"I don't want government to operate effectively because to do so would ruin my ideological minarchism"
and
"I don't want government to operate effectively because I can profit from it operating less effectively"
are very friendly bedfellows indeed.
seems reasonable to me. otherwise you could "raise" taxes by eliminating deductions.
The number of deductions and credits is orthogonal to whether the IRS can save you the effort of collecting the information about what they think you owe.
> It’s no secret that the IRS and big spenders in Washington, D.C. want to socialize all tax preparation in America. The (ironically-named) IRS Office of Taxpayer Advocate has been pushing for IRS preparation of tax returns for years. There’s only one reason proponents want to do this—tax revenues. If the IRS invites a conflict of interest by adding “tax preparer” to its role as “tax collector,” it’s a near-certainty that everyone’s taxes will rise. In fact, higher tax revenues are a major selling point of mandatory IRS-prepared tax returns.
...
> More importantly, it directs the IRS that it “shall not compete with the private sector in providing these services to taxpayers, nor acquire, develop, or deploy enabling systems to duplicate or replace private tax preparation services.”
> Never again would taxpayers have to worry about the IRS filling out a Form 1040 for them against their will.
These are unserious people that shouldn't be anywhere near the halls of power.
https://www.atr.org/taxpayer-advocates-issue-joint-free-file...
The second quote is ridiculous -- it would mean the IRS shouldn't have a public facing free information site at all, that you should have to find someone else to tell you anything whatsoever about paying your taxes at all.
The third seems like a deliberate strawman -- all proposals would involve you needing to approve the IRS quote.
Unserious, indeed.
Because this is an actual problem for some people?
I don't know if getting rid of taxes entirely is really a goal for many of these people, but what you describe doesn't sound that unreasonable. Making paying taxes easier does sound like support for taxes, right? For example, if we didn't have payroll deduction, surely there would be more popular support for tax cuts.
Doesn’t mean that we wouldn’t have taxes, but we’d have a tight temporal and psychological link between what we pay and the selections we make at the ballot box.
Practically it would never happen so it's difficult to argue for other than on ideological grounds. I think we as a society would find out that a huge amount of the population would simply be incapable of budgeting even quarterly tax payments. The enforcement costs would be immense.
That's the temporal connection that needs to be made.
The idea that there is a whole host of politicians who want to increase taxes is ludicrous. No one campaigns on the basis of increasing taxes. Further, in most of the West, taxes have dropped dramatically over the past few decades. Most politicians campaign on (1) reducing taxes or (2) providing some benefits. The dishonest politicians campaigning on #2 are teh ones who claim you can increase benefits without increasing taxes (which is occasionally true but rarely). It's only the honest politicians campaigning on #2 who add that the benefit will indeed have to be paid for by higher taxes.
The politicians increasing taxes are the good guys because they're the only ones at least thinking about paying for benefits.
How does that fit into their logic?
What happens if all the taxes are abolished and there is no need for that business? Will they start lobbying for more tax or lobbying against the final cut? Or lobbying for an income report system with the tax component stripped out, basically building what would have helped in the first place?
Starving the beast is a major policy aim.
The radical anti-tax groups are so anti-tax that they see making it easier to pay taxes as support for taxes. So they want it to be difficult to pay taxes to make it easier for them to argue against taxes entirely.
The system is broken in so many places trying to approach it with any rationality gives you a headache.