The alternative to democracy is feudalism, which is basically what we have now. You might hold your nose and say "politics" or "populism" but this is how you as an employee can exercise power in the workplace.
I certainly prefer "populist execs vying for employee votes" to "brown nosing employees vying for exec favor".
>> you can change jobs
At the whim of the hiring managers and their bosses etc.
>> start your own business
At the whim of the financiers or by boostrapping yourself with the crumbs the capitalists leave to the working class.
>> move
In fact often one has to move away from one's home, community, and family to find work, because that's where the bosses decided to employ people.
>> do freelance work
Again at the whim of those who have money to pay for your services.
>> or not work at all
If you want to accept a severely reduced lifestyle with the dregs of an under-funded dehumanizing welfare state, designed to force people into employment.
I'm absolutely serious.
This is such laughable hyperbole that I have to wonder whether you work in a skilled profession or you're just another internet commentator. The only way you could think CEOs have absolute authority over you like a king would is if you have a psychological complex.
And how on earth would that be a valid counter argument? It's patently false! Companies _do not_ require shareholder or VC investment to exist. They require people to work at the company and produce a product ("product" being the most extended notion of a company's deliverable).
There's a pretty big difference. Shareholders/VC firms investing capital in them allows the company to expand faster or better allocate resources. They're helpful and make the system what it is, but they're pretty interchangeable from an abstract perspective, and corporations would still exist without them in some way shape or form - maybe different structures of ownership and liability, but they'd be there. Corporations could not, meanwhile, structurally exist as a thing or concept without the government's consent.
(side note: I acknowledge there is no world where the US decides corporations stop existing, and that in all practicality, such an event would probably not result in the actual dissolution of every single US based corporation, but I'm talking theoretically here to make a point - the Government's participation in a corporation's existence is fundamentally different from shareholder's)
> My initial reaction is I don't want to work under populist execs vying for employee votes; I think we get enough political speak from them as it is.
How is political pandering to shareholders (stock growth! dividends! profit!) fundamentally different from political pandering to workers (narrower wage gaps! livable working conditions! sick and vacation days!)? Additionally, working at one of the companies that (at least in word) tries to listen to and pander to its employees, it can be a positive, symbiotic relationship.
I think you're giving workers too little credit - most people understand fundamental economic realities, and that they're not going to get gold plated toilets, beer drinking fountains, and 7 figure entry level salaries (I'd use 6 figure entry level salaries.... but, well, that's already a thing in Silicon Valley, which in addition to the ridiculously nice working conditions many here benefit from, does quite a bit to throw the whole tone of many of these posts in pretty sharp relief =P). Mostly workers would probably just press corporations to redistribute a historically representative portion of profits to workers, improve working conditions in ways that make sense, and focus on the longer term. After all - workers will be there, ideally, 5-30ish years, while many shareholders are looking to pump the stock price as high as they can in the short term so they can jump ship before the decisions that lead to that point come home to roost.
I get what she's saying here but it's not exactly the cause. A counter-argument to this premise could take this line and re-write it as "American corporations exist only because shareholders/VC firms invested capital in them."
And while I don't disagree that CEO pay is nutso today I'm not convinced that employee-elected directors is the way to go. My initial reaction is I don't want to work under populist execs vying for employee votes; I think we get enough political speak from them as it is.