Re:When Security Compromises Security – The Caesars/Defcon d...
by dannyw on Tuesday August 14, 2018 @05:01AM
(#17756375)
We live in a sad world when hotel room searches are normal and accepted.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:When Security Compromises Security – The Caesars/Defcon d...
by pluma on Tuesday August 14, 2018 @05:43AM
(#17756521)
Careful with the "we". This is very much just an American thing.
Re:When Security Compromises Security – The Caesars/Defcon d...
by s3cur3 on Tuesday August 14, 2018 @06:00AM
(#17756582)
As an American, I would raise hell if a hotel owner searched my room for no reason.
Re:When Security Compromises Security – The Caesars/Defcon d...
by jsjohnst on Tuesday August 14, 2018 @09:36AM
(#17757726)
You are on their property. If you refuse, you’ll be forced to leave. Does that make what they did ethical, no, but it’s 100% within their legal rights. Same goes if I was a guest at your house, even if I was paying to stay there.
Re:When Security Compromises Security – The Caesars/Defcon d...
by ectospheno on Tuesday August 14, 2018 @10:11AM
(#17758051)
You'll find that once you accept payment for them staying there your rights are curtailed depending on which state you live in. Your blanket statement isn't even close to true in quite a few places inside the US.
Re:When Security Compromises Security – The Caesars/Defcon d...
by jsjohnst on Tuesday August 14, 2018 @11:56AM
(#17759071)
Citation needed
(I was stating my opinion, you are the one claiming I am factually wrong and not providing any proof, further a quick google search proves I was correct in my statement too based on reputable legal sites)
Re:When Security Compromises Security – The Caesars/Defcon d...
by ectospheno on Tuesday August 14, 2018 @02:27PM
(#17760560)
Sure. As I mentioned this varies by state. I'm not going to google all 50 states for you despite your apparent need for me to.
The original article was concerning Nevada I believe. Here is a link for Nevada. http://www.loving.lawyer/blog/2016/8/23/think-twice-before-k...
Again. This varies quite a bit by state.
Re:When Security Compromises Security – The Caesars/Defcon d...
by jsjohnst on Tuesday August 14, 2018 @06:27PM
(#17762465)
As I suspected and why I said citation needed, you went on an irrelevant tangent into tenancy law. How does that link negate anything I said? If I had said “I could force you to leave my home immediately”, yes, that link would sorta apply, but I didn’t (evicting you via the courts is “force you to leave”). The conversation is specifically around your right to privacy when staying at property you don’t own. Yes, fourth amendment would prevent the property owner from letting police in under many (but not all) circumstances, but there is virtually no law preventing them from “violating your privacy” entering at their will. The laws that do apply generally only dictate notice periods, and even in those cases they have exceptions for emergencies, which ensuring security when they feel there is a credible risk qualifies.
Again, shady as hell ethically what they did and how they did it, but still very legal.
Re:When Security Compromises Security – The Caesars/Defcon d...
by CaptSpify on Tuesday August 14, 2018 @10:49AM
(#17758418)
Just because it is legal does not mean I am not allowed to raise hell
Re:When Security Compromises Security – The Caesars/Defcon d...
by jsjohnst on Tuesday August 14, 2018 @11:55AM
(#17759059)
Of course, you are definitely right you can raise hell, but that doesn't mean my statement is wrong at all either.
Re:When Security Compromises Security – The Caesars/Defcon d...
by hybridsole on Tuesday August 14, 2018 @05:19AM
(#17756426)
They don't make any sense. Anyone planning something will now anticipate this. It only discourages honest people from staying in a traditional hotel. You can either relax in an air-bnb or worry about the hotel service demanding entry to your room (while being reminded of horrific mass shootings).
Re:When Security Compromises Security – The Caesars/Defcon d...
by Cthulhu_ on Tuesday August 14, 2018 @05:52AM
(#17756547)
You're trying to make it sound like AirBnB would be a better option, but just no. A hotel has accountability at least. AirBnB as an organization has and takes none, and you have to deal with the individual and their house yourself. A hotel chain has their reputation to maintain, a random guy renting out his apartment doesn't.
Re:When Security Compromises Security – The Caesars/Defcon d...
by Kliment on Tuesday August 14, 2018 @05:58AM
(#17756575)
That's true but the sad thing is that random people renting out their apartments are, in practice, more accountable via airbnb reviews than a major hotel chain who can implement an evil policy like this across their properties and do a lot of damage before it's reined in.
Re:When Security Compromises Security – The Caesars/Defcon d...
by fbender on Tuesday August 14, 2018 @07:11AM
(#17756853)
I can imagine a (three-letter-agency) renting out places on AirBnB and the likes and wait for a fish to be caught in the net. Esp. in Vegas if only for gambling-related fraud (initially, at least).
Re:When Security Compromises Security – The Caesars/Defcon d...
by Kliment on Tuesday August 14, 2018 @01:31PM
(#17759972)
Why rent out apartments at immense cost and hope someone gets caught when you can dragnet hundreds in a hotel?
Re:When Security Compromises Security – The Caesars/Defcon d...
by trevyn on Tuesday August 14, 2018 @05:58AM
(#17756569)
Most Airbnb hosts seem to care about their review history.
Re:When Security Compromises Security – The Caesars/Defcon d...
by repler on Tuesday August 14, 2018 @06:35AM
(#17756705)
Agreed, but also - it's private property and most likely a contract was signed at hotel checkin that permitted it legally.
Re:When Security Compromises Security – The Caesars/Defcon d...
by Cthulhu_ on Tuesday August 14, 2018 @05:53AM
(#17756551)
Where did you get the notion that it's normal and accepted? Have you read the article? Have you even read the title? "Debacle" does not mean the same as "normal and accepted".
Re:When Security Compromises Security – The Caesars/Defcon d...
by tedunangst on Tuesday August 14, 2018 @12:04PM
(#17759142)
Same comment every time anything happens. "I can't believe this is allowed." As if disallowed things never happen.