To paraphrase Churchill - the American century is the worst form of global hegemony, except for all the others.
Personally, I would much rather have lived my life under the purview of the USA than the Soviet Union or China, simply because, despite its excesses and hamfisted anticommunist coups, it is a country with values that consider the individual to be of value as a matter of course.
But we are living in a different era: an era of enligntment, democracy and globalization, where multilateralism had a good chance to succeed.
The crime of the US is not that it has been worse than the past empires: it is that is has killed, for good and for a long time to come, one of the rare chances that we had of creating a world community with strong international institutions, government by the strength of the law and not the law of the strong.
For that reason you will not find much sympathy around the world.
I'm not sure how you'd envisage such a multilateral world developing naturally from the imperialist days of the Great Game.
That is the kind of US that we admire. But that US does sadly not exist anymore, and the world is awaking to that fact.
I just worry about what comes next - in my corner of the world, China is actively seeking influence, perhaps even dominance, and frankly, the values of China are so antithetical to the values of my country that the idea of a protectionist inward facing US scares me - because the EU certainly isn't about to project power and influence into an ocean that doesn't lap their shores. The EU, while I admire it, is very much all about Europe, and bugger the rest of the world. Or so it seems to this one very subjective Kiwi.
I’m asking what makes you think a more balanced world would have been better?
> Inequality in your homeland is rampant. What you call American Empire is known also by Globalization, and it seems that is not very popular in the US right now.
Yes. We believe the “American Empire” has been far too altruistic towards other nations and ignored its own people....
I don’t think that really helps your argument.
We believe that:
1) The US has been extremely egoistical, by more than making up for the losses it has endured on trade by manipulating the global economy through the use of its monopoly on the dollar. Also by plundering resources all around the world (see Irak war for example).
2) That the economic problems of the US are of its own making, by buying into the fantasy of the American dream and letting its politicians funnel all richess to the 1 percenters, while promising that the money will trickle down.
If you believe that France, or Germany, or any other members of the EU wouldn't have done the same had their currency become the global default by dint of being the largest economy on the world, you're kidding yourself.
1) In this context why does it matter what you believe?
America doesn’t need your permission to fight for fairer trade deals.
2) I don’t think you understand Americans or our problems.
A 10% increase in tax revenues by focusing on the uber-wealthy will not fix our structural problems.
We know you do not need permission, and even when you pretend to get it (Irak war), you do it by blatantly lying.
You will not sell to the world that your fight is fair though.
> A 10% increase in tax revenues by focusing on the uber-wealthy will not fix our structural problems.
Your structural problems are not our problem - that is, as long as you are being confrontational. The world can be convinced to be more sensitive to the US's issues if the US shows sensitivity for the world's issues.
You want a fairer trade? Great! Let's do that. Let's eliminate at the same time the dollar as a huge distorting factor.
I think you misunderstand the power imbalance.
The world needs to convince the US that it is fighting unfairly.
We spent over a trillion dollars on the Iraq war. We could handle a 1-2 trillion dollar trade war - who else can reliably say the same?
The same imbalance that strengthens your hand on trade (the huge trade deficit that the US has), is a big weakness regarding the dollar: the fact that the world has accumulated and keeps accumulating dollars could prove a big problem for the US once we decide your policies must be retaliated with actual measures.
For example, it does not make any sense for the EU to be unable to abide by a perfectly working international commitment (the agreement with Iran about non-proliferation, which has been positively audited internationally), just because we are unable to manage the flow of capitals when the US decides to block them. It would be in the interest of the EU to actively fight the prominence of the dollar.
Maybe if Trump starts talking about across the board 50% tariffs it might make sense.
I think the EU has far bigger structural problems to worry about.
You really think that the US has been too altruistic? From my perspective in the South Pacific ocean, that's a very odd statement.
Unless you're referring to the $50 billion of foreign aid per annum, but then that money is less than a tenth of what the US spends on the military - if you wanted to shift spending internally. I don't think the foreign aid is curtailing internal domestic spending, I think it's political ideologies. You guys could have vastly more accessible and available healthcare and social welfare if you so chose, but for political and ideological reasons, you choose not to. It does baffle me.
I certainly agree with you that the US century has been good for many people across the world, and vastly preferable to the alternatives, but I see very little altruism in America's activies and very much realpolitik.
However, it does help when the world's leading power with the most firepower also happens to be a nation where the individual is considered valuable, and freedom and democracy considered core traits, even if your own internal execution is somewhat lacking.
What I am saying is: "we could do much better, but the current course of action is bringing us to a much worse situation"
I wouldn’t call it realpolitik.
I think a lot of the decisions are based around a mix of altruism and ideology. It’s hard to seperate the two.
For example I would say Europeans and Americans have some fairly similar ideals overall. However, if something is bad for Europeans in the short term then they tend to avoid it.
I’d say the only exception is on European integration where they are driven by ideology.
> You guys could have vastly more accessible and available healthcare and social welfare if you so chose, but for political and ideological reasons, you choose not to.
Could we though? And with what trade-offs?
States have a lot of power in the US - so for example a state like California could implement its own single payer system and show the rest of the country how it is done.
Yep, you already pay the most for healthcare in the world, yet people are routinely bankrupted by medical issues.
> And with what trade-offs?
Health insurer and pharmaceutical company shareholders might get a lower dividend.
In NZ, we have (near) free healthcare available for all, but private health insurance and private hospitals still exist as an alternative for those who want them. We have far fewer economies of scale - our entire population is only slightly larger than the population of LA in a country larger than the UK - yet our healthcare costs impact our economy significantly less than they do yours.
I know that some of the world's best medical treatment can be sourced in the US - if you can afford it, or your insurance cover it. But I also know that we spend less on healthcare and live longer, and no-one ever goes bankrupt because of medical bills.
But I also know that a former President of the USA once recorded an LP (admittedly before he was President, 10 years after he co-starred in a film with a chimpanzee) explaining that socialised medicine was pretty much Communism and/or the devil, so yeah, I find your country a very strange beast.
Our government already spends as much on healthcare as many governments with socialized medicine.
If it was simple then we would already have it.
> We have far fewer economies of scale - our entire population is only slightly larger than the population of LA in a country larger than the UK
And that’s exactly why the push for socialized healthcare scares so many Americans.
Countries like NZ clearly demonstrate it can be done at the state level.
So left leaning states can implement it and over the course of 10-15 years they can prove to the other states it is a better system.
Instead they want to push it at the federal level exposing the entire country to the risk.
> Health insurer and pharmaceutical company shareholders might get a lower dividend.
I think it might result in a lot less R&D, less capable doctors, etc.
I don't understand that - why does it scare Americans that we do it cheaper despite having a more dispersed population?
Because if you can do it with a country of a few million then there is no reason for us to handle it at the federal level.
Doing it at the federal level is then a political attack on people that want a different system and have different beliefs.
Edit: heck, ask that to the Americans. Inequality in your homeland is rampant. What you call American Empire is known also by Globalization, and it seems that is not very popular in the US right now.
Anyway, that decission is not for the US to make, and I reckon the whole world would prefer a more balanced situation.