Greg Mankiw" will have to give way to something like Wildland Fire Management.
It is less than honest to suggest that the tax increases we are discussing will be used for things like fire protection. The vast majority of government spending these days is not providing public goods. Police, fire, defense, the CDC and other public goods make up a relatively small portion of the budget.
For the most part, the extra money Mankiw pays will simply be redistributed to people less productive than him (federal bureaucrats, people capable of working but who don't wish to, corporations less productive than competitors/alternatives). If you wish to argue that those are useful purposes, be my guest.
However, the dominant component of "people capable of working but who don't wish to" is --- by my casual analysis (please correct me) --- retirees on social security. It's also dubious to suggest that if we drastically cut back on the social safety net that the entire entrepreneurial class would necessarily fare better; many of us[1] would have to redirect our efforts and risk tolerances to fund our parents retirement.
We probably agree more than we disagree on the subject of civil servant pensions.
I am willing to accept that there is no tax/spend scheme that is ever going to make me entirely comfortable (a single trip to the DMV illustrates this nicely) without rejecting entirely the idea that we should trade off some personal incentives for our collective well being.
[1] Not me, though.
It would not be necessary for young people to fund their parent's retirement, their parents would not necessarily need to retire. A large number of older people are capable of working, and the latest projections suggest that this trend will only increase in the future:
We likely agree on ratcheting up the retirement age.
This argument plays out like a chess endgame. Can we cut to the chase and acknowledge the tradeoff that's being made? At some level, we as a society are trading units of Mankiw happiness for units of peace of mind about retirement.
We certainly do it inefficiently, and, in particular, we drag alone a whole class of free riders who create a drag on the operation of our local and state governments. But even if we optimized all that away, the same fundamental response would apply to Mankiw's argument.
I am not simply pointing out that "taxes buy stuff" --- though that is also a valid point to make. I am saying that Mankiw ignores an offsetting form of incentive to work and (particularly) take risks: the well-being of our close relatives.
Again, it may very well be more than the claimed 90% tax rate. I also realize the professor has a vested interest (for several reasons) in knocking the tax cut expiration. But the United States tax system is complex beyond belief and I think any comparison with other countries is never simple.
Edit: Or higher than the 'real' tax rate if the professor is pushing the numbers in his favor (likely).
The "complexity" of the US tax system is orthogonal to the issue we're discussing.
Without doing the research to prove it
http://www.photius.com/rankings/tax_burden_country_ranks_200...You'll notice that US/NYC is 21 and US/IL (where I'm at) is 35. You should also notice that many of the >35 burdens have a large VAT/Sales Tax which has less impact on the top 1% of earners.
Again, I'm not an expert in these matters. And, in any giving country the professor may be paying more in taxes. However, to systematically dismiss the tax burden of the United States because we have a low income tax isn't taking the full picture into account.
This seems like the appropriate comparison to draw, since it's the metric Mankiw himself evokes.
"In effect, once the entire tax system is taken into account, my family's marginal tax rate is around 90%".
While continuing to point out that the US has a lower tax burden than Denmark, Sweden, Belgium, Italy, France, Austria, Finland, Norway, Hungary, Luxembourg, The Netherlands, The Czech Republic, Portugal, Germany, Iceland, the UK, Poland, New Zealand, Spain, Canada, Greece, Australia, Switzerland, Slovakia, Japan, and Ireland, and also pointing out that several of America's most unprecedented periods of economic growth occurred under significantly more onerous taxes than Mankiw faces in 2010, I concede that there is in fact a coherent narrative that he can construct in which a Harvard professor might turn down a speaking engagement because of the rollback of the Bush tax cuts. That's a price I'm willing to pay, but you'll have to make up your own mind.